Gilgo Beach LISK Serial Killer, Rex Heuermann, charged with 3 murders, July 2023 #4

[imstilla.grandma]

One neighbour recalls a confrontation with Heuermann, who was talking about "the girls" while drunk and threatening violence.

Jimmy Mack, who lives a couple of blocks away from Heuermann's home, revealed that he had intimidating encounters with the suspected murderer.

He mentioned that he once caught Heuermann babbling about "the girls" while drunk and alone at the end of his driveway. When Mr Mack con

The neighbours also reported that Heuermann's dog was often left outside, barking incessantly and causing disruptions to the neighbourhood.

Mr Mack recounted the terrifying encounter with the suspected murderer. The incident reportedly occurred when Heuermann was walking home from the LIRR station past Mr Mack's house on March 2

Mr Mack told the Daily Mail he was sitting on his porch close to 10pm, smoking a cigarette when he overheard Heuermann talking to himself. He mentioned that Heuermann didn't realize he was there and appeared intoxicated.

Heuermann was heard saying, "oh here we are again… I told them ...I told those girls once already ... now you guys are going to understand."

Feeling alarmed by Heuermann's words, Mr Mack asked him, "bro are you talking to my house?" Heuermann responded aggressively, asking if Mr Mack owned the car parked there.

He then mentioned that he had warned someone previously and now they would see, implying some kind of threat.

Gilgo Beach suspect's neighbour 'heard him drunkenly talking about the girls'

Neighbours of the Gilgo Beach serial killer suspect, Rex Heuermann, described him as intimidating, with one neighbour recounting a confrontation where he talked about 'the girls'

www.mirror.co.uk

 

[Lex141]

I know everyone like myself is going wild trying to find any info on this monster/people related to case, so I am just throwing this out there. Many of these online people/property search sites are NOT ACCURATE. Especially if they are free sites. Sure, there are some accuracies, but try looking yourself up and see what you find. People “connected to you” could be a neighbor who moved in next door 5 years after you left. If you were married, your ex residence could come up linked to you, etc.

 

[Inthedetails]

One neighbour recalls a confrontation with Heuermann, who was talking about "the girls" while drunk and threatening violence.

Jimmy Mack, who lives a couple of blocks away from Heuermann's home, revealed that he had intimidating encounters with the suspected murderer.

He mentioned that he once caught Heuermann babbling about "the girls" while drunk and alone at the end of his driveway. When Mr Mack con

The neighbours also reported that Heuermann's dog was often left outside, barking incessantly and causing disruptions to the neighbourhood.

Mr Mack recounted the terrifying encounter with the suspected murderer. The incident reportedly occurred when Heuermann was walking home from the LIRR station past Mr Mack's house on March 2

Mr Mack told the Daily Mail he was sitting on his porch close to 10pm, smoking a cigarette when he overheard Heuermann talking to himself. He mentioned that Heuermann didn't realize he was there and appeared intoxicated.

Heuermann was heard saying, "oh here we are again… I told them ...I told those girls once already ... now you guys are going to understand."

Feeling alarmed by Heuermann's words, Mr Mack asked him, "bro are you talking to my house?" Heuermann responded aggressively, asking if Mr Mack owned the car parked there.

He then mentioned that he had warned someone previously and now they would see, implying some kind of threat.

Gilgo Beach suspect's neighbour 'heard him drunkenly talking about the girls'

Neighbours of the Gilgo Beach serial killer suspect, Rex Heuermann, described him as intimidating, with one neighbour recounting a confrontation where he talked about 'the girls'

www.mirror.co.uk

If he was walking toward his house, I would think "the girls" referred to his wife and daughter. Perhaps he found fault with something they had done or didn't do "again." I wouldn't be surprised if he wasn't the nicest guy at home.

jmo

 

[terssi333]

I think RH's plan was to burn down the LI house and move to SC.

For insurance money, he used external help for repair.

 

[Friday13]

I think RH's plan was to burn down the LI house and move to SC.

For insurance money, he used external help for repair.

This thought crossed my mind as well. For insurance money among other possible reasons.

 

[Momoffourboys]

Gilgo killings unsolved for 13 years because ‘bad dudes botched the case’

“They failed, they failed miserably,” Robert Banfelder said of certain Suffolk County law enforcement officials. “They thwarted everyone who was trying to help the investigation, …

nypost.com

…

As for Heuermann, he said, “He’s going to be accused of murdering the fourth one. That’s almost a given. And from there, they’re going to go on to working at these other six victims and even beyond them beyond that.”

 

[Inthedetails]

I think RH's plan was to burn down the LI house and move to SC.

For insurance money, he used external help for repair.

Aha. Makes sense. Good thinking.

 

[fred&edna]

This is a really informative! Makes me really curious to how they'll justify taking things like the mirror or fire extinguishers. Also makes me realize that we the public really don't know anything.

Something silly: Prof. Jules Epstein kept referring to LE being able to collect items in "plain view". My insomniac brain was like "What's in Plainview?!" (It's a town on LI just north of RH/Massapequa).

I've seen interviews with Jules Epstein before. I wish I could sit-in on a Jules Epstein class... his "lawspeak" explanations are wonderful.

