Hand drawn police sketches are *notoriously* inaccurate. Various sources give you different percentages of accuracy but omg. It is bad, as low as less than 10% of sketches are identifiable as the person they were trying to depict. The psychology of police sketches — and why they're usually wrongNeither of those sketches are a strong likeliness - you could have both images surrounding him and it still wouldn't be obvious.
There is no way I would have gone in to CVS and pointed him out with either drawing.
JMO
I have participated in a workshop where we got to try out the computer generated composites a few years back and actually, the majority of the group of non-trained participants were able to produce some amazingly similar composites. A shame it is not standard practice in the US yet (as far as I know).
Anyone remember the golden state killer sketches? Exactly. I wouldn't put too much weight on how much they match the person. At least one of them reasonably close to BG. IMO.