GUILTY FL - Doug Benefield, 58, shot and killed by estranged wife, Manatee County, 27 Sept 2020

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves

New Posts

Status
Not open for further replies.
The tension between the new much younger wife and the 15yo is totally understandable and to be expected. The victim handled the transition incredibly poorly and selfishly. He was way outta line imo. And the 15yo had every right to be antagonistic with this immature, whiny 24yo “step-mother” who was just a few years older than her.

It seems to me the victim chose the defendant over his daughter. That’s tragic. And now he’s dead! Smh

JMO
 
Izzylizzy said:
I can't let this go. lol

Last night I listened again to prosecutor O'Donnell's opening statement.
She brought up the unfounded accusation made by AB that DB was poisoning her and her unborn child.
Why didn't she also tell the jury that AB's accusations against DB that he physically/sexually abused their daughter was also unfounded?
Those reprehensible false accusations should give more than pause to the jury when deciding whether to believe AB's claims that she was an abused wife who killed her husband in self-defense.
I don't recall hearing O'Connell bring up AB's false claims of this abuse to her daughter when she examined AB.
Click to expand...
I think she leans towards histrionic personality disorder -
Obviously, he was abusive, manipulative, intimidating, controlling -
In her head, it was perfectly REASONABLE to leap to the worst possible conclusions.

Given his KNOWN history of violent propensity - I’m now leaning towards NOT GUILTY

A woman shouldn’t have to be beaten before defending herself.
 
The law says a woman or man has to be in imminent threat of death or serious bodily injury to justify killing someone. I think all this psycho babble is meant to justify a hysterical woman who involved herself with a hysterical man and together they had a volatile, immature relationship. He was never physically abusive towards her by her own testimony. She’s guilty.

JMO
 
I will be very interested to see what kind of questions the jurors come back to court with once they begin deliberating (assuming they don't just reach a unanimous verdict almost immediately, of course). Both sides (State & Defense) have put a lot of emphasis on the events before the shooting, rather than the shooting itself so they might feel a need to reach definite conclusions regarding who did what on that front before deciding?

JMO
 
Weki said:
The law says a woman or man has to be in imminent threat of death or serious bodily injury to justify killing someone. I think all this psycho babble is meant to justify a hysterical woman who involved herself with a hysterical man and together they had a volatile, immature relationship. He was never physically abusive towards her by her own testimony. She’s guilty.

JMO
Click to expand...

Observations by this guy that just testified. Doug is Domineering, controlling, wanted marriage to work,they had plans to move to MD. Doug is an Alpha male. Ashley stated she was scared. Was Doug godly, over the top godly but didn't think it was genuine. Due to Ashley's false accusations wonder why DB wanted to continue relationship. Odd that DB waited in lobby for an hour while his daughter was outside in car with AB.Only saw him at beginning and end of hour so DB could have left and returned. A WHOLE BUNCH OF NOTHING. JMOO
 
Ohhhh Dr. Quintal said Doug’s Godliness was disingenuous! I have to agree there. He also said he fit the stereotype of an “Alpha male” ——- I have to strongly disagree. Doug seemed to have no control over his emotions - that is the opposite of Alpha male to me. The term seems to be used nowadays to describe a gym bro who acts tough! Puhlease!

He said Doug was controlling and seemed determined to make it work with AB despite all the disparaging things she said about him. AB told him that she was scared of Doug. Again, I think she’s setting Doug up by creating a record all over the place that she was “abused.” I’m not buying it!

JMO
 
Linda7NJ said:
I think she leans towards histrionic personality disorder -
Obviously, he was abusive, manipulative, intimidating, controlling -
In her head, it was perfectly REASONABLE to leap to the worst possible conclusions.

Given his KNOWN history of violent propensity - I’m now leaning towards NOT GUILTY

A woman shouldn’t have to be beaten before defending herself.
Click to expand...


"In her head"?
No, she knew damn well what she was doing.

By her filing those charges against DB she knew that his visitation would be immediately stopped until an investigation takes place.


There's nothing more heinous then the sexual/physical abuse of a child and to make these false accusations because you want sole custody of your child shows just how despicable you are.

There is NO evidence presented that AB was beaten by DB.
 
Weki said:
Ohhhh Dr. Quintal said Doug’s Godliness was disingenuous! I have to agree there. He also said he fit the stereotype of an “Alpha male” ——- I have to strongly disagree. Doug seemed to have no control over his emotions - that is the opposite of Alpha male to me. The term seems to be used nowadays to describe a gym bro who acts tough! Puhlease!

He said Doug was controlling and seemed determined to make it work with AB despite all the disparaging things she said about him. AB told him that she was scared of Doug. Again, I think she’s setting Doug up by creating a record all over the place that she was “abused.” I’m not buying it!

JMO
Click to expand...
For what it's worth both were Evangelicals and DB did not believe in divorce.
 
Interesting that AB took a drastic turn in her feelings about DB once she moved home with mommy, isn't it? All of a sudden she now wants nothing to do with DB, they both go back up to Charleston and move her things out while he is elsewhere and she leaves him a note. Then she goes to LE in Charleston to get a restraining order but can't get one specifically against Doug so she goes for the mutual no contact version.

All the rest of the shenanigans she did with the child abuse claims - I see her mother's hand in all of this. NO DOUBT IN MY MIND.
 
We’re in the defense case now so we’re in the major derailment portion of the trial but I hope state brings this back to earth on rebuttal and closing argument. What matters most is was she in reasonable fear for her life when she shot him! By her own words he had never physically harmed her prior to that day. And all of a sudden he was body checking her and hitting her with boxes and taking a warrior stance with her on that day??? It would be laughable if it wasn’t so pathetic.

JMO
 
Izzylizzy said:
"In her head"?
No, she knew damn well what she was doing.

By her filing those charges against DB she knew that his visitation would be immediately stopped until an investigation takes place.


There's nothing more heinous then the sexual/physical abuse of a child and to make these false accusations because you want sole custody of your child shows just how despicable you are.

There is NO evidence presented that AB was beaten by DB.
Click to expand...
I do not believe she claimed she was badly beaten.
I don’t believe someone needs to be beaten before lethal force is justified

I’m not claiming she’s INNOCENT -
I’m staying thus far, the prosecution is FAILING to prove it’s case.
 
Defense has a ballistic expert and another doctor coming in this afternoon. Good lawd! I’m behind on the feed so just seeing the discussion of the afternoon plans. Defense will be done today it sounds like. JMO
 
Wishbone said:
Just showing evangelical AB, not believing in divorce, got one too. Doubt they believe in murder as well, but she did one of those as well. JMOO
Click to expand...

No need to show me anything.

I trust my own judgement.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

DNASolves

Who is DeKalb County John Doe (2022)?

Members online

... and 138 more.
Total: 2,974 (members: 139, guests: 2,835)

Online statistics

Members online
139
Guests online
2,835
Total visitors
2,974
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
603,453
Messages
18,156,862
Members
231,734
Latest member
Ava l
Back
Top