Found Deceased CO - Suzanne Morphew, 49, Chaffee Co, 10 May 2020 *Case dismissed w/o prejudice* *found in 2023* #114

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves

New Posts

Status
Not open for further replies.

At a motions hearing at the Alfred Araaj U.S. Courthouse in downtown Denver Wednesday, defense attorneys asked U.S. District Judge Daniel Domenico to apply absolute and qualified immunity and toss the case.

Representing Deputy District Attorney Jeff Lindsay, defense attorney William O’Connoll of Wells Anderson, argued, “Mr. Lindsay is alleged to have taken an active hand in drafting the arrest warrant affidavit, which is part and parcel of his role as an advocate the court, it’s part of the judicial process, and it relies on his professionalism judgment for what to include, what not to include.”

Morphew’s attorney, Iris Eytan, urged Domenico look beyond the shield of immunity and hold the actors responsible for supporting a faulty arrest, but the Donald Trump appointee declined.

“You understand I’m just here at the bottom rung and I apply the law set in precedent, so if you are trying to preserve your argument for a higher court, you’ve done it,” Domenico said. “Immunity is something we’re going to have to deal with.”

Analyzing the warrant in question, Domenico said he could see it supporting probable cause for an arrest, but postulated the question should be answered by a judge, not a jury.
 
More from @MassGuy quoted link:

“You are not a potted plant, you have a low bar to find whether or not the case survives qualified immunity,” explained Hollis Whitson, also on behalf of Morphew. “All the court needs to do is decide whether we have sufficiently alleged violations. and could a jury make the determination that there was probable cause lacking.”

[Domenico is hardly going to overrule Judge Murphy on probable cause! On what standing?]

As evidence of probable cause, police pointed to “what was believed to be a needle cover to a syringe, by itself at the bottom of the empty clothes dryer.” Not only was the cap not really associated with Morphew’s tranquilizer guns, he argues, he hadn’t filled a prescription for animal tranquilizer in years — facts not disclosed in the arrest warrant.

[Infuriates me how IE can leave out BM's own words that he tranq'd a deer to cut the horns weeks before SM disappeared. Not filling an Rx is not the same as having the serum on hand].

When filing for an arrest warrant however, investigators failed to disclose the fact that DNA found in the house and Suzanne’s car was linked to two other unsolved sex offenses in Arizona. Local law enforcement also relied on questionable GPA [GPS drift] data despite being cautioned against it by the federal investigators, Morphew claims.

[..]

Domenico did not indicate how he would decide the motions before him but promised a written order in the coming weeks.
 
Last edited:
Seattle1 said:
More from @MassGuy quoted link:

“You are not a potted plant, you have a low bar to find whether or not the case survives qualified immunity,” explained Hollis Whitson, also on behalf of Morphew. “All the court needs to do is decide whether we have sufficiently alleged violations. and could a jury make the determination that there was probable cause lacking.”

[Domenico is hardly going to overrule Judge Murphy on probable cause! On what standing?]

As evidence of probable cause, police pointed to “what was believed to be a needle cover to a syringe, by itself at the bottom of the empty clothes dryer.” Not only was the cap not really associated with Morphew’s tranquilizer guns, he argues, he hadn’t filled a prescription for animal tranquilizer in years — facts not disclosed in the arrest warrant.

[Infuriates me how IE can leave out BM's own words that he tranq'd a deer to cut the horns weeks before SM disappeared. Not filling an Rx is not the same as having the serum on hand].

When filing for an arrest warrant however, investigators failed to disclose the fact that DNA found in the house and Suzanne’s car was linked to two other unsolved sex offenses in Arizona. Local law enforcement also relied on questionable GPA [GPS drift] data despite being cautioned against it by the federal investigators, Morphew claims.

[..]

Domenico did not indicate how he would decide the motions before him but promised a written order in the coming weeks.
Click to expand...
This infuriates me: DNA found in the house and Suzanne’s car was linked to two other unsolved sex offenses in Arizona.

The only “sex offender” DNA, was on the glovebox. No matching samples were found anywhere or on any item.
 
MassGuy said:
“You understand I’m just here at the bottom rung and I apply the law set in precedent, so if you are trying to preserve your argument for a higher court, you’ve done it,” Domenico said. “Immunity is something we’re going to have to deal with.”
Click to expand...

