GUILTY ID - Robert Manwill, 8, Boise, 24 July 2009 - #5

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
Search warrant reveals little in case of Robert Manwill's death
A second search warrant that led to the arrests of the boy's mother and her boyfriend remains sealed.
Published: 09/24/09
<snipped>
Despite spending hours over two days searching the backyard of Evan Wallis' south Ada County home for evidence of then-missing Robert Manwill, detectives left with fewer than a dozen pieces of evidence, according to search warrant documents released this week.

But Wallis' home was just one of two residences police searched in the 10-day search that drew more than 2,300 volunteers and national attention. The other was the Oak Park Village apartment shared by Robert's mother, Melissa Jenkins, and her boyfriend, Daniel Ehrlick Jr. - both charged with first-degree murder after the boy's body was found Aug. 3 in the New York Canal in southern Ada County.

What police found at Jenkins' South Boise apartment on July 30 - and even what evidence allowed them to get the search warrant in the first place - remains a mystery.

Fourth District Magistrate John Hawley sealed those search warrant materials at the request of county prosecutors in July. This week, he rejected a request from the Idaho Statesman to unseal the documents.


Article:
http://www.idahostatesman.com/102/story/910830.html
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Our View: Fair trial still possible if warrant goes public in Robert Manwill case
Published: 09/25/09
<snipped>
The Robert Manwill disappearance became big news - and the Boise Police Department did nothing to discourage it.

The unprecedented search effort and the intense public interest will complicate jury selection, if the case of Robert's murder goes to trial. The rights of the accused must be protected. But this can be done without sealing court documents - a judicial overreach that could embolden police and prosecutors to try to keep other documents out of public view.

Magistrate Judge John Hawley has kept a lid on a key record - a search warrant for the apartment shared by Robert's mother, Melissa Jenkins, and her boyfriend, Daniel Ehrlick. Saying the document contains accusatory hearsay statements against the two first-degree murder suspects, Hawley said its release would only make it more difficult to find an impartial jury.

It is a strangely reasoned and highly troubling decision.

Search warrants are presumed to be public records. They have been made public prior to other high-profile local trials. Hawley concedes this point, then proceeds to ignore it.


Article:
http://www.idahostatesman.com/editorial/story/912303.html

:angel:
 
If by releasing the information and making it public could jeopardize their trials in anyway, I think I'd rather the information remain sealed. My first thought isn't about an impartial jury, I always worry that something could be revealed that could allow a person to walk away, scot-free. JMO. (I don't know enough about how things work to form an educated opinion, it just seems like the more we hear about any case opens up some sort of loophole for people to slink away.)
 
Divas lend their considerable talents in a Concert for the Children
Mon, Oct 12, 2009 at 3:31 PM
<snipped>
On Thursday, Oct. 22, the nine women currently on the Diva roster&#8212;many of them mothers&#8212;will perform on the Humpin' Hannah's stage to raise funds to fight child abuse. Idaho icon Rosalie Sorrels will perform a solo performance and then the Divas will join her for the final set of the night.

Johnson said after the Robert Manwill case, more cases of child abuse began surfacing and she and her fellow femme fatales felt inspired to do something to help.


Article:
http://www.boiseweekly.com/Cobweb/a...derable-talents-in-a-concert-for-the-children
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Say Hello On Halloween
(2009-10-13)
<snipped>
BOISE, ID (idaho) - In memory of Robert Manwill and in response to a community's desire to do more for children, the Idaho Children's Trust Fund wants to "introduce" something new this Halloween. And "introduce" may be the operative word. Boise State Radio's George Prentice talks with the Trust Fund's Executive Director Roger Sherman about new initiatives to strengthen families and help protect children.

You can go to this web address to print our your "Say Hello On Halloween" sign:
http://idahochildrenstrustfund.state.id.us/publications/Hello_on_hallo_OL.pdf

*NOTE: Audio Included At link!

Article:
http://www.publicbroadcasting.net/i.../0/1565260/IDAHO.Local/Say.Hello.On.Halloween

:angel:
 
My head still hurts when I come here..I may have to detach. I did email our local CASA office today...the director has been trying to get me to do it for years. She was the Head Start Coordinator when my oldest (yeah, my 8-year-old) went. Perhaps I can focus this anger I feel into something positive for a hurting child.

