NC - Shaniya Davis, 5, missing from her home 11/10/09 #4

[kiki the parrot]

Caller saying the same exact thing I first thought when I saw McNeill... looks like the Cheshire Cat.

arrot:

 

[Patty G]

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6Mb0sRXRjQ"]YouTube- Prime News 11/13/09 Shaniya Davis Part 1[/ame]
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZEKRjxlRB_Q"]YouTube- Prime News 11/13/09 Shaniya Davis Part 2[/ame]

 

[panthera]

But the attorney for Mario Andrette McNeill, 29, said Friday that his client would plead not guilty to kidnapping Shaniya Davis. Fayetteville Police Department spokeswoman Theresa Chance said McNeill admitted taking the girl.

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5gw47YRAXLmLUQ69FzCcPLZpmX2SwD9BUUG280

Admitted taking vs. Admitted to kidnapping. In the letter of the law, not much difference, but in in the spirit of the confession, means everything.

I agree. Thank you for the link.

 

[Kimberlyd125]

But, if he admitted taking her with permission it would mean a lot! IMO
If I take my nephew with my sisters permission, then she reports him missing, I can truthfully say I did not kidnap him.
KWIM
So, maybe in this case, he really thinks he took Shaniya but did not kidnap her.
Am I making sense???

 

[not_my_kids]

I think that smirk is just his mugshot face. JMO.

 

[panthera]

Alright, no LDT's.
Arrested the wrong guy.
Didn't follow up the tip until they were already gone...

Let's all applaud the various LE agencies involved in this case. They are providing a shining example of what not to do.
If they know enough that it just looks that way...then they need to get off their butts and go get her. The only thing that would excuse this level of seeming incompetence is if they know where she is, and if that is the case, then why are they just talking about her, go get her.

Someone on Nancy's show just basically said the same thing, that it was total incompetence starting with the arrest of Coe. MOO

 

[Money Girl]

Huh????

When I see a grown man carrying a little girl into a hotel, I think "dad."

Except, we know he is not her dad.

 

[Kimberlyd125]

Ok, gonna say goodnight since hubby thinks I'm gonna divorce him and marry websleuths. LOL
Y'all have a good night and I will try to catch up in the morning.
I'm thinking I may get a notebook in the morning and start from thread 1, post 1 and see if I catch anything. IDK
Something in this mess has to make sense.

Good night y'all.

Praying for Shaniya and all who love her.

 

[ella971]

You guys notice in the video his hair was not in dreads? In court it was. Just taken notice to little things.Also at 6:00 am on that day it was cold in the morning. I would think she was cold.Regarding her little legs.I pray she is safe.

 

[panthera]

But, if he admitted taking her with permission it would mean a lot! IMO
If I take my nephew with my sisters permission, then she reports him missing, I can truthfully say I did not kidnap him.
KWIM
So, maybe in this case, he really thinks he took Shaniya but did not kidnap her.
Am I making sense???

Yes, you're making complete sense. That's why I was questioning exactly what McNeill admitted he did. He wouldn't be admitting to kidnapping if he was handed Shaniya and told what to do with her, such as deliver her to somebody else. What I can't understand now, is if she's still alive, why would he sit in jail and not tell LE where she is. MOO

 

[mycroft]

I think that, in fact is mom!!!!!!!! Good find IMO.
Now what? Where is she? Where is public plea? What did she do?
IMO of course.

If that's her IMO:
-She does not look like the MS page that's floating around.
-She does not look like the still frame of the people getting into the squad car at the trailer park.
-That is a different middle name than appears earlier in the thread for mom.
-I don't think that the MS person is the woman in the squad car photo.

All of which is to say, I'm confused. It's seems like we've got three or four people in the mix here as possible ADs.

 

[trigger]

I think that, in fact is mom!!!!!!!! Good find IMO.
Now what? Where is she? Where is public plea? What did she do?
IMO of course.

I wonder where she use to live. Just throwing this out there..Maybe her sister plotted this whole thing with her ex bf? Maybe for the reward money? Maybe the mom really did put the child on the couch so she could be alone with her bf. An hour later she goes into livingroom and sees that she is gone, wakes up her sister and they call 911.They are seen outside looking around for the child. I think the sister has something to do with this but thats only MO. Mcneill is keeping quite because he will get his gf, the moms sister, in trouble.