This is Gold. Save the latter for your political aspirations, IE.
 
denvergazette.com

Morphew case is ongoing, new prosecutor states

Lawyers for 19 law enforcement officers who worked on the arrest and failed prosecution of Barry Morphew made their various cases for dismissal of a lawsuit the widower filed against them in federal court Wednesday.
denvergazette.com denvergazette.com

-But it wasn’t the attorneys’ arguments that caught people’s attention during the nearly three-hour motions hearing.

Instead, it was comments made by the presiding judge.

In questioning Morphew’s attorneys, Judge Domenico stated several times that Barry Morphew is "still being investigated” for the alleged murder of his wife, Suzanne, who disappeared Mother’s Day weekend 2020. It was a statement which appeared to catch Morphew's attorneys off guard, considering the case was dismissed without prejudice on the eve of trial in April 2022.

Morphew walked out of the courthouse a free man and has always maintained that he did not kill his wife.

Domenico's statements led Morphew civil attorney Jane Fisher-Byrialsen to take issue, noting at the hearing’s close that new lead prosecutor Anne Kelly has told her in phone conversations that the Morphew investigation is a cold case.

“This means there is no suspect,” said Byrialsen addressing the judge. “I want to be very clear. You said Barry Morphew is under investigation. This is irrelevant and not true.”

When asked about Fisher-Byrialsen’s comments, Kelly told The Denver Gazette in an email statement that “the investigation into the remains of Suzanne Morphew is ongoing. The 12th Judicial District Attorney’s office is assisting with that investigation.”

-As to the reference to the Morphew case as “cold,” she added that guidance from her office and the Colorado Department of Criminal Justice “designated this ongoing investigation as a ‘cold case.' That phrase is specifically defined in the Colorado Victims’ Rights Act.” She added that the cold case designation is used “narrowly by the investigation team” to guide their decision-making around the release of information.
 
MassGuy said:
Domenico's statements led Morphew civil attorney Jane Fisher-Byrialsen to take issue, noting at the hearing’s close that new lead prosecutor Anne Kelly has told her in phone conversations that the Morphew investigation is a cold case.
Click to expand...

More gold!!

As if any sitting DA wants a working relationship, open line of communication, with IE, et., al when BM's defender founded an organization for the purpose of taking down Prosecutors! Nope. IE further attacked Hurlbert at today's hearing. Kelly's not falling for that trap to even take his teams phone calls! Good on her. MOO
 
MassGuy said:
-As to the reference to the Morphew case as “cold,” she added that guidance from her office and the Colorado Department of Criminal Justice “designated this ongoing investigation as a ‘cold case.' That phrase is specifically defined in the Colorado Victims’ Rights Act.” She added that the cold case designation is used “narrowly by the investigation team” to guide their decision-making around the release of information.
Click to expand...

 
"Cold Case?" Let's follow the money:

IMO, Chaffee County took a huge hit already and the 12th Judicial District receives even less funding so if they need to call this a 'Cold Case' to tap into funding at CBI, I say good on them. MOO

In 2022, CBI received funding that enabled us to establish a full-time Cold Case Team. The Cold Case Team is comprised of four agents, one analyst, one forensic investigative genetic genealogy analyst and a supervisor. We also have two DNA and one latent prints forensic scientists embedded with the team.


Cold Case | Colorado Bureau of Investigation

Our Mission The Colorado Cold Case Database was created through legislation in July 2007. The Cold Case Database features unsolved homicides, long-term missing person, and unidentified remains cases. The purpose of the database was to create a central repository to house these unsolved cases in...
cbi.colorado.gov cbi.colorado.gov
 
Seattle1 said:
More gold!!

As if any sitting DA wants a working relationship, open line of communication, with IE, et., al when BM's defender founded an organization for the purpose of taking down Prosecutors! Nope. IE further attacked Hurlbert at today's hearing. Kelly's not falling for that trap to even take his teams phone calls! Good on her. MOO
Click to expand...

As if the prosecutor is going to be telling the defense attorney the current state of the investigation into her number one suspect client. I doubt any judge would buy that. He is not born yesterday, whatever the official status of the investigation. Irrelevant lol!
 
FWIW I can't fathom IE will follow through on a second autopsy. Confirming the results, too damning. It's the appearance she's after. As if there's something suspect about the autopsy.

Ah, but there's only one actual suspect in this case.

But we already knew that.

JMO
 
So we're ready for it -- do we know the shelf life of BAM?

