GrainneDhu
Verified Expert
- Joined
- Jun 11, 2010
- Messages
- 5,159
- Reaction score
- 53
About the 50/50 comment in the article: this is why media filtering is sooooo frustrating.
The KGW raw, unedited video with both parents was so much better than this because the viewer could hear the questions and see the entire, unedited answers. All the context was there.
Who knows what the context was in the People article? If he said "uh, well, I'm afraid they want an arrest quickly to pacify the public, um, uh, well, it looks like, I mean, ah, I'm afraid, uh, they are framing Terri... maybe, uh, it is a 50/50 chance right now." that would completely change the implications of the reported comment.
Remember that the Supreme Court has ruled that making up quotes out of nothing is protected free speech (Masson v. New Yorker Magazine) so long as the person to whom the quotes are misattributed cannot prove they were substantially harmed by them.
Compared to baldfaced making up quotes, picking a sentence or phrase out of context is at least true albeit a very limited truth that may actually convey a falsehood.
The KGW raw, unedited video with both parents was so much better than this because the viewer could hear the questions and see the entire, unedited answers. All the context was there.
Who knows what the context was in the People article? If he said "uh, well, I'm afraid they want an arrest quickly to pacify the public, um, uh, well, it looks like, I mean, ah, I'm afraid, uh, they are framing Terri... maybe, uh, it is a 50/50 chance right now." that would completely change the implications of the reported comment.
Remember that the Supreme Court has ruled that making up quotes out of nothing is protected free speech (Masson v. New Yorker Magazine) so long as the person to whom the quotes are misattributed cannot prove they were substantially harmed by them.
Compared to baldfaced making up quotes, picking a sentence or phrase out of context is at least true albeit a very limited truth that may actually convey a falsehood.