CO - Angela Craig, 43, mother of 6, allegedly poisoned by cyanide in protein shake by dentist husband, Aurora, Mar 2023

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves

10/9/23

ARAPAHOE COUNTY, Colo. — An Aurora dentist accused of killing his wife by poisoning her protein shakes pleaded not guilty to the charges against him on Monday afternoon.

James Toliver Craig, 45, made the plea in Arapahoe County Court around 4 p.m. Monday in front of Judge Shay Whitaker, who accepted it after discussion about possibly continuing the arraignment once again.


Both parties agreed that the jury trial will run across three weeks in the spring of 2024: April 23 through April 26, April 29 through May 3, and May 7.
 
Thank you.

Until recently, going back to the Colorado State Constitution, there was an exemption to that rule. Judges could order people accused of first-degree murder held without bond. But after a squabble over the term Capital Murder (implied a penalty of death (abolished in CO)), and a state Supreme Court ruling in July, the justices concluded that even defendants in those most serious of cases should have a chance to post bond.
 
Date
Len
Appearance
Name
Hearing Type
Case #
Location
Division
1/10/24
2:30 PM​
1Hr​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Permanent Restraining Ord Hrg​
C212023C4171​
El Paso County​
DIV N-ROOM S301 (South Tower)
1/30/24
9:00 AM​
1Hr​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Motions Hearing​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 308
4/12/24
8:30 AM​
1Hr​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Pre-Trial Readiness Conference​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 308
4/18/24
8:30 AM​
1Hr​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Jury Trial​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 308
4/19/24
8:30 AM​
1D​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Jury Trial​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 201
4/23/24
8:30 AM​
1D​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Jury Trial​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 201
4/24/24
8:30 AM​
1D​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Jury Trial​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 201
4/25/24
8:30 AM​
1D​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Jury Trial​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 201
4/26/24
8:30 AM​
1D​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Jury Trial​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 201
4/29/24
8:30 AM​
1D​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Jury Trial​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 201
4/30/24
8:30 AM​
1D​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Jury Trial​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 201
5/1/24
8:30 AM​
1D​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Jury Trial​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 201
5/2/24
8:30 AM​
1D​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Jury Trial​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 201
5/3/24
8:30 AM​
1D​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Jury Trial​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 201
5/7/24
8:30 AM​
1D​
IN PERSON​
CRAIG, JAMES​
Jury Trial​
D32023CR664​
Arapahoe County​
Div. 201

 
I wonder who wants the permanent restraining order, since she's deceased. Is it from the children?
From the docket heading, I'm inclined to believe there was a Order granted in El Paso County and the petitioner, most likely representing one or more of the minor children, is seeking to amend the Order to correspond with the requirements at trial in Arapahoe County.

I know that the couple had six children -- not certain how many are minors: The couple had been married for more than 20 years and were parents to six children - five girls and a boy - aged eight to 20.

Craig children
 
Wednesday, January 10th:
*Permanent Restraining Order Hearing (@ 2:30pm MT) - CO - Angela Dawn Pray Craig (43) poisoned (potassium cyanide) by husband & left her brain dead & taken off life support (arrived at hospital on Mar. 16, 2023) & died Mar. 18, 2023, Aurora. *James Toliver Craig (45) arrested (3/19/23), charged (3/23/23), formally charged (7/12/23) & arraigned (10/9/23) with 1st degree premeditated murder after deliberations & tampering with physical evidence. Held without bond. Bond set at $10M on 6/28/23. Plead not guilty (10/9/23).
Jury selection set to begin on 4/18/24.
Trial set to begin on 4/23/24 (thru 5/7/24) 4/24, 4/25, 4/26, 4/29, 4/30, 5/1, 5/2, 5/3 & 5/7/24. No court on Mondays.

Case & Court info from 3/16/23 thru 7/12/23 reference post #415 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...entist-husband-aurora-mar-2023.670769/page-21

8/29/23 Update: Today's arraignment hearing has been continued to 10/9/23 @ 4pm. The defendant did not enter a plea today.
10/9/23 Update: Defense Counsel for Craig entered a "not guilty" plea in court today in front of Judge Shay Whitaker, who accepted it after discussion about possibly continuing the arraignment once again. Both parties agreed that the jury trial will run across three weeks in the spring of 2024: 4/23/24 through 4/26/24, 4/29/24 through 5/3/24 & 5/7/24. Next motions hearing on 1/30/24 @ 9am.
1/6/24 Update: A permanent restraining Order hearing is set on 1/10/24 @ 2:30pm. A motions hearing 1/30/24 @ 9am & pretrial readiness conference hearing on 4/12/24 @ 8:0am with trial beginning on 4/18/24 thru 5/7/24. No court on Mondays. Dates are 4/18 & 4/19 for jury selection & trial begins on 4/23 thru 4/26, 4/29 thru 5/3 & 5/7/24 all @ 8:30am.
 
Date Len Appearance Name Hearing Type Case # Location Division
1/30/24
9:00 AM 1Hr IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Motions Hearing D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 308

4/12/24
8:30 AM 1Hr IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Pre-Trial Readiness Conference D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 308

4/18/24
8:30 AM 1Hr IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 308
4/19/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
4/23/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
4/24/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
4/25/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
4/26/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
4/29/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
4/30/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
5/1/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
5/2/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
5/3/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
5/7/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201

link: Colorado Judicial Branch - Court Docket Search
 
Tuesday, January 30th:
*Motions Hearing (@ 9am MT) - CO - *Angela Dawn Pray Craig (43) poisoned (potassium cyanide) by husband & left her brain dead & taken off life support (arrived at hospital on Mar. 16, 2023) & died Mar. 18, 2023, Aurora. *James Toliver Craig (45) arrested (3/19/23), charged (3/23/23), formally charged (7/12/23) & arraigned (10/9/23) with 1st degree premeditated murder after deliberations & tampering with physical evidence. Held without bond. Bond set at $10M on 6/28/23. Plead not guilty (10/9/23).
Jury selection set to begin on 4/18/24.
Trial set to begin on 4/23/24 (thru 5/7/24) 4/24, 4/25, 4/26, 4/29, 4/30, 5/1, 5/2, 5/3 & 5/7/24. No court on Mondays.

Case & Court info from 3/16/23 thru 10/9/23 reference post #431 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...entist-husband-aurora-mar-2023.670769/page-22

1/6/24 Update: A permanent restraining Order hearing is set on 1/10/24 @ 2:30pm. A motions hearing 1/30/24 @ 9am & pretrial readiness conference hearing on 4/12/24 @ 8:0am with trial beginning on 4/18/24 thru 5/7/24. No court on Mondays. Dates are 4/18 & 4/19 for jury selection & trial begins on 4/23 thru 4/26, 4/29 thru 5/3 & 5/7/24 all @ 8:30am.
1/10/24 Update: Next motions hearing on 1/30/24 @ 9am.
 
@DA18th

***COURTROOM UPDATE***James Craig, the #Aurora dentist charged with his wife's death will be in court Tuesday for a Motions Hearing. Time: 9:00 a.m. Courtroom: DIV 308Location: Arapahoe County Courthouse

1706639164154.png

5:54 PM · Jan 25, 2024







@DA18th

***JAMES CRAIG COURTROOM UPDATE***There is no Webex livestream for the Motions Hearing in case 23CR664. However, any member of the public (or media) is welcome to attend in-person. COURTHOUSE: Arapahoe CountyROOM: DIV 308#courts #colorado


12:39 PM · Jan 30, 2024


 

A7A99E4F-9155-4A18-B472-7870B1D20FE4.jpeg

Defense attorneys want key evidence tossed in murder trial of Aurora dentist

Less than three months before the start of a first-degree murder trial of an Aurora dentist accused of poisoning his wife, an Arapahoe County district judge is deciding whether or not to admit some key evidence in the case.

