puzzleworldplanet
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2023
- Messages
- 148
- Reaction score
- 411
Ok. So now I'm feeling confident my theory is rock solid, I'm going to look at mainstream/popular theories and try to cross them off the list if I can.
1) Lake theory - total nonsense in my opinion. See attached images. Look at the thickness of the wall. You'd struggle to stumble over it if you were trying to. Even by some freak miracle you did, you'd land either on top of it, or in the bushes on the other side. This just isn't a viable thing in my humble opinion. Besides that, the lakes were dragged. I feel safe ruling this out.
2) A random person, not affiliated with the campus coming from the motorway/interstate - so unlikely that it's at the bottom of my list. They wouldn't know what time Josh was coming out of the party, wouldn't necessarily know if there's cameras pointing at them. It's not a theory I think works very well.
3) Monk involvement - Not impossible, but for the most part, the monks tended to groom young adults, not necessarily kidnap/kill them. I feel safe to cross this one off, but not ruling it out 100%.
4) Random hook up theory - no. No evidence ever really suggested this, and besides, how many random hookups end up in murder - not saying it's impossible, but this is so far down my list I think it's almost ridiculous
Which brings me back to the theory I proposed in the posts above. It's the only one that makes sense of the times Josh left the party, the lack of body being found in the water, the key card times, the time discrepancies, the wallet etc.
1) Lake theory - total nonsense in my opinion. See attached images. Look at the thickness of the wall. You'd struggle to stumble over it if you were trying to. Even by some freak miracle you did, you'd land either on top of it, or in the bushes on the other side. This just isn't a viable thing in my humble opinion. Besides that, the lakes were dragged. I feel safe ruling this out.
2) A random person, not affiliated with the campus coming from the motorway/interstate - so unlikely that it's at the bottom of my list. They wouldn't know what time Josh was coming out of the party, wouldn't necessarily know if there's cameras pointing at them. It's not a theory I think works very well.
3) Monk involvement - Not impossible, but for the most part, the monks tended to groom young adults, not necessarily kidnap/kill them. I feel safe to cross this one off, but not ruling it out 100%.
4) Random hook up theory - no. No evidence ever really suggested this, and besides, how many random hookups end up in murder - not saying it's impossible, but this is so far down my list I think it's almost ridiculous
Which brings me back to the theory I proposed in the posts above. It's the only one that makes sense of the times Josh left the party, the lack of body being found in the water, the key card times, the time discrepancies, the wallet etc.