It was also discussed on Crime & Justice the previous night as well. Here's the link to that transcript.
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1805/15/ptab.01.html
But first to Western Pennsylvania, where a driveway turned into a death scene, that is where Rachel DelTondo was found bleeding Sunday night after reportedly going out for ice cream with a friend. And that is where Rachel DelTondo was pronounced dead of multiple gunshot wounds to the chest. Police have taken a cell phone and will try to figure out what happened. But why anyone would kill her is still a huge mystery. Tonight, a stunning 33-year-old teacher who neighbors call nice and beautiful.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
DWAN WALKER, ALIQUIPPA MAYOR: Miss DelTondo was a bright light, she didn`t bother anybody. She didn`t hurt anyone. To lose a life like that, Rachel DelTondo, they speak to the heart of Aliquippa, because we are so close.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
LALAMA: I want to bring in my panel Kirstin Kennedy, Cops and corpse reporter for the Beaver County Times, also CNN law enforcement analyst, and former assistant Director of the U.S. Marshalls, Art Roderick and defense attorney, Anahita Sedaghatfar.
OK. Kirstin, so, I`m hearing that up to 12 shots were heard. So my first question is, did anybody see it? What`s the motive? What do we know?
KIRSTIN KENNEDY, REPORTER, THE BEAVER COUNTY TIMES: You know, police have made it really clear they`re not going to tell us whether they have a suspect. And until they have a suspect, they`re not going to release any sort of type of motive. The multiple gunshot wounds, that is coming from the autopsy and that is coming from the Coroner, who said that, you know, she sustained several gun shots. Neighbors reported hearing 10 to 12 shots. And police have said that they`re interviewing witnesses, but they haven`t said who.
LALAMA: Well, you know, there`s a bit of a back story that I think I should explain before we go to you and our other guests. So, there`s arteries coming out of this big vein which is the horrible murder. She was on paid suspension from her school for allegedly being found in a steamy windowed car with a minor. The D.A., Kirstin, you say, is apparently now saying, oh, that is all wrong, that is rubbish, shouldn`t have happened. Now there`s a state imvestigation in Pennsylvania of the local P.D., because of a leak on the report. Now, where does all this go? Where does it take us? And is it connected in any way?
KENNEDY: You know, I can`t really say that it`s connected. I know I received an anonymous e-mail in November that contained that police report. I don`t know who sent it to me. We did double-check with the Cyber School, where she was employed and they had said that she was on suspension. And, you know, really to that, they`re not saying much.
LALAMA: But what about, I mean, will there be charges on this other matter?
KENNEDY: You know, police are really vague of whether it`s even related. So I couldn`t even begin to speculate.
LALAMA: Wow, I know. I mean, we want answers, and it`s just so strange. So I want to go to Art Roderick, CNN law enforcement analyst, former assistant Director U.S. Marshalls. So there`s one other odd element to all of this.
[18:05:06] And that -- this happens to be a woman who was going to get married. The engagement was called off allegedly, because of this incident with the minor. And she fought and fought and fought. Apparently there was a TV segment, to get her money back for the dress. So just kind of on a cursory level, because we don`t know anything really, something just sounds strange to all of this.
ART RODERICK, CNN LAW ENFORCEMENT ANALSYT: Yes, the back stories are the strange part of this whole particular case. And as a criminal investigators, as all criminal investigators, we don`t believe in any coincidences whatsoever. So all this -- all these back stories will be looked at to see, if there`s any connection to the crime. Now, the interesting thing I find it is six to 12 rounds being fired, somewhere in that vicinity, indicates to me, that it`s sort of a semi- automatic handgun or rifle. If it`s a handgun, that that means to me that they unloaded the whole clip, the whole magazine, every round in the magazine into Rachel, which is sort of an overkill shooting here, which could indicate that there`s a personal issue going on here, and that the perpetrator knew Rachel when the crime was committed. So I`m sure law enforcement is looking at all this. And also the indication that they`re tight-lipped just means to me that they have some very good leads that they`re tracking down right now.
LALAMA: Well, wouldn`t it also be potentially a murder for hire that someone shows up with an automatic weapon?
RODERICK: It could be, yes.
LALAMA: Anahita Sedaghatfar, defense attorney, well, we don`t have anybody for you to defend yet, but just looking at it, in your experience, look at all these different odd elements, I think somebody`s covering their, you know what, somewhere.
ANAHITA SEDAGHATFAR, DEFENSE ATTORNEY: It seems to me, I agree with you. This is not a coincidence. This was in a residential neighborhood. It was a quiet neighborhood. And there were so many people that had a motive to harm this woman. Could it be the jilted ex-husband? Could it be the individual that released that confidential police report about her and allegedly this young man? Could it be the wedding dressmaker that she had a conflict with? We just don`t know. But it`s good that the police are saying at least they have her cell phone, Pat. So they are going to look at her texts messages, they are going to go through her e-mails, her online activity and hopefully get some clues from that electronic data.
LALAMA: And back to Kirstin. Kirstin, do we know that it`s her cell phone and not of the presumed assailant?
KENNEDY: You know, they would not say who the cell phone was -- who possessed it, but they did say that it was going to the state capital in Harrisburg for further analysis than what they`re able to do locally.
LALAMA: Can you expound -- and I don`t want to sound like a conspiracy theorist, but I`m looking at so suddenly the State of Pennsylvania is investigating Aliquippa P.D., where my family settled after coming from Italy by the way, Kirstin. And so, I`m just wondering, somebody`s in trouble for something. But we just don`t know what avenue to go down at this point. And for the right reasons, they`re probably staying hush-hush at this point, but any clues at all?
