I have always thought she planned to tell them Caylee was missing, but she was waiting until the last possible minute. I think she was planning to say Caylee was abducted that day, that she had fought and begged, and eventually she would have added her car was stolen too. Then she would let the police look for her awhile, grieve appropriately, and then be the girl with the sad story about her beautiful baby who was stolen and murdered. And hopefully she could weave in something about needing to buy a bunch of stuff at Target and Penney's to appease the kidnapper so Amy wouldn't be so mad.
ICA liked to be perceived as a victim. She told many people stories about the tragic death of Caylee's father, with the most frequent death scenario being that he died on the way to Caylee's birthday party. :tears: She has a tragic miscarriage story :tears:. She has a tragic story of her dad having some kind of stroke and being rushed to the hospital :tears:, her parents impending divorce :tears:, her brother sneaking into her room :tears:. I have no doubt she was formulating a plan to have Caylee's disappearance and then death become part of her tragic story as well. But she couldn't commit to it... yet.
ICA has a history of putting off telling people bad news... i.e. the night before graduation announcing she isn't graduating... 8.2 months pregnant before she tells her parents, getting well into the next relationship before breaking off the former one. She never got around to telling her parents that she lost her job. She is a conflict avoider, and a decision avoider.
I have a relationship in my life with someone like this... someone who puts off making all the hard decisions until they get made for her (so it isn't her fault! There was no other choice!) and who avoids telling anyone things that might make them mad at her or question her decisions. She will wait until she is completely backed into a corner with no other way out before she admits anything, and even then she is probably only telling you part of the story. Which is what I think LA forced out of her 7/16/08... he backed her into a corner and she blurted out a piece of her half-baked idea. Then she was kind of stuck with it.
It seems to me that she was just putting off the day she had to face the music. Each day I suspect she thought "I need to do something about this problem, but everyone will be so upset. Maybe tomorrow. Just one more day." Then she went on with living her life five minutes at a time.
ITA with the people here who think that because no one ever confronted her, she thought she was a great liar. The girl I know is the same way, and if you catch her in a lie, she will spend hours convincing you that you were wrong, that what you saw isn't what you thought you saw, you shouldn't have been snooping around, and btw, she wouldn't have to lie if you weren't always treating her like she could not make her own decisions.
What would she have done with one more day? Nothing useful to her or her defense, but she would probably have come up with a better story which could address more of the actual facts and had less points that could be proven false.