GUILTY NY - Evanna Tranberg-Bennett, 12, died, parents failed to get her medical care, 6 Dec 2019 Probation

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
How did Evanna develop end-stage renal disease? I assume she was never seen by an actual board-certified pediatrician thus any kidney problems were never diagnosed? And, any complaints she might have voiced to her parents/family were ignored or "treated" with their miracle macro's?? How quickly can kidney problems lead to renal failure in children?? JMO, But it seems incredibly rare or impossible to go from healthy child, to child with a cold, to child dying of renal failure without precursors.
In one of the first posts on the Facebook page, the family stated that they were told, at the hospital that Evanna might have suffered from an autoimmune disease. I actually think that's very much possible.

My understanding is that whatever Evanna had and that affected her kidnyes was chronic, meaning it was going on for a very long time.

The thing with kidney-related problems is that, generally, you can detect something is wrong with basic lab tests.

I have a really hard time believing Evanna, being a child, never complained about any symptoms way before the weeks and months before her death.

It is possible that it was the first time she showed severe ankle swelling, but it's very likely that she had been suffering with her legs, ankles and even feet swelling for a long time and nobody noticed or if the adults noticed, they didn't pay much attention to it. She might have complained of shortness of breath in the past, maybe she complained about being tired a lot.

I can totally see parents dismissing those symptoms, and I can totally believe that her symptoms probably went away and came back many times.

With kidney issues, it's also pretty usual to complain about lower back pain. And she probably had recurring UTI's.

Her end-stage renal disease could've been caused by several diseases/conditions, one of them being Lupus, for example.

It's one thing for a child to have a chronic disease, or an autoimmune disease and the parents not ever noticing anything wrong with the child until the child's condition gets severe and life threatening. That happens a lot with these types of conditions.

It's a whole different thing to see your child suffering and spend hours, days, weeks thinking if you're going to seek medical help or not. A 12-year-old child with a distended abdomen, severe ankle swelling and possibly many more symptoms can't just be ignored like that. It's not a weird rash that you try to wait for a few days to see if it goes away. That child was clearly dying and everyone just stood there.

I can't believe Evanna was going to the bathroom by herself, walking around, eating candy, etc. That poor child was most likely barely hanging on for dear life. She should've been in a hospital, and I don't think she would've been saved because her condition was clearly way too severe for anything to be done at that point.

What could've been done was taking Evanna to an hospital, she would've been provided some quality of life, she would've died in peace. This child DID NOT have to suffer. She didn't deserve that, she was just a little girl that couldn't do anything to get help, her parents had the responsibility to get her help and they didn't.

And yes, if Evanna went to the doctor for regular check-ups, her condition would most likely have been diagnosed and threated. She didn't have to die, and she certainly didn't have to die like this.
 
Evanna had pneumonia...which was not treated....which led to kidney failure, which can happen with children and the elderly
My understanding is that she suffered from end-stage renal disease, which means that the pneumonia was a consequence and not a cause in Evanna's case.

Meaning, her immune system was very weak, her kidneys were already failing, severely. Literally any virus, even something minor would've killed her. Any viral infection, such as the regular flu or a pneumonia would literally kill her.

Pneumonia has killed many generally healthy people, so for a already very sick child to get pneumonia on top of the issues that she already had... that was the recipe for the tragedy that ended up happening.

From the looks of it, the kidney damage was absolutely irreversible at that point. If her parents ever made a point for her to have regular checkups, if her symptoms were taken seriously (because I just can't believe this poor child never complained about anything up until that point), and if she received treatment, she most likely would've not died when she did.

People that have what Evanna had can't get the flu, because they will most likely die. They can't get pneumonia because they will most likely die. They have to avoid, at all costs, to have any viral infection because something minor can absolutely kill them. Messing around with unvaccinated animals is also a big no-no, specially cats.

If Evanna would ever be diagnosed, the doctors would recommend for her to take both the flu shot and the pneumonia shot. If she was still alive, she would be at-risk for COVID.

With that many people living in the same house, Evanna had absolutely no chance of surviving without treatment. 15/16 bringing germs and virus into that house, when there is a child with a very weak immune system... not a great idea.

It would actually be interesting to have someone with children with this type of condition to come here and share with us how life is. Or someone that has it.
 
Well... on their *** they posted an update last February saying Evanna's body had been released and they needed at least 5k in donations to hold her funeral. Then on their FB page they posted on November 1 that they haven't been able to have a funeral yet for Evanna so I guess there's been no funeral. There haven't been any announcements about a memorial service either. I'm not sure where poor Evanna's body is. MOO.
What the what?! It’s been almost a year and seemingly no funeral? Yuck. These people

IMO
 
If there wasn’t the actual news articles about this and a dead child, I would think this whole thing was made up. Unbelievable. I’ve been watching this from the beginning. Ugh. Poor Evanna. I feel terrible for all of the kids. Especially the one whose head is so misshapen that it will be hard to lead a normal life. All MOO. I had to say that “out loud”.
 
If there wasn’t the actual news articles about this and a dead child, I would think this whole thing was made up. Unbelievable. I’ve been watching this from the beginning. Ugh. Poor Evanna. I feel terrible for all of the kids. Especially the one whose head is so misshapen that it will be hard to lead a normal life. All MOO. I had to say that “out loud”.
Yep, I was relieved when it was hinted that DSS was pushing to get the child adequate treatment for his condition.

If the family admits that a “slap” could kill him, then it’s pretty obvious that he needs treatment.

I understand that it’s scary to have a child undergo brain surgery but I would be even more scared to have a child walking around with such a severe condition.

These children deserve to have quality of life, to be healthy.
 
