GUILTY NY - Evanna Tranberg-Bennett, 12, died, parents failed to get her medical care, 6 Dec 2019 Probation

[craftyhistorynerd]

Is there anywhere I can read about the previous involvement with CPS in Mass ?

they talk about it on some of the first posts on the page they talk about all the run ins with cps and how all the removals weren't their fault and the run ins were normal for a large family

 

[MsBetsy]

Is there anywhere I can read about the previous involvement with CPS in Mass ?

There are several posts and comments about previous cases on their FB from last December. They also included an article that was written by their attorney in one of the cases in the comment section. They say all the cases were dismissed. It's a lot to read but they go into detail about their side of the story.

 

[Lilibet]

Is there anywhere I can read about the previous involvement with CPS in Mass ?

Dec 28, 2019 Tranberg-Bennett Family FB page. There were 4 previous cases, two were said to involve someone calling DSS to get them evicted, one a case of someone calling DSS on them to get revenge on someone else...or something like that, and the fourth when a child fainted in a grocery store and was taken to ER. Take it all with a grain of salt. And now their fifth case in NY.

 

[Lusitana]

When it comes to your health, when you go to the doctor, you ask about what’s going on, you ask the doctor to explain whatever is happening and what the next steps are.

They only seem to question when there’s no use. Why didn’t they have any questions when Evanna was showing symptoms and suffering for who knows how long? I can totally relate with searching on Google when I get unwell, but if it persists then it’s doctor time, which means, a visit to a real doctor.
Why were they peeping on Xrays at the hospital? How about... just asking? They were probably too busy yelling about how the other kids couldn’t be vaccinated. While a child was dying.

If this happened when COVID already hit I could somewhat understand them delaying taking her to the hospital if they were concerned about COVID exposure, but I’m talking about a day or two, not weeks. But it was CLEARLY an emergency, you don’t worry about anything else when you have a child that needs urgent medical care.

It honestly breaks my heart to even think about what her last weeks in that house were like.

 

[readmylips]

Has anyone questioned why, since they pop up EVERYWHERE else with their vast volumes of "rebuttal", the family has not appeared here on WS?

 

[shotgun09]

According to the family, they were escorted out of the hospital. I have some ideas as to why, but I can come up with one that I saw enough of myself while working in the hospital. That is..A family became Disruptive.

I can see that very situation happening in poor Evanna's story.
Obviously, we have only heard the T-B version of events, which glaringly portrays DSS, EMS as the villains.

IMO, the family became disruptive when DSS was called in and began their questions and investigation. Instead of being cooperative and loving parents (and family), they chose the verbally combative and disruptive route. This was the 5th time that they were under the microscope, and their daughter lay dying. This was serious ****! IMO, the family went into 'defense mode' fairly quick and accusations against all others began . It got ugly there, no doubt.

Shortly thereafter the social media defense I have entitled " We are the victims" was enacted (thanks to Venuska), and we all 'heard' the one sided ( ever changing) story. And we ain't buyin' it

All IMOO

 

[shotgun09]

Has anyone questioned why, since they pop up EVERYWHERE else with their vast volumes of "rebuttal", the family has not appeared here on WS?

There were a few ' brief ' but wordy visits here by VTB. There might have been some issues with rule following....

 

[Alethea]

Has anyone questioned why, since they pop up EVERYWHERE else with their vast volumes of "rebuttal", the family has not appeared here on WS?

It's my understanding that VTB was invited to become a verified insider at WS but she declined.

 

[MsBetsy]

Has anyone questioned why, since they pop up EVERYWHERE else with their vast volumes of "rebuttal", the family has not appeared here on WS?

There are many comments about that on their FB page, posted on November 13.

It seems to be yet another example of their inability or refusal to follow rules. Then when there are consequences for their actions, they retaliate by pointing the finger in other directions, making accusations and threatening to sue for defamation.

It seems to be a pattern for them.

Imo

 

[Warwick7]

Has anyone questioned why, since they pop up EVERYWHERE else with their vast volumes of "rebuttal", the family has not appeared here on WS?

