AL AL - J.B. Beasley, 17, & Tracie Hawlett, 17, Ozark, 31 July 1999 #1

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
I had a stressful day here....had to deal with the yahoos that made a mess of our new floors....they came back- with the store owner- told him that was the only way they were getting in my house again...sigh...its better but I hate dealing with things like that and Dh got called to work out of town today. Kitty was walking fine this morning so we didn't go. Then just now, she jumped from the top of the cat tree and is limping...I think we'll get her checked tomorrow morning to make sure there isn't a break. I will make sure we go by American towing and and check it out-discreetly of course! Kitty is used to traveling and will be fine in her kennel- it's large because she has traveled on trips with us and even has room for a small litter box.

I'm curious and hoping they might have an old vehicle of theirs parked in the back or something that I check on a possible logo on the door to compare with the newer one in Dime Detective's picture.
 
I was just looking back over my notes and this little tidbit caught my eye. From The Troy Messenger, "One Year Later, A Father Remembers," July 30, 2000:

At about the same time the girls were reported missing, J.B.’s car was found parked on a street in Ozark, about a block away from the Dale County hospital.

http://www.troymessenger.com/2000/07/30/one-year-later-a-father-remembers/

Could the car's proximity to the hospital be a clue?
 
Hey everyone. I am sorry but I haven't had a chance to contact LE yet. My 7 year old cut hrr leg really bad, so had to make a trip to the ER. I will try my best to do this tomorrow.
 
Hey everyone. I am sorry but I haven't had a chance to contact LE yet. My 7 year old cut hrr leg really bad, so had to make a trip to the ER. I will try my best to do this tomorrow.

She okay? Poor girl :getwell:
 
Can anyone come up with a theory about the hospital connection?

The only thing I can come up with is if they were flagged down by an employee and they trusted someone in a nurse/orderly/doc uniform.

Maybe the truck driver said he was having a heart attack so they told him to get in the back and they would drive him there??
IDK
 
Can anyone come up with a theory about the hospital connection?

The only thing I can come up with is if they were flagged down by an employee and they trusted someone in a nurse/orderly/doc uniform.

Maybe the truck driver said he was having a heart attack so they told him to get in the back and they would drive him there??
IDK

The only thing I can think of is if the perp was hurt really bad. He realized that he couldn't take the car with bodies in the back to the hospital, knowing he would be admitted while the cops were looking for it.
I say that someone (LE) should check admittance records from the hours of ?-? on the day the girls went missing.
 
Hospital theories could definitely be worth looking into. But right now, my number one hunch would be to find out what garage Barrentine worked at and finding out who else worked there at that time.
A retired murder cop once told me coincidences happen quite often. Two coincidences happen together from time to time. Three or more coincidences together and you better look deeper. 1) Barrentine worked at a garage 2) grease stain reportedly found in back seat 3) Suspicious truck that "could" be a tow truck on video for apparently no reason just hours before the girls demise

But LE surely would have travelled down this path... wouldn't they?
 
Can anyone come up with a theory about the hospital connection?

The only thing I can think of is if the perp was hurt really bad. He realized that he couldn't take the car with bodies in the back to the hospital, knowing he would be admitted while the cops were looking for it.
I say that someone (LE) should check admittance records from the hours of ?-? on the day the girls went missing.

Looking at a map, the car really was left just around the corner from the hospital. Here's a Google Earth screenshot; Point A is where the car was left and Point B is the Dale Medical Hospital:

8b1951c0-7f58-47db-b130-9394e62e8b43.jpg

The car was found on Herring Avenue 90 feet from James Street. It is approximately 0.2 miles from the car to the hospital. To walk from the location of the car to the hospital takes about five minutes, according to Google Maps.

Note the large parking lot on the east side of the hospital. I think it's interesting that this lot is on the near side of the hospital when approaching from the direction of Herring Avenue on James Street.

One of my two initial thoughts on a possible hospital connection was that the hospital would have a large parking lot. While likely far from packed at that time of night, there still would have been a fair number of vehicles parked in the lot. The hospital would have been one of the very few places open at that time of night in Ozark. A person walking up, getting into a car, and driving away would have been less conspicuous here than the parking lot of an establishment that was closed for the night. Like say, for example, the Big/Little Store.