Loved the "vigilante" posts. If I were more of a BAMF, I might be inclined to join the lynching mob. :)

KUDOS for you gg,
I too am a CASA volunteer , and applaud all those who do also!!!! I too, would rather channel my anger into something more positive!!! :woohoo:
 
Ada County will not seek the death penalty in Robert Manwill murder case

Ada County prosecutors decided Friday they will not seek the death penalty against first-degree murder suspects Daniel Ehrlick and Melissa Jenkins for the beating death of 8-year-old Robert Manwill earlier this year.

http://www.idahostatesman.com/eyepiece/story/938872.html

:furious:
 
Too bad. I wonder why they decided not to pursue the DP? I'm sure if the jury convicted them of Robert's death, they would feel the DP was appropriate.

I didn't read the article - maybe later :(

Salem
 
Yes, too bad. That in itself is criminal. I can't imagine why they would make this decision. I don't believe that it was any accident.

(snipped from article at above link)

It's the prosecutor's job to determine whether the aggravating factors exist for a jury to sentence someone to death, like if the killing was heinously cruel, the defendant has a propensity to commit murder, or the killer showed an utter disregard for human life.

So what part of the above does Jenkins and Ehrlick not meet? I would say that the treatment of Robert and his ultimate murder is definitely heinously cruel and that the killer certainly disregarded his life.

The whole thing makes me sick.
 
Prosecutor won't seek death penalty against Manwill suspects
Story Created: Oct 16, 2009 at 4:27 PM MDT
Story Updated: Oct 16, 2009 at 9:39 PM MDT
<snipped>
Greg Bower, Ada County prosecutor, announced the decision Friday afternoon.

Bower said the decision is based "upon our careful review of federal and state death penalty law."

"There are many legal and factual reasons why the prosecutor's office will not seek the death penalty in this case," Bower said.

Both Jenkins and have waived their right to a speedy trial. Their attorneys and the judge will meet Nov. 5 to schedule a date for the trial, which probably will be in the spring or early summer.


Video: Prosecutor won't seek death penalty against Manwill suspects
http://www.2news.tv/news/64611337.html?video=YHI&t=a

Article:
http://www.2news.tv/news/64611337.html
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Mom, boyfriend won't face death penalty in Robert Manwill case
Updated 14 hours 24 minutes ago
<snipped>
"The determination not to seek the death penalty in either of these cases is based upon our careful review of federal and state death penalty law, the specific facts and circumstances of this case, and is informed by our experience, as the Ada County Prosecutor's Office is the only office in the State of Idaho that has obtained both a conviction and the penalty from an Idaho jury," Bower said in a prepared statement to media. If Ehrlick and Jenkins are found guilty of murder, they will face life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Article:
http://www.idahopress.com/news/?id=27064
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Prosecutor will not seek death penalty in Robert Manwill murder case
05:44 PM MDT on Friday, October 16, 2009
<snipped>
Ada County Prosecutor Greg Bower announced today that his office will not seek the death penalty against Daniel Ehrlick and Melissa Jenkins.

According to a grand jury indictment, Robert died from a series of prolonged abuse that included repeated hits by Erhlick to his abdomen and head, which causing internal bleeding, bruising and swelling of the brain.


Video: Greg Bower's statement about the decision
http://www.ktvb.com/video/index.html?nvid=407667

Article:
http://www.ktvb.com/news/crime/stories/ktvbn-oct1609-manwill_case.2228653d5.html
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Ada County will not seek the death penalty in Robert Manwill murder case
Published: 10/16/09
<snipped>
It's up to defense attorneys to find the mitigating factors a jury might consider to spare a life, like if the defendant suffers from mental illness or was a victim of child abuse themselves.

It is unknown exactly what evidence has been exchanged so far. Jenkins&#8217; attorneys have filed a motion with 4th District Judge Darla Williamson to make prosecutors give them a copy of the search warrant documents which detail how Boise Police established the probable cause to search Jenkins&#8217; Boise apartment and report what evidence they found there &#8212; evidence which contributed to her and Ehrlick&#8217;s arrest.