IMO VTB while here didn't like to follow the rules. The rules are set up for the safety of everyone.

 

[Warwick7]

Are there new posts from the family?
It has been too quiet.

 

[shotgun09]

Are there new posts from the family?
It has been too quiet.

My own musings regarding the quiet:
Could it be the T-B Family has finally been told to stop? And listened to advice? Or, I wonder if they were 'slapped' with additional charges of defamation of character ?
There was an awful lot of that going on in their postings, IMO.

It is actually nice not to have the almost daily nonsense to read.

 

[MsMarple]

Unfortunately, we will only see what the family cherry picks and crops from the reports. If it doesn’t fit their narrative, it won’t be made public by them. Imo

IMO you're right on the money. The autopsy reports likely explain the circumstances leading to Evanna's death as opposed to a few cherry picked blurbs. The pathology findings have little meaning if no context is given. For example, one screen shot they posted notes that Evanna's labia were swollen and edematous. Is that significant? Without knowing the circumstances it's difficult to read anything definite into the findings. IMO.

For that matter what if Venuska herself caused chest trauma to Evanna while performing CPR before the EMTs ever arrived? Why haven't they produced evidence that Evanna had the broken ribs, punctured lungs and "massive" internal bleeding they keep insisting the EMTs caused?

In some cases involving a child's death LE and DSS/CPS release various reports, including the 911 call and prior involvement with DSS. I don't know how Evanna's case will proceed but if the adults do end up going to trial we may get to see the real documents in their entirety. In the meantime what the family posts IMO should be taken with a very large grain of salt. MOO.

 

[Alethea]

IMO you're right on the money. The autopsy reports likely explain the circumstances leading to Evanna's death as opposed to a few cherry picked blurbs. The pathology findings have little meaning if no context is given. For example, one screen shot they posted notes that Evanna's labia were swollen and edematous. Is that significant? Without knowing the circumstances it's difficult to read anything definite into the findings. IMO.

For that matter what if Venuska herself caused chest trauma to Evanna while performing CPR before the EMTs ever arrived? Why haven't they produced evidence that Evanna had the broken ribs, punctured lungs and "massive" internal bleeding they keep insisting the EMTs caused?

In some cases involving a child's death LE and DSS/CPS release various reports, including the 911 call and prior involvement with DSS. I don't know how Evanna's case will proceed but if the adults do end up going to trial we may get to see the real documents in their entirety. In the meantime what the family posts IMO should be taken with a very large grain of salt. MOO.

If there's a trial I may have to drive the 4 hours to attend.

 

[Warwick7]

IMO you're right on the money. The autopsy reports likely explain the circumstances leading to Evanna's death as opposed to a few cherry picked blurbs. The pathology findings have little meaning if no context is given. For example, one screen shot they posted notes that Evanna's labia were swollen and edematous. Is that significant? Without knowing the circumstances it's difficult to read anything definite into the findings. IMO.

For that matter what if Venuska herself caused chest trauma to Evanna while performing CPR before the EMTs ever arrived? Why haven't they produced evidence that Evanna had the broken ribs, punctured lungs and "massive" internal bleeding they keep insisting the EMTs caused?

In some cases involving a child's death LE and DSS/CPS release various reports, including the 911 call and prior involvement with DSS. I don't know how Evanna's case will proceed but if the adults do end up going to trial we may get to see the real documents in their entirety. In the meantime what the family posts IMO should be taken with a very large grain of salt. MOO.

Is the Edma in the screenshot recorded as being all over her body?
The alledgedly claim the the medical feild filled her up with water. Or does it show edema in her feet and ankles? Which would contradict TB Family.

My other concern is 'Evanna's labia were swollen"...
Swollen Vulva: Causes, Other Symptoms, Treatment

 

[shotgun09]

Is the Edma in the screenshot recorded as being all over her body?
The alledgedly claim the the medical feild filled her up with water. Or does it show edema in her feet and ankles? Which would contradict TB Family.

