Steely Dan
Former Member
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2008
- Messages
- 30,559
- Reaction score
- 108
Wow, this is fascinating. I love to see a psychopath questioned.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I'm not sure Juan Martinez is the right guy to be parsing a journal that sounds like it was written by a 12-year old, but the utterly brilliant thing he has done is that in one morning's worth of cross-examination, he has succeeded in completely reversing the image of JA as a meek, vulnerable, submissive individual who might be cowering in fear about text messages being sent by someone who is 1,000 miles away.
After this morning, would you believe that poor widdle Jodi was oh so skeered of Big Bad Travis' thunderous temper, as expressed in text messages, that she felt he was compelling her to travel 1,000 miles just to placate him? That whenever Big Bad Travis got upset, she submitted to all kinds of debasing activities just because that seemed to make him less angry?
Or are we starting to understand that this was a determined woman so grimly obsessed with someone who didn't want her that she stalked him and stood outside his window in the night watching him surreptitiously. All of a sudden, it's a lot more plausible to believe she was quite capable of slashing his throat so ferociously from ear to ear.
In that sense, I think JM got off to a racing start. Took him hardly nothing to completely destroy that image that Nurmi spent a week cultivating, and expose the true face and temperament of JA.
At least that's my view. I see the legal experts on TV have reservations about how he started but I don't think they grasped the essence of it, that in one morning's session, he tore off the mask of meek submissiveness she's spent a week whining about because she wanted to set the stage for defense experts to convince the jury that she is a poor pathetic victim of abuse who can't even decide things for herself anymore. He tore that facade down and ripped it into shreds.
I'm going to say something probably unpopular, but I really dislike the way Juan Martinez goes about his cross-examination. It feels very uncomfortable. I understand he is doing his job but it feels like an interrogation that is crossing the line somewhat; I think he could expose JA's lies just as easily by going about things in a less abrasive, slightly more clever fashion. I know if I was sitting on that jury I'd be distracted by Juan Martinez and his attitude when what we really need to hear are the flaws and the inconsistencies within JA's answers.
JMO.
She doesn't want to nail time a time so he can't corner her with evidence.
He's got evidence to disprove this incident. I know it.
Games ... so many games. Her strategy is to wear everyone down with silly details but it's actually just crazymaking which is classic abuser behaviour.
In the same sense that Verne Troyer looks short.
If he were less abrasive, she would be too, and therein lies the problem. He needed to expose her to the jury, that she is NOT timid and shy like she tried to portray during direct. Look at her, no matter how abrasive Juan is, Jodi is smug, defiant, going toe-to-toe; she is absolutely not the shy timid thing she tried to fool the jury into believing she is.
IMO, Juan is exposing a lying, murdering sociopath for what she is.
That's her weak point. He has found it and now he will hit it again and again. She will grasp for that upper hand no matter how damning her testimony is. It is all about the moment and control at this moment. Nothing else matters. Her demeanor and argumentative nature could pave the way to her own death, but she is still more concerned with control at the moment that it doesn't matter.