Those documents, normally made available after a suspect is arrested, have been kept secret in this case.

The next hearing in the case is set for Nov. 5, when a trial date likely will be set


Article:
http://www.idahostatesman.com/Crime/story/938872.html

:angel:
 
I am beyond furious! I feel like Robert has been failed again. What a SHAME!
 
Prosecutors won't seek the death penalty in the Robert Manwill murder case
Melissa Jenkins and Daniel Ehrlick could be sent to prison for life if convicted of the murder of 8-year-old Robert Manwill.
Published: 10/17/09
<snipped>
Ada County prosecutors used all 60 days they had before announcing Friday they would not seek the execution of first-degree murder suspects Daniel Ehrlick and Melissa Jenkins - and they didn't say much to explain why.

Ada County Prosecutor Greg Bower declined to define "the many legal and factual reasons" why he is not seeking the death penalty, saying he didn't want to say anything that could "prejudice the verdict" in one of the most high-profile crimes in years.


Article:
http://www.idahostatesman.com/robertmanwill/story/939209.html

:angel:
 
:wave: Welcome To WS's twins2008!

welcome005.gif


:angel:​
 
I suspect they are not seeking the DP because the prosecution wants to ensure they get a 1st degree conviction especially for the 'mother' and are fearful that a jury will not convict her with a DP charge because her involvement (as horrendous as it is) did not include the actual murder of Robert. However, I don't understand why they don't seek the DP against that fat, ugly, revolting, insecure piece of **** called Daniel.

It is cases like these which make me waver back and forth in support and against the DP. If I had to chose I would say I am against it however there are many cases, like this ( and any cases having to do with animal cruelty) where I have no qualms whatsoever about these people being killed for what they have done. I can even go so far as to wish a horrible torturous death like the one they inflicted upon their victims.
 
A project aims to unify neighborhoods while remembering slain child Robert Manwill
BY ANNA WEBB - awebb@idahostatesman.com
Copyright: © 2009 Idaho Statesman
Published: 10/20/09


The murder in July of 8-year-old Robert Manwill inspired an unprecedented community outcry and volunteer effort. When Robert was first reported missing, thousands of people pinned green ribbons to their shirts in support and joined the search for the boy.

People who run local programs for children decided to seize that momentum and started meeting and talking about ways to make the Treasure Valley safer for kids.

Now, the group, which includes representatives from the Idaho Children's Trust Fund, Court Appointed Special Advocate Program and others, has an official name, Our Kids: Our Business, and its first grassroots project.

[http://www.idahostatesman.com/localnews/story/941853.html/ [B]
 
Elementary school to celebrate life of Robert Manwill
Posted on October 29, 2009 at 7:19 AM
Updated today at 7:33 AM
<snipped>
A celebration will be held Thursday to honor the life of young Robert Manwill.

New Plymouth Elementary School will be celebrating Manwill's life at 10:15 a.m.

A new swing in front of the school will be dedicated to Robert and balloons will also be released in his honor.

The public is welcome to attend.


Article:
http://www.ktvb.com/news/Elementary-school-to-celebrate-life-of-Robert-Manwill-67210532.html
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Manwill death prompts community building effort
Story Created: Oct 23, 2009 at 5:53 AM MDT
Story Updated: Oct 23, 2009 at 9:02 AM MDT
<snipped>
It's been more than two months since 8 year old Robert Manwill was laid to rest. Child advocates are hoping to turn his tragic death into something positive this Halloween.

It's been more than two months since the community said goodbye to Robert. To help keep his memory alive, child advocates are hoping you'll take part in the "Say Hello on Halloween" project.


Video: Manwill death prompts community building effort
http://www.2news.tv/news/local/65757122.html?video=YHI&t=a

Article:
http://www.2news.tv/news/local/65757122.html

:angel:
 
Swing to be dedicated to Robert Manwill
Staff in New Plymouth pledge to work even harder to support students

[snip]

"A plaque at the top of the large green swing has the boy's photo, and the inscription reads, "Forever in Our Hearts." "

[snip]

"None of us have gotten to the point where we can talk about him without crying," said Tammy Arnzen, a secretary at the school. "This is our little way of keeping a part of him."