On Tuesday, James Craig's attorneys argued to suppress Google searches found on the dentist's work computer for several poisons and whether or not they were detectable. Those queries were discovered by detectives through searching the hard drive of an office computer but made from an account called jimandwaffles@gmail.com. The account was a new one, created on Feb. 27, three weeks before Angela Craig died.

The searches included “how many grams of pure arsenic would kill a human” and “Is Arsenic Detectible in an Autopsy?”

During their search, detectives also played a YouTube video accessed through jimandwaffles@gmail.com which showed The top 5 undetectable poisons showing no signs of foul play, according to the arrest affidavit.

Some of these searches, the defense said, were discovered illegally by investigators whom they contend went “beyond the scope” of what they asked for in the search warrant.

[…]



Craig, whose hair appears to have greyed since earlier hearings, listened intently to the proceedings, at times even chuckling at some of the comments made by his attorneys. His ankles were shackled and his hands were cuffed from behind, but he was able to lean over to put on his reading glasses to read paperwork on the desk in front of him.

Friends of Angela Craig were in the courtroom to watch the hearing, which took up most of the day, but none of the Craig’s six children were present in person.

[…]

Eighteenth Judicial District Judge Shay Whitaker did not rule on the motion to suppress the searches, but said she would make an order soon.

Craig's trial is set for April 23, with jury selection starting April 19 and it could last until at least May 7.
 
Actually they have jury selection starting 4/18/24....

Date Len Appearance Name Hearing Type Case # Location Division
4/5/24
3:30 PM 1Hr IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Status Conference D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 308

4/12/24
8:30 AM 1Hr IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Pre-Trial Readiness Conference D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 308

4/18/24
8:30 AM 1Hr IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 308
4/19/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201

4/23/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
thru

5/7/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201

link: Colorado Judicial Branch - Court Docket Search
 


Defense attorneys ask for delay in Aurora dentist's murder trial​

Expert toxicologist expected to testify suffers stroke​

Attorneys for an Aurora dentist accused of poisoning his wife a year ago want his upcoming trial delayed because the toxicologist they hired to testify had a stroke.

James Craig's murder trial is currently scheduled to begin April 18.

[…]

Defense expert Henry Spiller, a former director of poison control centers in Ohio and Kentucky, has testified about the dangers of tetrahydrozoline in other trials — perhaps most recently in the November trial of a Pewaukee, Wisconsin woman accused of poisoning her friend with eye drops in 2018.

In their continuance motion, Craig's attorneys said that they became alarmed when they were "suddenly and unexpectedly unable to reach Mr. Spiller" and then realized that he had become ill around Feb. 22.

Spiller, who was retained in the case last September and is "an indispensable witness," according to the motion, told attorneys that his prognosis was good. But in order to secure Craig a fair trial, his attorneys asked for a continuance.

[…]
 


Defense attorneys ask for delay in Aurora dentist's murder trial​

Expert toxicologist expected to testify suffers stroke​

Attorneys for an Aurora dentist accused of poisoning his wife a year ago want his upcoming trial delayed because the toxicologist they hired to testify had a stroke.

James Craig's murder trial is currently scheduled to begin April 18.

[…]

Defense expert Henry Spiller, a former director of poison control centers in Ohio and Kentucky, has testified about the dangers of tetrahydrozoline in other trials — perhaps most recently in the November trial of a Pewaukee, Wisconsin woman accused of poisoning her friend with eye drops in 2018.

In their continuance motion, Craig's attorneys said that they became alarmed when they were "suddenly and unexpectedly unable to reach Mr. Spiller" and then realized that he had become ill around Feb. 22.

Spiller, who was retained in the case last September and is "an indispensable witness," according to the motion, told attorneys that his prognosis was good. But in order to secure Craig a fair trial, his attorneys asked for a continuance.

