I have FINALLY read through the entire 2 threads to get caught up. This whole situation makes me furious, and also sad for all victims of sexual abuse.
I am also sitting here torn, wondering who all deserves not only sympathy and compassion, but also blame.
Hear me out here - and please know I am NOT defending pedophilia or sexual molestation or how the Duggar's have chosen to "handle" this situation...I am still simply trying to understand and process this.
These people obviously have a very different set of beliefs and followings from what we, as a society, deem "normal" or "accepted", right? So...I wonder, do these girls, boys, etc. who WE deem as victims of this abuse really feel the same violations, shame, etc. that other victims do?
If you are raised from birth in a circle where X = Y and there is NO deviation from those beliefs, no questions asked, no other thoughts or feelings, do they "naturally" feel what others raised OUTSIDE of those beliefs feel?
As an example - Mr. CannotKeepHisHandsToHimself (stealing that because I can't stop laughing at the name LOL) touches a person in a private area. They have apparently been told - on some level - this is wrong. However, do they know WHY it's wrong? Because (as sick as this sounds) it may not FEEL bad. It may actually feel good. (God that makes me want to barf just typing it).
But, if they DO tell someone that this event happened, and Mom and/ or Dad say "Ok...thanks for letting us know, we will take care of it" - what's next? If Michelle and Jim Bob TRULY and HONESTLY believe that based on THEIR church, THEIR belifs, THEIR followings, they took the steps to handle the situation as THEIR prophet desires by the words of HIS teachings - do they even understand that what they did is wrong?
Are they "brainwashed" (I guess you could call it) enough that regardless of what the LAW states - they followed the protocol of THEIR scriptures. They went to elders, the went to law enforcement, they prayed etc. But maybe above all - in THEIR religion, beliefs, etc. they were told in scripture that protecting your own comes before what "outsiders" (the rest of society" have deemed The Law of the Land.
We ASSUME there is intentional deceit - that they are INTENTIONALLY deceiving the laws, INTENTIONALLY covering up this scandal with $$$ in their eyes, INTENTIONALLY etc....but what IF they are -for lack of a better word- too "blind" to know any better? Are their beliefs SO strong that "Laws of the sinners society be damned...this is how WE deal with a situation in the religion WE choose to follow"? That IF they choose to go the route of what the REST of us filthy sinners do, they are disobeying the word of their God...
Does that even make sense? They do everything else in their religion differently and more conservative than what society at large considers "normal" or "traditional". Why would handling a situation like this be any different?
I feel horrible for all of his victims - Anna as well. However (again) - she doesn't KNOW any different (or better). She has been raised from a baby to believe that God chooses your husband under the direction of her FATHER (who is apparently the protector of the family - by God's word). If her FATHER approved her marrying him and she prayed, etc. and wrote off any hesitation as just "normal nervousness" why WOULDN'T she blindly do what she's been told? SHE DOESN'T KNOW ANY BETTER!! And I mean this in the most literal terms. She LITERALLY does not know that there are options to say NO. Even if she DID feel any sort of hesitation - it's not because it's not right and God is telling her that - it's that God is asking her to be more open, more forgiving, more modest, more InsertWhateverShortcomingsSheMayHave.
It's sick and twisted - that's for sure. But I seriously have NO understanding of why they believe what they do. But again, I wasn't RAISED that way. I don't always do what I'm told. I argue with my husband. We (as the rest of society at large) consider that NORMAL. That I have just as much of a say as he. I don't live in a world where my voice has no authority. But if you were RAISED to believe that your only job on earth was to put out, make babies and shut up - would I really feel that I was DESERVING of sympathy when someone violated me?
I hope I'm making sense...I feel like I just rambled, but I just can't put into words what I'm trying to say. I guess to summarize - WE know it's wrong, because that's what WE have been raised to KNOW. But when you aren't raised from birth in our world - do you even KNOW that things SHOULD be handled differently than they are? Maybe they all HONESTLY feel that what Josh did had been "resolved" (per their religious teachings and doctrine of how to handle situations) and don't understand why everyone else is up in arms about it. That we are all filthy sinners anyway - NOT following what they believe to be "The Words of God" - that OUR way of dealing with things is the WRONG way.
I really hope DHS steps in here - I really do. I hope that IF these kids don't know any better, that somehow, some way, someone can break their silence and teach them that the rest of the world isn't filled with hell bound, horrible people. That they CAN trust others outside of their religion and no harm will come their way.