Evanna had pneumonia...which was not treated....which led to kidney failure, which can happen with children and the elderly.
It is not known to me if her pneumonia was viral, bacterial or fungus related. But pneumonia can progress to sepsis, or infection of the blood and body systems. Her kidneys were affected by the pneumonia, causing acute renal failure
I don't think it was pneumonia that caused her kidneys to fail. In the autopsy report from January 2, 2020, it was (allegedly) indicated that the scarring and other findings were "most likely due to Vesicourinary Disease.(VUR)"

According to the autopsy report, "Kidneys were mottled, markedly atrophic, and scarred on the cortical surface."

Of course there are many types of kidney disease, but scarring generally develops over months or years, so it sounds like Evanna had an undiagnosed underlying kidney disorder.

I think she developed the pneumonia as a secondary infection following the virus, which is not uncommon.

This is one reason why I wondered if Evanna had developed a fever at any time during her cold, as this would be a sign of secondary infection. From everything I have read there is no mention of anyone keeping track of Evanna's temperature.

IMO
 
The TB children are hopefully in good hands, and being seen and treated medically on a regular basis. I hope that littlest one receives the best care. I also wish the TB family could just recognize that this is all for the benefit of the remaining children. A 12 year old child has died! And IMO, instead of being cooperative and answering some legitimate questions, they have chosen to evade and cry " conspiracy"! The proverbial @##!storm if you will is swirling around them, and THEY created to the storm!

ETA: IMO
 
Last edited:
Yep, I was relieved when it was hinted that DSS was pushing to get the child adequate treatment for his condition.

If the family admits that a “slap” could kill him, then it’s pretty obvious that he needs treatment.

I understand that it’s scary to have a child undergo brain surgery but I would be even more scared to have a child walking around with such a severe condition.

These children deserve to have quality of life, to be healthy.
In this case I think the doctors made the right decision not to perform the surgery at that time.

There are many dangerous risks associated with brain shunt surgery, and in my opinion it should only be performed when necessary and when the benefits outweigh the risks.

It's been 8 or 9 months since DSS allegedly tried to schedule the surgery, and I'm sure the child is being closely monitored for signs of neurological problems or symptoms that would necessitate a shunt procedure.

Imo
 
If there wasn’t the actual news articles about this and a dead child, I would think this whole thing was made up. Unbelievable. I’ve been watching this from the beginning. Ugh. Poor Evanna. I feel terrible for all of the kids. Especially the one whose head is so misshapen that it will be hard to lead a normal life. All MOO. I had to say that “out loud”.
A large head is typical in children with hydrocephalus. People with this condition can still live normal lives with regular therapy and treatment. Imo
 
Last edited:
In this case I think the doctors made the right decision not to perform the surgery at that time.

There are many dangerous risks associated with brain shunt surgery, and in my opinion it should only be performed when necessary and when the benefits outweigh the risks.

It's been 8 or 9 months since DSS allegedly tried to schedule the surgery, and I'm sure the child is being closely monitored for signs of neurological problems or symptoms that would necessitate a shunt procedure.

Imo
In the most recent pictures, the baby's head does look bigger.

I agree that this surgery or any surgery that isn't an emergency should be looked into very carefully and not be rushed. I'm glad he's being monitored. Medical records show that they were also checking to see if he had eye problems.

To me, it seems like the children are receiving medical attention while in foster care. A child that fainted is being monitored to find out what's causing it, at least two other kids got glasses, etc.
 
The following are descriptive words used in the TB family's latest post about Evanna. They are alarming, IMO...and show just how little the family truly cared for and about her. She was a middle child, clearly ignored and treated poorly IMO.

1..Evanna was " invading" the parlor...and keeping them up all night
2. Evanna would "use any excuse "to.....blah blah blah
3. Evanna was 'violating' our home quarantine... requiring
and ignoring (their) demands.
4. talking about Evanna's "thing" on the phone message with Tenji. What exactly is this "thing"?
5. a comment trying to explain an IM message regarding Evanna, claims that she was "Bothering" poor sick Papa Steve. The old man gets care and compassion...Evanna gets 'jack'.

Evanna was a poor sick girl, who should have been cared for by her family, including a phone call or a visit to the doctor, much much sooner than Dec 3. Instead, she was a 'bother', she was 'violating', and, IMO ignored. Sounds kinda negligent to me.

Did they just delete a lot of fb posts? The long, lengthy posts people were mentioning here appear to be gone. Is there more than one family page?
 
In the most recent pictures, the baby's head does look bigger.

I agree that this surgery or any surgery that isn't an emergency should be looked into very carefully and not be rushed. I'm glad he's being monitored. Medical records show that they were also checking to see if he had eye problems.

To me, it seems like the children are receiving medical attention while in foster care. A child that fainted is being monitored to find out what's causing it, at least two other kids got glasses, etc.
Well, apparently it was about eight months ago that doctors reportedly said there was "no increase in intercranial pressure" so it's possible that there is a little more pressure now. A rapid increase would likely indicate a significant increase of pressure.

Either way, he will likely have the surgery eventually, and hopefully it will be a success and there won't be many complications.

Yes, apparently a child fainted a few times last February but I haven't read if they ever found the reason why.

And yes, the state is required to provide medical care for any child in their custody.

Imo
 
Tricia and I have discussed the Chatham Community Board .

As members of the family have been charged, the Tranberg-Bennett comments on that board, with appropriate links, are now open for discussion.

Please do not link to or discuss comments by anyone else on that board as they are not the accused in this case. If the TB comments are answering a question on that thread, you may briefly paraphrase the question without naming the individual who asked, but do not link to that member's profile or discuss them in any way.

Any questions, please do not post them on the thread. Send them to me or any Mod/Admin via private messaging.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
185
Guests online
244
Total visitors
429

Forum statistics

Threads
608,657
Messages
18,243,159
Members
234,411
Latest member
FineArt
Back
Top