So I typed out this long and quite brilliant (if I do say so myself) theory about the type of person that would have known Mollie was home alone that night (not a specific person mind you, just the type of person). So I’m going along, typing it up and thinking “Hey, I’ll get some links to back up some of the small details I’m posting.”
And once I did that, I found a link that blew my theory out of the water
I was going to mention that it’s possible anyone in town could have known Mollie was alone, even if she didn’t know them. With the brothers in a construction business, in order to make it worth their while to do a job out of town (gas, food, hotels) they probably quite frequently stay gone for several days in a row, and it might be common knowledge around town.
As I’m perusing articles, I came across this one referencing an interview with BJ, Dalton’s brother:
Mollie Tibbetts search: Boyfriend's brother says scrutiny directed at his family unwarranted
“Blake Jack told The Associated Press on Tuesday that on July 18, he was visiting his fiancee, Aimee Houghton, in Ames, where she is working this summer. He said his brother was working a job for their family construction company about 100 miles away in Dubuque.”
I did a search of the forum to see if this had been discussed but didn’t really see anything. I thought the fiancé and brother were working out of town together on a job? I figured they were all out of town for the week, but if he was just visiting his girlfriend, I wonder for how long?
I am not trying to sleuth and/or accuse anyone and I hope I’m not crossing the line with this post. I do not feel the BF, brother or fiancé had anything to do with it. But if the brother wasn’t working a job (which he very well could have been, in addition to visiting his girlfriend), that would narrow down the suspect pool my theory is based on. IMO, it would now have to be someone known to someone in the house to have the confidence in knowing Mollie was alone that night. Otherwise, not knowing if/when the brother might be home would be a huge gamble. That is, if she was taken from the house.