 

[puckle]

Also, you really need a dog if you're duck hunting. I've been on several duck hunts and a good water dog is essential (retrieving the ducks from the water that they are shot over). So either he had a dog at one point and hadn't duck hunted for years (used it as a guise to hide his real intentions) or he hunted with a friend who had a dog. I thought I read somewhere he shared a boat with someone, so maybe that person had the dog? Plus, hunting can be pretty hard work. You have to tramp through a lot of rough terrain to get to your duck blind. Duck hunting isn't as physically challenging as pheasant or deer hunting, but still, he doesn't look like he did a lot walking...

i heard somewhere, don’t know if it was reddit or here, that his son had just got a puppy. maybe they had one that recently passed ?

 

[puckle]

I think RH's plan was to burn down the LI house and move to SC.

For insurance money, he used external help for repair.

it’s surprisingly difficult to purposely burn down a building and leave no evidence. if he did this, it probably would’ve lead to him being caught anyway.

 

[PaulaDC]

Yes. Gacy's crime scene was crazy. It was in the news for weeks, months. I was traveling on business in the Chicago area about a month after his arrest, The local rep who was driving me around took us past Gacy's house. There wasn't much left at that point, they had found most of the bodies by then. It was a surreal fall and winter, between Jim Jones in November and John Wayne Gacy making news around Christmas. The late 70's were harsh.

I grew up in DesPlaines. He used to cruise our town for boys. Some of the missing came from the school my Mother was employed at. They totally had to take that house apart to get to that crawl space. That was a true nightmare for those that had to clean up.

 

[Inthedetails]

it’s surprisingly difficult to purposely burn down a building and leave no evidence. if he did this, it probably would’ve lead to him being caught anyway.

And I'm sorta laughing, thinking of how many firefighters lived on that block (as reported at link above).
jmo

Edited to add: I'm not laughing at the idea of arson, which I think might be possible, but at the thought of starting a fire in a neighborhood of firefighers.

jmo

 

[x_files]

What in the heck am I seeing here. Looks like the belt has been altered using the clone tool in photoshop. Why.

From the search warrant executed at Craig Heuermann's property in South Carolina:

"Potential instruments used in the homicides that investigators sought included cell phones, condoms, cut distal ends of black leather belts, devices that stamp letters on leather, knives, scissors, cutting instruments, and Bounty paper towels."

View attachment 436080

Edited to add: We've been wondering about RH's travels. <modsnip>

maybe blood was on it and it was obscured for the public? It does look odd.

 

[x_files]

It’s interesting to me that they were all positioned facing East, and his home on LI is East (Northeast) of AC.

Maybe it was a clue, taunting the police?

 

[fred&edna]

The guy is kinda huge and ruthless. Anyway, no way to know.

I just hope the guy feels fear at some point. Karma, baby.

ITA

I absolutely do not like blaming everything on parenting (nor am I suggesting sleuthing family!) However, I have to wonder a bit about his childhood. What caused his WWII vet father's death at a "relatively" young age, and did mom stay home and raise her sons? (And, of course, there's my age-old question... What causes/creates and fuels sadistic torture and killing? I don't think I'll ever understand.)

 

[x_files]

Despite having years of outstanding taxes on the Massapequa Park house, RH is up-to-date on his property taxes on the 4 lots he owns in Chester County, SC.
View attachment 436086

curious about what he has buried there.

 

[Lex141]

And I'm sorta laughing, thinking of how many firefighters lived on that block (as reported at link above).
jmo

Edited to add: I'm not laughing at the idea of arson, which I think might be possible, but at the thought of starting a fire in a neighborhood of firefighers.

jmo

Agree. The fire theory is a bit out there for me. Nothing would bring more attention to you then setting a place in a suburban neighborhood

 

[NicMed329]

Here is the poster/photo removed from RH's Massapequa home. I have rotated and slightly unwarped the image. No retouching or altering. Just removed the background.
View attachment 436188View attachment 436190

I had posted that i thought she looked like Melissa Bethelemy but bow I think it looks like a younger version of his wife. Jmo

 

[Lex141]

ITA

I absolutely do not like blaming everything on parenting (nor am I suggesting sleuthing family!) However, I have to wonder a bit about his childhood. What caused his WWII vet father's death at a "relatively" young age, and did mom stay home and raise her sons? (And, of course, there's my age-old question... What causes/creates and fuels sadistic torture and killing? I don't think I'll ever understand.)

I think a lot about what that house dynamic must have been like during RH and CH childhood. It’s curious to me that no one who knew him as a child has come forward. His father died at a pivotal age (RH was 11). It seems that RH idolized his father, took after his wood working hobbies etc. His hatred for women could have simply arose after his fathers death, having to take orders from his mother. Curious if any animal torture/bed wetting/arson came into play in his youth which are tremendous red flags

 

[minazoe]

They were not. One was asphyxiated, one was killed by ligature strangulation, the other two the method of killing was unable to be determined due to decomposition.

MOO

as with Gilgo he would perhaps find a spot and use that spot for 4 of his victims...rather than chose another spot.
there are so many reasons this could be..I am not hanging my hat on different signatures etc..I think it could all be him..
he has had years to operate on the seaboard and elsewhere.