2011.07.04 State Closing Argument Rebuttal Thread
- Thread starter beach
- Start date
- Status
texaslb218
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2005
- Messages
- 1,331
- Reaction score
- 1,192
great point about agreement.
anb
New Member
- Joined
- Jun 1, 2011
- Messages
- 362
- Reaction score
- 0
I wish he wouldn't have just said for the jury to come up with whatever scenario they think happened. I know what he meant by it, but some may take it as the SA "came up" with the best scenario they could think of. Maybe I'm thinking too much into it.
TiaM
Calm and Watchful Now
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2010
- Messages
- 1,746
- Reaction score
- 0
She'd use her eyebrow pencil to draw over them....
rosepetal1065
Ive got splinters..in the windmills of my mind....
- Joined
- Oct 3, 2008
- Messages
- 1,695
- Reaction score
- 13
Really... more objections..it's a clown show from that table....shut your pieholes...sitting on hands now
Mendara
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 30, 2008
- Messages
- 4,035
- Reaction score
- 303
No impress him that his dad is a hero and found this missing child. Which is exactly what everyone was calling him when she was found. A hero.
Justin Tyme
New Member
- Joined
- Apr 27, 2010
- Messages
- 871
- Reaction score
- 1
ICA is appears to be angry.
Etiana
Truth fears nothing but concealment
- Joined
- Jun 15, 2011
- Messages
- 485
- Reaction score
- -4
apparently he is *oy*
strawberry
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Dec 31, 2009
- Messages
- 12,052
- Reaction score
- 2,727
JB thinks he's safe because he's behind JA but I saw HHJP looking his way when he was smirking.
Ricki
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Apr 9, 2010
- Messages
- 7,422
- Reaction score
- 1,198
Her face might freeze like that if she does not relax those facial muscles.
truthsleuth
New Member
- Joined
- Aug 5, 2008
- Messages
- 1,946
- Reaction score
- 9
Late for the rebuttal. Sorry.
They then tell you that when the police are searching that George doesn't tell them about the duct tape. If George is concocting an nefarious plan, what doesn't he tell the police from the very first day? the police take the item, which at the time they have no idea has anything to do with anything, at this point George Anthony takes him back and holds onto it for 4 months. just lets it sit there. Then in December when the body was found, the police find the can at the house. So what does this nefarious criminal do? he uses the tape to display posters? does any of this make sense? to assert that George Anthony uses the same tape on his posters to find his missing granddaughter doesn't make sense.George Anthony had absolutely no idea that that roll of duct tape had anything to do with the death of his granddaughter. Because he wasn't involved, just as he told you.
...
Counsel also says the crime scene was staged and RK is connected to the duct tape. Then he tells you that George is connected to the tape too? Counsel says the crime scene was staged. You will recall this is the photograph out there on Suburban Drive before anything was disturbed. The only thing that disturbed this scene is mother nature herself.
There is a 2 to 3 inch level of leaf litter surrounding the skull. There are lines going through everything. This scene is staged by mother nature and no one else. The body did not move for six months. The odd thing happened is some of the animals might've moved pieces of the body before was discovered.
Dr. Schultz, forensic anthropologist, showed how the grouping of the various bones indicate how the body was discovered disarticulated. the bones showed indications of animal activity. These bones were not scattered by RK. They were scattered by animals.
This photograph is a little closer to where the skull is. It is surrounded by the hair that has fallen directly on top of the head. It is pretty much evenly distributed around the skull.
The duct tape is partially covered by leaf litter. the tape actually goes around the head, the leaf litter partially covers the duct tape. It wrapped around the mandible. it didn't just get washed there by water. That's where Casey Anthony put it.
You can see in this photograph how fibers have been lifted away from the mandible. Strings from the tape actually go under the mandible. the tape was placed on her head before she decomposed.
The scene was not staged. It appears as it does due to the forces of nature. And any suggestion contrary is conclusively refuted by the evidence that we have. That you have heard. This crime scene was not staged. The tape was placed on Caylee's face the day that she died.