My other concern is 'Evanna's labia were swollen"...
Swollen Vulva: Causes, Other Symptoms, Treatment

The swelling and edema is very often evident in a brain dead patient. The brain is not communicating with the rest of the body anymore. All systems are now controlled by medicine while patient is kept alive. Fluids are added to keep blood flowing...while the heart is now failing it's ability to pump and send oxygenated blood. Excess fluid builds up then throughout the body...in all areas.. It is a never ending fluid balance in Critical Care. Wide spread swelling and edema is not unheard of at all.

In Evanna's case, from what was originally told by the family as well as from EMS, her abdomen was already enlarged and swollen, along with both of her lower extremities well before the sad end of her life.

 

[MsMarple]

Is the Edma in the screenshot recorded as being all over her body?
The alledgedly claim the the medical feild filled her up with water. Or does it show edema in her feet and ankles? Which would contradict TB Family.

My other concern is 'Evanna's labia were swollen"...
Swollen Vulva: Causes, Other Symptoms, Treatment

The particular screen shot I mentioned only addresses the labia. The autopsy sketch posted by the family shows serous fluid seeping from Evanna's legs. Other drawings include the dressings from various treatments including a CRRT catheter (for dialysis) and IV locations in her wrists while she was in ICU during the last days of her life. Screen shots of other pathological diagnoses note that her spleen was congested and of course that she had ischemic cortical edema.

And why did the family post about Evanna wanting to grocery shop on the way to the hospital because she thought the food there would be bad? Were they anticipating that she'd be admitted and if so, why? They wrote that they saw no emergency until she collapsed and had actually planned to take her to the hospital to be checked only because the snowstorm/blizzard kiboshed the trip to MA to see their regular doctor.

That's why I say so much of what the family posts is meaningless without having the entire picture of what happened before, during and after December 3, 2019.

 

[Warwick7]

The particular screen shot I mentioned only addresses the labia. The autopsy sketch posted by the family shows serous fluid seeping from Evanna's legs. Other drawings include the dressings from various treatments including a CRRT catheter (for dialysis) and IV locations in her wrists while she was in ICU during the last days of her life. Screen shots of other pathological diagnoses note that her spleen was congested and of course that she had ischemic cortical edema.

And why did the family post about Evanna wanting to grocery shop on the way to the hospital because she thought the food there would be bad? Were they anticipating that she'd be admitted and if so, why? They wrote that they saw no emergency until she collapsed and had actually planned to take her to the hospital to be checked only because the snowstorm/blizzard kiboshed the trip to MA to see their regular doctor.

That's why I say so much of what the family posts is meaningless without having the entire picture of what happened before, during and after December 3, 2019.

So this part is not a screen shot but autopsy sketch posted by the family?

 

[MsMarple]

So this part is not a screen shot but autopsy sketch posted by the family?

Two separate types of posts.

They posted screen shots of excerpts from the first autopsy report on December 6, 2019 showing specific pathological findings/diagnoses of Evanna's internal organs , such as her brain, spleen, thorax, liver, pancreas, etc.. That also included the report on her genitalia, both internal and external where the doctor noted the swollen labia.

They also posted a screen shot of the body drawing from the same autopsy, made by the doctor who performed it. The drawing/sketch showed external observations of Evanna's body at autopsy such as the serous fluid leaking from her legs, where IV lines were inserted, dressings from dialysis, bruises and petechiae, etc.

It's a little confusing since I can't post the screen shots directly. For those who have FB they can see the autopsy body sketch observations in the photos from November 15 (also 23 and 26):
Tranberg-Bennett Family

The screen shots of the pathological findings can be seen in the photos here from November 28:
Tranberg-Bennett Family
https://www.facebook.com/TranbergBennettFamily/posts/229444161908482
Tevania Tranberg-Bennett

 

[greyarea]

Wow... this may be a bit premature but I believe they took the page down. Additionally many of VTBs links have been removed or set to private.

I wonder if their lawyer finally got wind of the sight or something or a gag order was instituted. I guarantee this wasn’t their idea (This is not a guarantee) MOO

*EDIT as if right now the TB (not TBF) page is still up