[…]
I watched his testimony in the Wisconsin trial, and while Spiller put on a bit of a show for the defense the prosecution was able to rebut him pretty much completely. His degree was from a degree mill, he was making calculations that the toxicology association said were inappropriate, and he misinterpreted the data from a scientific paper he disagreed with.

Seemed basically to be a hired gun who will readily say what the defense wants to cast doubt in poisoning cases. Sorry to hear about his stroke though.
 
Docket for: Arapahoe County - Arapahoe County Justice Center
Showing 1 - 15 of 15 records

Date Len Appearance Name Hearing Type Case # Location Division
3/8/24
9:00 AM 1Hr IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Status Conference D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 308

4/5/24
3:30 PM 1Hr IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Status Conference D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 308

4/12/24
8:30 AM 1Hr IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Pre-Trial Readiness Conference D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 308

4/18/24
8:30 AM 1Hr IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 308
4/19/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
4/23/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
4/24/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
4/25/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
4/26/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
4/29/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
4/30/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
5/1/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
5/2/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
5/3/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201
5/7/24
8:30 AM 1D IN PERSON CRAIG, JAMES Jury Trial D32023CR664 Arapahoe County Div. 201

LINK: Colorado Judicial Branch - Court Docket Search
 
Friday, March 8th:
*Status Conference Hearing (@ 9am MT) - CO - *Angela Dawn Pray Craig (43) poisoned (potassium cyanide) by husband & left her brain dead & taken off life support (arrived at hospital on Mar. 16, 2023) & died Mar. 18, 2023, Aurora. *James Toliver Craig (45/now 46) arrested (3/19/23), charged (3/23/23), formally charged (7/12/23) & arraigned (10/9/23) with 1st degree premeditated murder after deliberations & tampering with physical evidence. Held without bond. Bond set at $10M on 6/28/23. Plead not guilty (10/9/23).
Jury selection set to begin on 4/18/24 & 4/19/24.
Trial set to begin on 4/23/24 (thru 5/7/24) 4/24, 4/25, 4/26, 4/29, 4/30, 5/1, 5/2, 5/3 & 5/7/24. No court on Mondays.

Case & Court info from 3/16/23 thru 1/6/24 reference post #433 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...entist-husband-aurora-mar-2023.670769/page-22

1/10/24 Update: Next motions hearing on 1/30/24 @ 9am. 1/30/24 Update: An Arapahoe County district judge is deciding whether or not to admit some key evidence in the case. On Tuesday, Craig's attorneys argued to suppress Google searches found on the dentist's work computer for several poisons & whether or not they were detectable. Those queries were discovered by detectives through searching the hard drive of an office computer but made from an account called jimandwaffles@gmail.com. The account was a new one, created on 2/27/23, three weeks before Angela Craig died. Some of these searches, the defense said, were discovered illegally by investigators whom they contend went “beyond the scope” of what they asked for in the search warrant. Eighteenth Judicial District Judge Shay Whitaker did not rule on the motion to suppress the searches, but said she would make an order soon. Next status conference hearing on 4/5/24 @ 3:30pm.
3/7/24 Update: Attorneys for Craig accused of poisoning his wife a year ago want his upcoming trial delayed because the toxicologist they hired to testify had a stroke. Craig's murder trial is currently scheduled to begin 4/18/24. Defense expert Henry Spiller, a former director of poison control centers in Ohio 7 Kentucky, has testified about the dangers of tetrahydrozoline in other trials — perhaps most recently in the November trial of a Pewaukee, Wisconsin woman accused of poisoning her friend with eye drops in 2018. In their continuance motion, Craig's attorneys said that they became alarmed when they were "suddenly & unexpectedly unable to reach Mr. Spiller" and then realized that he had become ill around Feb. 22. Next status conference hearing on 3/8/24 @ 9am.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
101
Guests online
3,313
Total visitors
3,414

Forum statistics

Threads
604,347
Messages
18,171,000
Members
232,420
Latest member
Txwoman
Back
Top