Considering how long outbreaks are continuing in places like Italy even with stores and schools closing weeks ago, I'd vote for home delivery only on those items and closing the stores to reduce people traveling and coming into contact with each other or the store assistants.
I think we need every edge we can get to minimise the health/medical suffering.
Supermarkets that usually have sections for makeup or paper and pens could even get rid of that stuff cheap and then use the space for toilet rolls and cleaning products .... Over here they reckon they're okay for getting the deliveries to the stores but even with the purchase limits there are still a lot of shelves that are looking quite bare.
In a way, the more stores that are open, the more it acts as an encouragement for a family to go out shopping as if it was normal times....these aren't normal times.
And if the supermarkets take some of those products off the shelves so that they can use the shelves for other products, and then another company can do home delivery on the clothing/note books, reading books, etc, people have more incentive to 'shop around' different stores instead of funelling all the money through the supermarkets.
Maybe the situation is different in some places in the US, but even in the UK the focus is more on 'essential' products being food and medicine, cleaning products, and self hygiene products, and you can't get those from a craft shop, office supplies store, or book store. Maybe for the duration of the pandemic, it wouldn't be a bad idea to have the food stores focus on what they were initially set up to sell (fifty odd years ago) and let the other stores sell by home delivery to reduce the number of outings and human interactions?