Was the hospital parking lot a key location in the killer's getaway plan?

Did the killer have access to a vehicle that was parked at the hospital while he was with J.B. and Tracie? Did the killer work at the hospital?

My other thought was in line with jenstar's thinking:

Though the perp seems to have kept his distance during the commission of the crime, thus making it unlikely that one or both of the girls injured him — according to one MSM report, the girls when found showed "few signs of struggle" and it was never reported that DNA evidence was found, for instance, under the girls' fingernails — he still could've sustained an injury, possibly while leading or pursuing the girls through the same rough/wet/dark landscape behind the girls' wet pants, muddy shoes, and the scrape on Tracie's arm. Possibly he hurt his ankle or something along these lines. If injured and in pain, he might've driven the car with the bodies as close to the hospital as was comfortable, then hobbled the rest of the way to the ER.

I wholeheartedly agree with you, jenstar: admittance records should be checked for the night of July 31 and the early morning hours of August 1.
 
Great picture DD! I would really love to see this blown up to include the B/L store and possible crime scenes. Gives a really good perspective . First question that pops in my head is why that spot? Why not deeper into the woods? Easier access to hospital parking lot? Maybe. One thing is for sure, the perpetrator wanted to get bodies away from crime scene. Almost definitely a local. Remember, the perp got out of the car at this spot and fled. Either on foot or a waiting car. Where did he go from here?
 
Hospital theories could definitely be worth looking into. But right now, my number one hunch would be to find out what garage Ballantine worked at and finding out who else worked there at that time.
A retired murder cop once told me coincidences happen quite often. Two coincidences happen together from time to time. Three or more coincidences together and you better look deeper. 1) Bellardine worked at a garage 2) grease stain reportedly found in back seat 3) Suspicious truck that "could" be a tow truck on video for apparently no reason just hours before the girls demise

But LE surely would have travelled down this path... wouldn't they?

Good post, CoolJ. ITA, we definitely want to continue looking at this.

After all this time, Barrentine is still the closest the case has come to having a strong suspect who may have been involved to some degree. Although he was ruled out through DNA testing, I think it says a lot that LE has left a potential Barrentine connection somewhat open-ended by stating that he could still be arrested if further evidence should point to him.

Even more interesting is the grease stain. In my humble opinion, it's very likely the killer was in the car with the girls that night; the fact that the grease stain was found on the back seat on the driver's side is of particular interest as this is likely where the killer would've been sitting (directly behind J.B. — it is J.B. he seems to have focused on more than Tracie overall, and as the driver it is J.B. he would've been looking to control first and foremost) if/after he pulled a gun on the girls and entered the vehicle.

And then the fact that there appears to be some sort of identifying design on the passenger side door of the white pickup truck, which in my mind points to a business of some kind, makes the possible garage connection compelling.
 
Great picture DD! I would really love to see this blown up to include the B/L store and possible crime scenes. Gives a really good perspective.

KeyLocations.png

Counterclockwise from upper right:

  • The Big/Little Store. The last place the girls were seen alive.

  • Depot Lane. Possible murder site. Only a 30-second drive from the Big/Little Store. Intersection of Jones Street and Depot Lane (at very top of map) is near where LE searched for evidence.

  • Left turn onto Highway 123. If J.B. and Tracie made it past Depot Lane, they may have turned left here and headed south, toward the second (unknown) suspected murder site, where a witness reported hearing gunshots and screams that night.

  • Dale County Medical Hospital. Did the killer head here after leaving the car on Herring?

  • Herring Avenue. 30 yards from James Street, a five-minute walk from the hospital, J.B.'s car was discovered here.
 
I like the hospital parking lot as a possible location the killer walked to in order to retrieve his vehicle. If there is a hospital connection, this might be it.

Right now, like Cool J I am still seeing more of a garage connection. I really want to check out the American Towing location, but I am so busy with work that if we decide to make a vet run, most likely I should send DH.....A trip to Ozark means the entire morning or most of the afternoon gets taken up.I'm trying to meet a deadline.

Dime Detective, when you were taking pictures, by any chance were you already thinking in that direction and take a peek around when you took the picture of the front of the business?
 
