IA IA - Daughter Alleges Father (Donald Studey) is Serial Killer - Searches Yielded No Evidence - Thurman

[cuffem]

I have a feeling crime podcasts and other crime forums will keep this claim going just for the clicks regardless of LE not finding any evidence pointing to his guilt. IMO.

 

[ChatteringBirds]

Why are some here so insistent there is no way any murders happened on this property? Despite cadaver dogs allegedly hitting and 2 violent deaths known to have happened, both very unusual ways of committing suicide?

I can't help but wonder why you are closed to the possibility of "maybe."

I get that Lucy's story changes but still.

Again I personally would like to read just "how" the well itself was searched. That seemed the one place most likely to actually yield something, if there was something. JMO.

 

[sgmet]

Why are some here so insistent there is no way any murders happened on this property? Despite cadaver dogs allegedly hitting and 2 violent deaths known to have happened, both very unusual ways of committing suicide?

I can't help but wonder why you are closed to the possibility of "maybe."

I get that Lucy's story changes but still.

Again I personally would like to read just "how" the well itself was searched. That seemed the one place most likely to actually yield something, if there was something. JMO.

I don’t think anybody is insistent that “no way any murders happened on this property”. Maybe? That could apply to virtually anywhere, could it not? I may have walked through a dozen potential crime scenes just walking into work today. Or I may have walked through zero.

There was no evidence that a crime has occurred. There was no evidence in 2007 that a crime had occurred. Or in the decades before that, or ever.

 

[ChatteringBirds]

I don’t think anybody is insistent that “no way any murders happened on this property”. Maybe? That could apply to virtually anywhere, could it not? I may have walked through a dozen potential crime scenes just walking into work today. Or I may have walked through zero.

There was no evidence that a crime has occurred. There was no evidence in 2007 that a crime had occurred. Or in the decades before that, or ever.

You stated you believe LE should actually bill her for the investigation. So you don't think she might be telling the truth. But I believe her numerous reports to LE over the years, together with the dogs signaling, are circumstantial evidence. Enough to require a thorough investigation.

 

[NoSpoonFeeding]

MOO Some believe her reports, with no personal knowledge of any evidence, and this does not meet the standard of calling the father a "suspected serial killer". He is not named as a suspect or even a POI in any murder. If he was alive, MOO, there would be no posting calling him a suspected serial killer. The daughter has a sibling, and her memory should also be treated with respect and it is assumed she is being truthful.

 

[cuffem]

MOO Some believe her reports, with no personal knowledge of any evidence, and this does not meet the standard of calling the father a "suspected serial killer". He is not named as a suspect or even a POI in any murder. If he was alive, MOO, there would be no posting calling him a suspected serial killer. The daughter has a sibling, and her memory should also be treated with respect and it is assumed she is being truthful.

Well said and I agree. This thread should be closed until LE has some kind of proof or reopens the case. Mr. Studey is not here to defend himself. IMO.

 

[Earth]

While I don't want this to end up the same way as Denise Huskins, maybe the woman needs psychological help. It seems as if her father was a nasty piece of work, even if he wasn't a serial killer. Unless she tricked her brain into creating false memories of him being horrible.

 

[cuffem]

While I don't want this to end up the same way as Denise Huskins, maybe the woman needs psychological help. It seems as if her father was a nasty piece of work, even if he wasn't a serial killer. Unless she tricked her brain into creating false memories of him being horrible.

Since I was a small child I have been scared of dogs. My parents were visiting people with dogs so they put me in a separate room to nap on a bed. I recall a giraffe putting his head in the window and licking my face. I was terrified crying. I vividly recall my mother seeking safety on top of a car and my father chasing the giraffe down the street. It had run away from the zoo.

Now my parents have always told me it was a Great Dane and not a giraffe and as an adult I realistically know it is not a giraffe but my memory will always see that giraffe.

Now I am not saying this is same as having memories of murders and bodies but just a memory of a young frightened child and now adult. MOO.

 

[OddOneOut]

You stated you believe LE should actually bill her for the investigation. So you don't think she might be telling the truth. But I believe her numerous reports to LE over the years, together with the dogs signaling, are circumstantial evidence. Enough to require a thorough investigation.

She also said they were investigating the wrong place. As I understood it, there were two wells and she said they were at the wrong one. It isn't unusual for rural properties to have more than one well over the years. An uncle of mine dug numerous wells on our family farm while looking for another source of water besides the house well. The police even commented that the well was on someone else's property.

 

[ChatteringBirds]

The thread title has been appropriately edited IMO.

 

[cuffem]

The thread title has been appropriately edited IMO.

Thank you Mods for changing title.

 

[AliceInPain]

I don't think she should have to pay for this. Mental health issues are going on here, imo, and she never asked for those.

...she wrote on the site, "To all the law enforcement agencies, GO F--K YOURSELF. Especially the Iowa DCI and Mitch Mortvedt. You'll have one more dead body in the morning. Mine." Mortvedt is the DCI spokesman.