[snip]

She describes him as a sweet, quiet and gentle boy who wore his feelings on his sleeve and loved to give hugs. When frustrated or upset, he would cry and put his head on his desk, she said.

In the wake of Robert's death, the staff at New Plymouth want to be sure students feel safe and supported at school, Aguas said. The theme at the school for the 2009-10 school year is "a caring heart."

"We've always had a caring staff. ... It's paying a little more attention to everything a child says," Aguas said.

Morales and Arnzen say their grief about Robert's death has been punctuated with anger.

"It's never going to make sense, no matter what comes out (in court)," said Morales, a mother of two boys.

Aguas recently misplaced her lanyard and keys. She was frantic - not because she'd have to re-key all the doors at the school - but because she feared she'd lost Robert's ribbon.

"This ribbon is going to last the rest of my career," Aguas said.

Entire Article here: http://www.idahostatesman.com/robertmanwill/story/953350.html
 
Elementary school celebrates life of Robert Manwill
Posted on October 29, 2009 at 9:30 AM
Updated Thursday, Oct 29 at 5:22 PM
<snipped>
A celebration was held Thursday to honor the life of young Robert Manwill.
The eight-year-old was found dead in a canal back in August.
New Plymouth Elementary School dedicated a new swing to Robert and released balloons in his honor.


Article:
http://www.ktvb.com/news/Elementary-school-celebrates-life-of-Robert-Manwill1-67212082.html
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
*NOTE: Much more info at link!

Idaho prosecutors opting not to seek death penalty
Only 2 Idaho counties have asked for the death penalty in murder cases since 2003, and Ada hasn&#8217;t pursued it since being denied twice in 2005
Published: 11/03/09
<snipped>
He ultimately wouldn't detail "the many legal and factual reasons" why he is not seeking the death penalty for Daniel Ehrlick and Melissa Jenkins, saying he didn't want to prejudice the jury pool.

But trying to predict exactly what that jury will do is likely a major factor why Bower won't seek the death penalty in the beating and murder of 8-year-old Robert Manwill.

Ehrlick and Jenkins will return to court Thursday to find out when a jury trial will be scheduled. The trial is expected to last several weeks and likely will be set for some time next summer.


Article:
http://www.idahostatesman.com/robertmanwill/story/959060.html

:angel:
 
Idaho prosecutors opting not to seek death penalty
Two counties have pursued it since &#8217;03
November 4, 2009
<snipped>
Fewer Idaho prosecutors are seeking the death penalty in murder cases in recent years.

Ada County Prosecutor Greg Bower decided not to pursue the penalty against Daniel Ehrlick and Melissa Jenkins, who are charged in the murder of Jenkins&#8217; son, 8-year-old Robert Manwill.

Bower said many legal and factual reasons were behind his decision but he declined to offer details.


Article:
http://www.spokesman.com/stories/2009/nov/04/idaho-prosecutors-opting-not-to-seek-death-penalty/
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Capital punishment may be gone for good in Idaho
Wednesday, November 4, 2009 1:00 am
<snipped>
Is the death penalty a thing of the past inthe Gem State? Sure looks that way. Ada County Prosecutor Greg Bower's recent decision not to seek the death penalty against the mother and her boyfriend accused of killing 8-year-old Robert Manwill last summer shows just how difficult prosecutors believe it is to convince a jury to put a convicted person to death in Idaho.

And there are other considerations as well. Recession-battered small counties simply can't afford the hundreds of thousands of dollars that prosecuting a death penalty case requires.


Article:
http://www.magicvalley.com/news/opinion/editorial/article_939f8e7a-e293-57a1-89bd-94c3d6857973.html

:angel:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
139
Guests online
1,913
Total visitors
2,052

Forum statistics

Threads
601,365
Messages
18,123,593
Members
231,030
Latest member
Ouisie
Back
Top