DD. that's what I'm talking about! That picture puts it all into perspective for me. Chances are somewhere in there within that picture is the area the girls were made to walk (or possibly chased) that made their shoes muddy and pants wet. The story lies within That picture!
In a previous post someone brought up the south union garage. I noticed south union is within this area. Now this garage may have nothing to do with this case but looking through the facebook page there are some interesting pictures. Notably a white pick up. Also some other tow trucks with door logos and mirrors that look similar to our truck. Interesting if nothing else.
 
Also regarding the grease stain. Points towards someone being in the back seat. I think we need to think about the possibility that there was no cop impersonator or scenario where the girls car is flagged down somehow. It is a possibility that the perp snuck into the backseat while girls were out of the car at B/L store.
 
Just some random thoughts-

If the hospital parking lot was used to park their car, this makes me think more that this was a planned attack, for the killer(s) to have the forethought to park there ahead of time.

Why did they chose the DMC parking lot?

Were they out looking for a random victim? Did they have a victim in mind? Did they miss the connection with their intended victim and get the girls instead when they happened into Ozark lost? Or were the girls their intended victims all along? If so, that puts an entirely different spin on things.

It's just MOO that this is a crime of opportunity and that pretty much rules out the DMC theory, but for now, I won't entirely discount it.

I too, believe the proximty of all the locations on DD's map is important to the crime, as is the neighborhood in general. And the dump site. There was a reason it happened this way, even if the killer didn't plan it out to be so. It all came together for a reason.
 
Also regarding the grease stain. Points towards someone being in the back seat. I think we need to think about the possibility that there was no cop impersonator or scenario where the girls car is flagged down somehow. It is a possibility that the perp snuck into the backseat while girls were out of the car at B/L store.


Yes! And that points right back at the white truck with more than 1 person in it in the B/L parking lot.
 
J.B. and Tracie's case is making me crazy. I don't have anything productive to add, other than the hospital angle is a good one, worthy of exploring.

Outside the box, that's where I am at.

I do think that the DNA issue is a red herring.

I think it's possible the semen evidence is separate from the murder. Just possible.
 
But, the grease stain…if a person had grease on them unless they had just been, say, working on a car at a closed gas station and it hadn't time to soak in or wipe off elsewhere would it transfer enough to be a “stain”.

Not a swipe, not a smudge but a “stain”.

Wouldn't it have to be fresh grease? Like axle grease?

It just seems it would be from a impervious object in the backseat. Like a tire?

Although it is unlikely a tire was put in the backseat with an available trunk… unless the girls were already in the trunk and a tire needed to be transported to another location so the perps vehicle could be operational.

I’m fascinated by a really greasy gas station attendant [full service station & repair shop] I see from a traffic light everyday and his grease is soaked in, if you know what I mean. Were I to give him a ride I might expect at the most a faint dingy spot.


all imo
 
But, the grease stain…if a person had grease on them unless they had just been, say, working on a car at a closed gas station and it hadn't time to soak in or wipe off elsewhere would it transfer enough to be a “stain”.

Not a swipe, not a smudge but a “stain”.

Wouldn't it have to be fresh grease? Like axle grease?

It just seems it would be from a impervious object in the backseat. Like a tire?

Although it is unlikely a tire was put in the backseat with an available trunk… unless the girls were already in the trunk and a tire needed to be transported to another location so the perps vehicle could be operational.

I’m fascinated by a really greasy gas station attendant [full service station & repair shop] I see from a traffic light everyday and his grease is soaked in, if you know what I mean. Were I to give him a ride I might expect at the most a faint dingy spot.


all imo

My daddy was a mechanic. I grew up playing in his gas station. I think it's very possible grease could be transferred. I've seen mechanics run the gamut from covered in grease to not a speck showing. My current personal mechanic- he works at a dealership durung the day and his own shop evenings and weekends- he is so immaculate I've never seen one iota of grease on his hands nor in his shop- I don' know how he does it! But more often I've seen lots of grease! Also what if the person had it on his shoe and his shoe wason the seat? As in he was on his knees in the seat leaning forward?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
137
Guests online
339
Total visitors
476

Forum statistics

Threads
609,473
Messages
18,254,623
Members
234,662
Latest member
LikeCandy
Back
Top