Madeleine74
Knower of Things
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2011
- Messages
- 11,556
- Reaction score
- 20,084
TA "using" JA or not still doesn't supply justification for his murder. That's the salient issue. We don't have to like TA, we don't have to believe he's a good guy (even though JA said he was...she said he was wonderful), we can all pretend he's a sleazy womanizing player and yet...
That still doesn't provide legal justification for what JA did to him. Remember SHE drove 1200 miles to see him. SHE served herself up on a platter. SHE brought a gun and a knife. SHE committed the crime. SHE tried very hard to cover it up.
At the end of the day when you look at the facts of the killing you still have to determine if JA had a reasonable fear for her life and if she used reasonable force to save her life. She admitted on the stand she could have run out the door and down the stairs and "doesn't know why she didn't." That nailed her right there. She could have gotten away!
She didn't have any reason to fear for her life and she sure didn't use 'reasonable' force. She butchered him. That's anger, not self-defense. And, she premeditated the murder because within the first couple of stab wounds she knew if she kept going she would kill him and she intended to kill him.
And that makes her guilty of first degree murder.
That still doesn't provide legal justification for what JA did to him. Remember SHE drove 1200 miles to see him. SHE served herself up on a platter. SHE brought a gun and a knife. SHE committed the crime. SHE tried very hard to cover it up.
At the end of the day when you look at the facts of the killing you still have to determine if JA had a reasonable fear for her life and if she used reasonable force to save her life. She admitted on the stand she could have run out the door and down the stairs and "doesn't know why she didn't." That nailed her right there. She could have gotten away!
She didn't have any reason to fear for her life and she sure didn't use 'reasonable' force. She butchered him. That's anger, not self-defense. And, she premeditated the murder because within the first couple of stab wounds she knew if she kept going she would kill him and she intended to kill him.
And that makes her guilty of first degree murder.