GRT
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2020
- Messages
- 3,062
- Reaction score
- 25,554
Suicide rates in the US were rising steadily for 2 years before CoVId, so we'd need to disentangle all the reasons (there are lots of studies, but this isn't a place where we can do a seminar on it),
The literature on DV and being isolated at home, by contrast, is 30 years old and definitely predicted the rise.
If it is true that more Americans committed suicide or considered it due to the shutdown (and disentangle economic factors from working-at-home-getting-same-income factors), then we have to ponder why America specifically has this issue as compared to other even-more-tightly-locked down nations, where economies were really poor to begin with.
Perhaps it's the fear so many have that they can't go to a doctor or hospital due to no insurance. But I need to see studies to relate the continued increase in fentanyl deaths (which is driving the suicide statistics) to be related specifically to CoVid...
I'm sure someday they'll do more extensive studies to determine the extent of the detrimental effects of the shutdowns but a number of stories are already out, such as this Reuter's article about increased domestic violence and school dropout rates, and a predicted 20,000 more suicides in the US and Europe.
The KHN Morning Briefing details how now only has domestic violence risen, the injuries are much more severe.
Perhaps the saddest is the impact on children because visits to the ER for child abuse have risen 35%.
Nothing happens in a vacuum. While we need to take safety measures, as a society, we also have to balance trying to stay healthy with the negative effects on human beings.