Prescriptions expire for a reason but that doesn't mean the efficacy of the drug expires. Cheap ol' Barry probably want adverse to using expired product. Maybe that's what he was doing during the turkeycarcass hunt -- testing out his supply of BAM on an unsuspecting doe to make sure it had adequate potency, something I suspect he would already know, but maybe he wanted to make fordamnsure.

Good reason to remove game cameras.

JMO
 
Barry’s goose is cooked to a golden brown. In answer to Iris’s claim that it wasn’t Barry’s BAM:

1.) How likely is it that someone else had motive and opportunity to kill Suzanne?

2.) Chemical analysis can prove the source of the BAM.

BAM is a mixture of at least 3 chemicals, each of which has its own variants. Each batch would have small chemical differences from other batches.

LE will do a chemical analysis of the BAM in both the sample from his home AND from Suzanne’s bone marrow. We all know that they will be chemically identical.

3.) How likely is it that anyone other than Barry would still have that 3-4 years old batch and happened to be in Salida Co.
 
SortaSleuthy said:
Barry’s goose is cooked to a golden brown. In answer to Iris’s claim that it wasn’t Barry’s BAM:

1.) How likely is it that someone else had motive and opportunity to kill Suzanne?

2.) Chemical analysis can prove the source of the BAM.

BAM is a mixture of at least 3 chemicals, each of which has its own variants. Each batch would have small chemical differences from other batches.

LE will do a chemical analysis of the BAM in both the sample from his home AND from Suzanne’s bone marrow. We all know that they will be chemically identical.

3.) How likely is it that anyone other than Barry would still have that 3-4 years old batch and happened to be in Salida Co.
Click to expand...

Excellent.

I'd add only that I fully expect that the BarryBAM is likely to have been well expired and used anyway by the thrifty Barry -- why spend unnecessarily on the tranq agent used to murder your wife?

BM is one of the few murderers I can imagine totting up the costs vs benefits of his crime(s) -- and in this case we know the benefits might have run into the millions, had they not been redirected towards IE.
 
SortaSleuthy said:
Barry’s goose is cooked to a golden brown. In answer to Iris’s claim that it wasn’t Barry’s BAM:

1.) How likely is it that someone else had motive and opportunity to kill Suzanne?

2.) Chemical analysis can prove the source of the BAM.

BAM is a mixture of at least 3 chemicals, each of which has its own variants. Each batch would have small chemical differences from other batches.

LE will do a chemical analysis of the BAM in both the sample from his home AND from Suzanne’s bone marrow. We all know that they will be chemically identical.

3.) How likely is it that anyone other than Barry would still have that 3-4 years old batch and happened to be in Salida Co.
Click to expand...
I thought they didn't find any in the home. If not, they don't have anything to sample from.
 
SortaSleuthy said:
Barry’s goose is cooked to a golden brown. In answer to Iris’s claim that it wasn’t Barry’s BAM:

1.) How likely is it that someone else had motive and opportunity to kill Suzanne?

2.) Chemical analysis can prove the source of the BAM.

BAM is a mixture of at least 3 chemicals, each of which has its own variants. Each batch would have small chemical differences from other batches.

LE will do a chemical analysis of the BAM in both the sample from his home AND from Suzanne’s bone marrow. We all know that they will be chemically identical.

3.) How likely is it that anyone other than Barry would still have that 3-4 years old batch and happened to be in Salida Co.
Click to expand...
As to 1.) and 3.) --

And leave a syringe cap in the Morphew dryer--

We're off the rails into flights of fantasy to try to tie this mess to anyone but Barry.

He locked it down.

JMO
 
Cindizzi said:
One of the places in the AA where BM is asked about animal tranquilizers is on pages 85-86:


View attachment 526147
Click to expand...
Why does Barry think the missing sheets make him look bad?

Nothing sketchy about Suzanne changing linens, washing them.

Nothing sketchy about household chores in progress.

Something sketchy about Barry agreeing with Grusing that it makes him look bad.

I'd like to know what.

JMO
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

DNASolves

Who is Fairfield County Jane Doe (1993)?

Members online

... and 223 more.
Total: 541 (members: 224, guests: 317)

Online statistics

Members online
224
Guests online
317
Total visitors
541
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
608,071
Messages
18,234,019
Members
234,279
Latest member
Sherlock@Home
Back
Top