theshadow45
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Mar 17, 2015
- Messages
- 5,789
- Reaction score
- 12,304
Julie has been missing for about 47 years today.
I personally don’t see any resemblance: lips, eyebrows, hair texture, distance between and angle of eyes, eye color are all very different to me.Is it possible that she could be the subject in this photo taken by Rodney Alcala?
Did you also search as last name being Tracy/Tracey? TYYear book photos from Ponderosa HS are on Ancestry. I have searched them for the period (late 50s to mid 60s dob) filtered to the name Tracy (or Tracey) and, unfortunately I do not see any obvious match. There are plenty of girls with that name but none look like the picture. This is not definitive because appearances (especially hairstyles) change but the facial shape in the picture is quite striking. It is also possible some pupils photos are missing - but the records for Ponderosa on Ancestry are extensive.
Re: punches on her student card. I am speaking to the idea that she could have gone missing even later. I grew up about 15 years later at a nearby high school. We used to play El Dorado in sports. My student card punches were for sporting events. The reason was so only kids from our school could get in for free for the #6 football game. You couldn’t pass a card around through the fence and sneak your friends from other schools in. That’s how I remember it anyway.HI All,
I've been looking through the year books for 1975,1976,1977 and 1978 El Dorado High School and apart from one image in the 1978 edition there are no images of Julie and her name is not listed in any of them. They contain all students at that time.
See image attached , it doesn't move the case along and it's not a positive id of her but I thought the girl in green looked like her. Photo is from the 1978 year book. Seems a lot of girls from that time period had that haircut
Based on what we have, IMO, we can rule out August 1 1977 or before as when she went missing. She has a 1977/78 High School Student Card, which wouldn't have been issued until late August or September 1977. The card has 40 slots around the outside signifying 40 weeks of school, only one slot is punched out.
In addition, over on Facebook a few years ago the PI helping out her sister asked a group if anyone knew her/had information. One guy mentioned he remembered her, how fitting in as the new person can be hard.
Throw all that together with her not featuring in the end of year 1978 school year book by name and I believe we can be confident she wasn't at El Dorado very long then went missing. Probably went something like this :
While the above doesn't move any discovery along, I've wondered why the August 1 1977 date was never challenged based on the school card which couldn't have been issued that early.
- Goes to her Grandfather's place in Placerville in summer break 1977, was only going to be a temporary measure.
- May have had a part time summer job at a clothing store , was mentioned on Facebook
- Goes to live in Foster Care (Aldea) sometime during summer break prior to school starting
- Starts school late August 1977, gets issued Student Card (she's been identified as having been at school)
- Judging by the lack of use of the Student Card, went missing September/October/November 1977
oh wow, this is an amazing visual match! the eyes, the nose (especially the bridge and directly between the eyes!!), the lips, the face/jaw shape... they are all very similar in my opinion. i'd say the differences are very minimal and could potentially be explained (reconstructions are never 100% accurate anyway): it looks like Julie plucked her eyebrows, and that her actual brow bone wasn't as high up as she plucked them; you can see that in the photos of her from when she was slightly younger. and while it may be a bit of a stretch, i have heard of some people plucking their widow's peak. her widow's peak seems most noticeable in this photo (and even then it's not super prominent), but again in her younger photos you can't really tell that she has one. the only part that i can't seem to think of an explanation for is the "deformed right ear", but because this doe was found in 1984, then maybe it could have somehow become that way in the intervening years???