KENNEDY: Well, my understanding with that initial investigation, through the Pennsylvania State Police was, that they were looking into some issues with the city and that they really weren`t able to release a lot of details. And I think it may be a jump to connect these two cases at this point.
LALAMA: Right.
KENNEDY: Just because I really don`t know.
LALAMA: Absolutely. I understand. So let`s go back to Art Roderick, CNN law enforcement analyst. So that cell phone is going to be really, really important, because it would probably reveal moments leading up to her death.
RODERICK: Yes. Not only the cell phone, but they`re also looking at security cameras from the surrounding neighborhoods to see who was driving in and out of that neighborhood at that particular point in time. They`re also looking at traffic cameras, any toll cameras in the neighborhood. So it`s important that they gather all this video from the surrounding neighborhood to find out who was in that neighborhood at that particular time. And there`s other technical things they can do from a cell phone perspective. Looking into the forensic portion of that cell phone to figure out exactly what she was doing for that whole day and who she came in contact with, you know, hours prior to this horrific crime occurring.
LALAMA: Kirstin Kennedy, what time of day did this happen again?
KENNEDY: About 10:45 p.m. on Mother`s Day, Sunday night.
LALAMA: OK, so it`s dark out. Can you describe the neighborhood for me? Is it dark? Is it remote? Give me an idea.
KENNEDY: It`s a very -- as it`s been described, a very quiet, calm neighborhood. It is off a main road and just down the road is sort of a small business district, but it`s pretty suburban and it is pretty quiet. When I was there yesterday, I didn`t take any particular notice of street lights. You know, I don`t know, you know, if the homes had lights on at the time. I would imagine they did.
LALAMA: Wow. Did she live with her mom, Kirstin?
KENNEDY: That is my understanding.
LALAMA: All right, does she have any children? Do we know anything about her family? I know her family is called traditional Italian.
[18:10:07] KENNEDY: Sure.
LALAMA: Anything else we know about siblings, anyone else that might be a known enemy?
KENNEDY: You know, those are some of the questions that I and other news outlets were asking today. As far as I know, she has no children. I don`t know really much more details about the family.
LALAMA: Anahita, this seems to me to be an act of vengeance. You know, this is, I mean, 12 shots in the driveway, premeditated, right?
SEDAGHATFAR: Yes.
LALAMA: I mean, we are all guessing at this point.
SEDAGHATFAR: It`s all guessing. But it does seem passionate, it does seem personal, kind of like overkill. One thing about the police kind a not saying much, Pat. I don`t think that is shocking. They may know much more than they`re letting us know in the media --
LALAMA: Yes.
SEDAGHATFAR: -- because this is a murder investigation. And they certainly don`t want to do anything that would compromise it. So I would suspect that they have interviewed witnesses. There might be someone that is a person of interest or possibly a suspect. We in the media just don`t know about it yet, because they don`t want to let that out.
LALAMA: Well, it`s always that fine balance, you know, between our right to know and their right to adjudicate and follow an investigation properly. And we get frustrated, because we want so much more and they have to do their diligence to make sure we don`t screw up the case. Excuse my lingo, so let me go back to Art Roderick on that. My guess, I agree with Anahita. I think they know more than they`re saying. What you and your experience?
RODERICK: Absolutely. If there was a public safety issue, they would have come out with some description of an individual and more information about the crime itself. So, I mean, having dealt with this in my career, usually when we`re quiet on the law enforcement side. That means we`re investigating something pretty good in the background, and we won`t put out information until we hit a dead end or we run out of leads.
LALAMA: So give us law enforcement 101, Art, you know, you`re the guy, you are the detective, a man to call on to the scene. Where do you begin?
RODERICK: Well, the crime scene is the key part. I mean, we did had some reports that law enforcement was looking into the bushes. I`m assuming they`re going after shell casings that are extracted from the weapon that usually comes out to the right side of a pistol or a semi- automatic rifle. So I`m sure they`re trying to track down every round. The ballistics are going to be important. Both shell casings that they find at the scene and also any of the bullets they can take out of her body to match that up with a particular handgun. And some of these serial shootings that we`ve had in the past, in Tampa and Phoenix, the ballistics is a key part of determining how the crime was committed, but also who committed the crimes. So, the crime scene is going to be the most important thing right away, and then you can follow that on with the cell phone and video cameras and her social media footprint also.
LALAMA: Absolutely. Well, I was just going to ask Kirstin, have you seen investigators carrying boxes out of her mother`s house? You know, do we know -- you said you`re not sure that she lives with her mom, but you think so. What do we know about that?
KENNEDY: Well, I know that the district attorney today did say that it appears that most of the casings, if not all are the same caliber. But he did say that he can`t confirm that they came from the same gun. That is going to come from the state police crime lab and could take months to really confirm.
LALAMA: So Anahita, it`s so hard, because we have nothing to work with here, but you would think that there maybe was a warning or maybe she had some sort of words with someone. I mean, I`m just pulling straws out of whatever right now, because we don`t have any information. But as a seasoned defense attorney, throw out some -- throw out conjecture and let`s make sure we understand we`re just guessing at this point.
SEDAGHATFAR: Well, we are guessing, but again, like I said before, there are people that had a possible motive to harm this woman. And so the police are certainly going to look at her family, the people she had disputes with, I think there might be something to the fact that she was having an alleged affair with an underage boy. Could this possibly have something to do with that? This police report about that incident was private. It was confidential, because she was never charged in that case. So how did it get released? So, I think that might be something the police really are looking at, at this point.
LALAMA: Well, Kirstin, very quickly, how was it released?
KENNEDY: It was sent by e-mail to some of the school officials and then other members of the media. When I responded to the address, everything I sent came back as undeliverable.