On Wednesday, in the statement she shared with Newsweek, she wrote: "It only took an attempted suicide by me on December 11, 2022 and a note posted on Facebook blaming them for my death in order for the FBI and Iowa DCI to finally contact me."

sbm from Daughter says authorities botched search at potential Iowa mass graves site

 

[cuffem]

One daughter insists father was Iowa killer; another says 'he certainly wasn't', cops find no evidence

Were there really bodies in the well? Sister of Lucy Studey McKiddy warned against believing the claims, but McKiddy remains adamant

www.yahoo.com

 

[MajorHoople]

One daughter insists father was Iowa killer; another says 'he certainly wasn't', cops find no evidence

Were there really bodies in the well? Sister of Lucy Studey McKiddy warned against believing the claims, but McKiddy remains adamant

www.yahoo.com

From the the beginning I doubted her story. It just didn't "pass the smell test". But she managed to convince the writers from Newsweek.

 

[Palisades]

What can be used here, if the info that cadaver dogs hit upon scents. This means either: 1. there are bodies, they were not uncovered or 2. this case shows cadaver dogs do not always hit correctly on human remains, which can be brought up when sleuthing other cases. Point #2 is important because so many people take cadaverdog hitting upon a scent as definitive proof of a decedant.

 

[AliceInPain]

What can be used here, if the info that cadaver dogs hit upon scents. This means either: 1. there are bodies, they were not uncovered or 2. this case shows cadaver dogs do not always hit correctly on human remains, which can be brought up when sleuthing other cases. Point #2 is important because so many people take cadaverdog hitting upon a scent as definitive proof of a decedant.

bbm
I read about other (organic) things than human remains that can cause a dog to hit... also, there's this from Samaritan Detection Dogs' website. I don't know how much land they searched but it wouldn't be odd if there are human remains lying around.

Our canines are trained to recognize the full spectrum of human decomposition odor; from a few hours ago, or days ago, to a few decades ago, to abandoned pioneer graves in the mid-1800's, to native-American burial mounds which may be hundreds or thousands of years old.

Samaritan Detection Dogs - Archaeology

 

[truetexan]

First I had of this was today. Maybe some day they will just dig the well and find out once and for all.

 

[Sillybilly]

ADMIN NOTE:

Members may not post inside information without being Verified. Posts containing inside info will be removed pending approval as a Verified member.

For an explanation of why Websleuths has this policy and how to apply for Verification, please read:

Verification Process for Professional or Insider Posters

*PLEASE NOTE THE NEW EMAIL ADDRESS FOR VERIFICATION IS WSVERIFY@YAHOO.COM* If you would like to add yourself as an expert in a certain field or as an insider to a case, please send an email to wsverify@yahoo.com Please note this is a new email address. If you do not wish to be identified as...

www.websleuths.com

 

[renah]

I followed this story on FB in a group run by his daughter Lucy. Activity there had been greatly reduced these past several months & I'd almost forgotten her story. Today a new, suggested post popped up in my feed; Lucy has started another group. A search for Lucy Studey McKiddy will bring you to it. It's a page that begins with "Falsely Accused Green Hollow...". It's VERY different from the original group and well worth a look.

I haven't gotten quite to the end but so far each post is accompanied by supported documentation of one type or another. It looks like she's uploaded them in the last day or so, and they're very organized and very coherent-- perfect for anyone who's interested in her story to get up to speed on the case. I've already come across several new anecdotes which, IMHO, reinforce her truthfulness. And most blessed of all: none of the craziness in the Comments section that unfortunately detracted from her Bodies in the Well original group.

I hope that Lucy can finally get her story properly investigated. She has been disbelieved the majority of her life, (I can't imagine!), and then when she finally did get her story out, media created an exploiting, superficial and sensationalist sh## show while her dysfunctional family piled on for all the public to see. Her new page seems to show that she's learned exactly what that will take. I was so impressed!!

 

[SharonNeedles]

I followed this story on FB in a group run by his daughter Lucy. Activity there had been greatly reduced these past several months & I'd almost forgotten her story. Today a new, suggested post popped up in my feed; Lucy has started another group. A search for Lucy Studey McKiddy will bring you to it. It's a page that begins with "Falsely Accused Green Hollow...". It's VERY different from the original group and well worth a look.

I haven't gotten quite to the end but so far each post is accompanied by supported documentation of one type or another. It looks like she's uploaded them in the last day or so, and they're very organized and very coherent-- perfect for anyone who's interested in her story to get up to speed on the case. I've already come across several new anecdotes which, IMHO, reinforce her truthfulness. And most blessed of all: none of the craziness in the Comments section that unfortunately detracted from her Bodies in the Well original group.

I hope that Lucy can finally get her story properly investigated. She has been disbelieved the majority of her life, (I can't imagine!), and then when she finally did get her story out, media created an exploiting, superficial and sensationalist sh## show while her dysfunctional family piled on for all the public to see. Her new page seems to show that she's learned exactly what that will take. I was so impressed!!

Lucy has made life hell for her sisters and continues to do so. And she still has absolutely nothing to support her wild stories.