The state did not call RK in this case. Roy likes to spin a good yarn. but what Roy said he did on December 11 is true. We didn't put Roy on to tell you a story. Roy found the skull back in August and reported it three times. He said the heck with it, I'm over this, maybe it really wasn't a skull. But then he told his son I know the skull is. He thought it would impress the son. RK found the skull yes, but not the way he said he did. That doesn't make Roy a morally bankrupt individual.
The main charge here is murder in the first degree. Premeditated murder and felony murder. You need to decide in your own minds what happened. You need to know, the state must convince you beyond a reasonable doubt of either premeditated murder or felony murder. while you must all agree the state has proven the case beyond a reasonable doubt, you don't have to agree on whether it was premeditated or felony murder. Some may think it's one, some think it's the other.
They then tell you that when the police are searching that George doesn't tell them about the duct tape. If George is concocting an nefarious plan, what doesn't he tell the police from the very first day? the police take the item, which at the time they have no idea has anything to do with anything, at this point George Anthony takes him back and holds onto it for 4 months. just lets it sit there. Then in December when the body was found, the police find the can at the house. So what does this nefarious criminal do? he uses the tape to display posters? does any of this make sense? to assert that George Anthony uses the same tape on his posters to find his missing granddaughter doesn't make sense.George Anthony had absolutely no idea that that roll of duct tape had anything to do with the death of his granddaughter. Because he wasn't involved, just as he told you.
...
Counsel also says the crime scene was staged and RK is connected to the duct tape. Then he tells you that George is connected to the tape too? Counsel says the crime scene was staged. You will recall this is the photograph out there on Suburban Drive before anything was disturbed. The only thing that disturbed this scene is mother nature herself.
There is a 2 to 3 inch level of leaf litter surrounding the skull. There are lines going through everything. This scene is staged by mother nature and no one else. The body did not move for six months. The odd thing happened is some of the animals might've moved pieces of the body before was discovered.
Dr. Schultz, forensic anthropologist, showed how the grouping of the various bones indicate how the body was discovered disarticulated. the bones showed indications of animal activity. These bones were not scattered by RK. They were scattered by animals.
This photograph is a little closer to where the skull is. It is surrounded by the hair that has fallen directly on top of the head. It is pretty much evenly distributed around the skull.
The duct tape is partially covered by leaf litter. the tape actually goes around the head, the leaf litter partially covers the duct tape. It wrapped around the mandible. it didn't just get washed there by water. That's where Casey Anthony put it.
You can see in this photograph how fibers have been lifted away from the mandible. Strings from the tape actually go under the mandible. the tape was placed on her head before she decomposed.
The scene was not staged. It appears as it does due to the forces of nature. And any suggestion contrary is conclusively refuted by the evidence that we have. That you have heard. This crime scene was not staged. The tape was placed on Caylee's face the day that she died.
The state did not call RK in this case. Roy likes to spin a good yarn. but what Roy said he did on December 11 is true. We didn't put Roy on to tell you a story. Roy found the skull back in August and reported it three times. He said the heck with it, I'm over this, maybe it really wasn't a skull. But then he told his son I know the skull is. He thought it would impress the son. RK found the skull yes, but not the way he said he did. That doesn't make Roy a morally bankrupt individual.
The main charge here is murder in the first degree. Premeditated murder and felony murder. You need to decide in your own minds what happened. You need to know, the state must convince you beyond a reasonable doubt of either premeditated murder or felony murder. while you must all agree the state has proven the case beyond a reasonable doubt, you don't have to agree on whether it was premeditated or felony murder. Some may think it's one, some think it's the other.
daisy.faithfull
RIP Joey, Summer, Gianni & Joey Jr.
- Joined
- Feb 26, 2009
- Messages
- 3,113
- Reaction score
- 95
ICA and Jose B both look kinda like spoiled brats who can't understand why they are not getting their way. CM is a babysitter...
I wonder if JB is posting on Twitter or Myspace about JA being a big meanie!
I wonder if JB is posting on Twitter or Myspace about JA being a big meanie!
You too Baz!!
It seems like yesterday when you and I were stomping through the swamps together.
I have a sense of peace that we are watching the end of this terrible case together.
summerthyme
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2003
- Messages
- 3,056
- Reaction score
- 43
JA is doing a great job.
- Status