:welcome2:
Welcome to Websleuths.:seeya:
:seeya:thanks
:welcome2:
Welcome to Websleuths.:seeya:
Follow the logic -
Eddie alerts to cadaver in the Renault
The Renault is swabbed
DNA consistent with Madeleine's is found at the swab site (cadaver alert site)
All other McCanns are alive.
:seeya:
The trouble with that is you're treating a presumptive test as confirmatory, and then a partial DNA match as definitive, then using them to mutually support each other. Faulty logic.
Dogs give false positives, not to mention that a hired car has been through I don't know how many hands and could have cadaver smell from I don't know how many sources.
McCann DNA in a car hired by the McCann family is not really that startling. If it was definitely Madeleine's DNA there you would have a confirmatory test of the dog alert. But that's not the case.
:seeya:
The trouble with that is you're treating a presumptive test as confirmatory, and then a partial DNA match as definitive, then using them to mutually support each other. Faulty logic.
Dogs give false positives, not to mention that a hired car has been through I don't know how many hands and could have cadaver smell from I don't know how many sources.
McCann DNA in a car hired by the McCann family is not really that startling. If it was definitely Madeleine's DNA there you would have a confirmatory test of the dog alert. But that's not the case.
:seeya:
I simply cannot see why the Cadaver dog alerted at the sites where DNA just so happened to be found.
THIS is the impossible aspect to me...the one thing that cannot be explained away by the "dogs r rong dna is rong" chant.
Finding McCann DNA in a car hired by the McCanns is not all that earth shattering.
Would be hilarious.... if the dog wasn't a dog trained to find decomposing human remains... and there wasn't a missing 3 year old.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - now Free
The same dog reacted to coconut shell and the animal remains, also reacts to any blood.. and was trained with pork meat![]()
#
No he wasn't
In his FIRST statement he said her saw a man carrying a child but didn't see his face
Weeks late he see Gerry on TV carrying the twin and then bases the way he carried the child as the same as the person he saw - he was 60% sure
Doesn't sound very very specific to me - can you imagine this scenario ever being presented in court .
are we also supposed to discount the witnesses who put Gerry in the resort same time ?
hi donjeta,
I was for 7 days in Paris and 7 days in Sweden, with no local knowledge and no language and no friends no car.. for me it would be impossible even to call a taxi on my own after 6 days, let alone commit a crime and hide it so well..
Plus how did they know there were no CCTV cameras around?
The McCanns friends had a car and the McCanns themselves hired one shortly after the "disappearance".
Untrue.
Cars were rented days AFTER Madeleine went missing.
On the night Madeleine went missing neither McCanns or any of their friends had an access to a car.
Didn't they borrow a car from Murat?
I can't locate the Gaspars. I'd like to read it. Do you have a link for that?I take it you haven't read the Gaspars statements that were made to LE?
Scotland Yard read all of the statements and they are still searching for live Madeleine
So should everyone else !
Whatever happened, happened, what is important now is to find this little girl.
A very powerful police force is looking for her now, their work should be prised and helped, not jeopardised by some stupid biased assumptions and speculative theories which they passed and investigated long ago.
Church..... maybe
None of them rented a car during the week vacation in Praia de Luz. Only later. If you are sure they did, please provide a link.The McCanns friends had a car and the McCanns themselves hired one shortly after the "disappearance".