I looked back in this thread and I don't think I saw anything already mentioned about him (apologies if I missed it) but what about
Paul Clyde Rollins? He disappeared only six months before Conahan was caught. This poor guy basically evaporated into thin air, leaving everything behind at his home. It doesn't seem like there is like any information really on what lead up to his disappearance or anything. Fort Myers is only about 2 hours south of New Port Richey and pretty much a straight shot down i75.
Paul Clyde Rollins - Websleuths Thread
To me he kinda looks like
him - both have fractured right hand/wrist, age is just a few years off, but not by much, height match. What do y'all think?
View attachment 344416