 

[passionflower]

Only in hotel for 1/2 hour than left..........alone? with Shaniya???
Isn't that really odd to pay that money for that time?
If someone was there, he would have not registered and paid.
Was Shaniya dirty (feces, no clothes) and just there to bathe?
If she never left hotel, where could she be there?

Is this Mario (aunt's X) father to her baby?
Was he messing around with Shaniya??

 

[Lexiintoronto]

He was there for one hour, reporters only privy to photos of Shaniya and accused entering hotel.

IMO police are releasing the images because they can, and because they're laying the evidence on the table to force the to admit where she is. As the time passes without him admitting where she is, I'm guessing they'll release more images.

The man checks into a hotel with a child only wearing a t-shirt and panties, and they don't have luggage and the cops aren't immediately called? Or at least the child isn't questioned by the receptionist? Something?

ETA: just concerned for the little girl -- maybe nothing looked out of the ordinary to the receptionist. Maybe he did just look like a dad. I just want to tell her to *run!!* when I see that surveillance tape

 

[MommyInHighHeels]

"Fayetteville police spokeswoman Theresa Chance said Friday that 29-year-old Mario Andrette McNeill confessed to the crime and has been charged with kidnapping."

Above quoted from article at this link: http://www.wral.com/news/state/story/6412437/


""His attorney, Allen Rogers, said McNeill surrendered to police after investigators contacted his family.

"Obviously, it's a very serious situation. Our hearts go out to the family of this young girl. I certainly hope she's safely returned to her family," Rogers said, declining further comment.""

Above quoted from article at this link: http://www.wral.com/news/local/story/6411942/

Quoting myself to show above quotes from WRAL.

 

[not_my_kids]

The MS page that's floating around has a picture of a little girl IMO, NOT Shaniya, the caption reading that she gave "Grandma" a big smile.

I really don't think that MS is her.

 

[trigger]

You guys notice in the video his hair was not in dreads? In court it was. Just taken notice to little things.Also at 6:00 am on that day it was cold in the morning. I would think she was cold.Regarding her little legs.I pray she is safe.

Great catch. I think that is a big clue ella....Who does his hair? A friend, coworker, cousin?? If he had his hair done maybe the little girl did to?

 

[kiki the parrot]

Chances are if McNeill was w sister BDavis, and Coe was w ADavis, they at least knew one another.

Assuming what neighbor Moore heard at 3am was blanket being tossed I still can't make any sense out of this. If it was McNeil putting blanket in trash can why would Mom lie, and say Shaniya was fine at 5:30 am, then report her missing?

Could Mom be telling the truth re 5:30 on couch, and maybe blanket was being disposed of around 3am... but Shaniya wasn't removed until the time Mom says? I guess this is maybe what someone else was getting at. That maybe abuse occurred earlier--I'm saying possibly that night--and she was taken that same am so she couldn't tell what happened.

arrot:

 

[MommyInHighHeels]

In the National Amber Alert issued last night, they mentioned that his mode of transportation was unknown. I hope they have since become aware of this and are thoroughly searching the vehicle for clues.

 

[panthera]

He was there for one hour, reporters only privy to photos of Shaniya and accused entering hotel.

IMO police are releasing the images because they can, and because they're laying the evidence on the table to force the to admit where she is. As the time passes without him admitting where she is, I'm guessing they'll release more images.

The man checks into a hotel with a child only wearing a t-shirt and panties, and they don't have luggage and the cops aren't immediately called? Or at least the child isn't questioned by the receptionist? Something?

ETA: just concerned for the little girl -- maybe nothing looked out of the ordinary to the receptionist. Maybe he did just look like a dad. I just want to tell her to *run!!* when I see that surveillance tape

I know what you mean, and my main concern is he doesn't appear to have a change of clothes for Shaniya with him, so did he leave with her just wrapped in the blanket after an hour or what? And what was the purpose of checking in in the first place if not to bathe and change her clothes? :waitasec: