mysteriew said:
I'm on the fence. There is so much information, controversial info, conflicting
'official' theory and conflicting unofficial theory that I just can't tell. I think it is possible, if they can disprove the alibi's that his family is giving him, I am likely to swing that he did it.
And things are not looking good for the family alibi's. The father insisting he was with them, the ex wife saying he was with her, nobody has any pictures and now the ex wife is slightly pulling back from it. Add that to the family selling the picture rights, and I just don't know how much I believe about the family alibis.
About the family....why would they sell the picture rights if they thought he was not guilty? I mean do they really think that anyone will want to make a movie of it if he is determinned to be a kook?
My take on it is that the family were clueless and they are caught up now in a maelstrom. They thought he was dead - he was their black sheep, their shame. Then he's arrested and all over the news. They automatically defend him when reporters call because otherwise they look bad. Then some showbiz agent types start calling and saying they can get good money to pay for his kids' college since he is going to be tried and possibly convicted. The family thinks about it and realizes they are in big trouble. At least if they have some kind of person who knows what he is doing helping them, telling them what to do, earning them money, then they can survive this. So they accept one of the first offers they get, quickly.
I tried to put myself in their place. This is not some normal All American, Leave it to Beaver family, but they don't want to be painted as a sick family that spawned a pedophile killer. I can give them credit for at least being normal people and not sick. The ones that are still alive are probably decent people, but there was known mental illness in the family, and John Karr is looking like a lunatic in the news...So they sign on the dotted line and hire the agent. They are trying to be rational and do the right thing.
The agent immediately starts talking to the media for them to stop them from stuttering and guessing about Xmas photos and stuff. I heard him on Inside Edition today. "The family believes he needs help." That kind of thing, kindly, concerned, but not admitting any guilt. I think this is standard and expected.
As long as there was no eyewitness to the murder and people still think there is not enough evidence to hang him, as long as no HARD evidence that places him in Boulder, they will keep on insisting he was in Atlanta or Alabama with them. Again this is so standard. Remember Karr himself was quoted as saying this is what families do. They will try to protect him. That doesn't prove they are right, just that they are trying to protect him.
Sorry but I can't forget Ted Bundy's sweet looking, frail, gentle, elderly mother saying he could not possibly have hurt anyone (and this is after he confessed and was executed). Family members sometimes have mental blocks about being able to believe their flesh and blood could have been a criminal. AS for Karr's insane mother, that would be a problem for them to deal with too, probably very hard for them, and they will be defending those allegations saying it was not her fault etc. etc. etc. and she got mental help, died tragically, but they are trying to get on with their lives and what about the children, they are doing the best they can to raise the boys to be normal, the abused wives have gotten on with their lives and they just want some peace, and of course, they will get some sympathy. And it's not about them anyway, it's about John Karr.
But whether or not Karr gets sympathy for being abused as a child, or is excoriated for causing a circus by making up his sick fantasies and never actually molesting or hurting anyone, he has got to be fully investigated and the family is just going to have to deal with it the best they can. If he is dangerous, other children will be kept safe if he is locked away as soon as possible. I leave a tiny opening of a chance that he is delusional and sick and didn't actually go to Boulder and kill JBR. But I am 99% sure he did, and he was smart enough to cover his tracks even with his family, for ten years. But the truth will come out soon enough, because if he was there, he DID leave evidence behind. I don't want the wrong person to be convicted. Of course I want it sorted out. But so far it's not just one or two things about this man that make him fit the profile of the killer. It's everything I've read about him and what he said, and his past....so I wait to see what the 50 page affidavit says.
Oh yes on Nancy Grace today they went into nonsense about the bracelet and how he knew about it; and the check stub and how he knew what drawer it was kept in. Please. As Nancy herself knew, the bracelet was in the autopsy, which is on the internet. Anyone could hazard a guess about a drawer. That is not something that would stir the police into action. These 2 pieces of information about the crime are not enough to arrest a man on. To even mention them as inside information is just stupid, and maybe they think the public is that dumb. Anyway, I am positive he either has actual souvenirs of the house, or knows things that were truly never printed anywhere, and thus no one like Karr would have been able to pick them up, not even by tricking Tracey into revealing inside information that he had, since Tracey wouldn't have it either.