Peter said,
Fine he would have needed about 6 minutes to subdue her. But you left in your "timeline" no room for him to turn his car around and find SG. But if you say only about 5 minutes more for that, and that would be a very short estimation by all means, he would have eleven minutes.
Peter what I said......... MP would have needed a total of six minutes to catch, subdue and leave Oak Beach, not eleven minutes
3 minutes to catch and subdue.
1 minute to reach gate by vehicle
2 minutes to raise gate and leave.
For a total of six minutes.
The factor you are forgetting in your equations for comparing GC speed and SGs speed of traveling is start times. This is crucial; before GC left his house to walk to the gate house did GC change his shoes, put a jacket on, lock the house, or turn out the lights in bathroom? These all could have delayed his walk to the gate house. Even if GC ran all the way, if he leaves 5 to 10 minutes after MP catches up to SG, he would have not seen MP leave.
Without knowing the start times it is impossible to compare arrival times.
The problem is now we are getting is conflicting information, now reports of LE arriving at 5:32am ( I do not believe the 5:32am time is correct) and GCs call was after BB who called at 5:22am. This makes no sense as there is no way police could respond to BBs phone call in 10 minutes.
GC only went to the gate house after his 911call. He had no idea anybody else called. So therefore he could be only responding to his own call when he went to the gate to let LE in.
My opinion is that GC called 911 before BB called, and then he went to the gate house to let LE in. It is my opinion because of the distances involved; LE arrived around 6:00am, possibly the 6:07am that has been stated.
If MP caught SG at 5:25am, three minutes after BB called 911, he could have exited Oak Beach quite easily by 5:31-5:35am. If GC arrived after 5:36am, he would not have seen MP leave.
The point I am making without knowing the exact time of GCs 911call and the exact time GC arrived at the gate, we are in a knowledge vacuum.
Can anybody, maybe ps149 can help, please give the following times.
1) Official time of GC 911 call
2) Official time of BB 911 call
3) Time of GCs arrival at gate to allow LE in.
4) Official Time of LE arrival at Oak Beach gate
When we have this information we can accurately calculate if MP had time to abduct SG, or not.
For those who believe MP could not be involved in SG'd death because he did not leave his home for months after. Most criminals do not leave ther homes after committing crimes. Some maintain the same residence for decades.
MOO
Fine he would have needed about 6 minutes to subdue her. But you left in your "timeline" no room for him to turn his car around and find SG. But if you say only about 5 minutes more for that, and that would be a very short estimation by all means, he would have eleven minutes.
Peter what I said......... MP would have needed a total of six minutes to catch, subdue and leave Oak Beach, not eleven minutes
3 minutes to catch and subdue.
1 minute to reach gate by vehicle
2 minutes to raise gate and leave.
For a total of six minutes.
The factor you are forgetting in your equations for comparing GC speed and SGs speed of traveling is start times. This is crucial; before GC left his house to walk to the gate house did GC change his shoes, put a jacket on, lock the house, or turn out the lights in bathroom? These all could have delayed his walk to the gate house. Even if GC ran all the way, if he leaves 5 to 10 minutes after MP catches up to SG, he would have not seen MP leave.
Without knowing the start times it is impossible to compare arrival times.
The problem is now we are getting is conflicting information, now reports of LE arriving at 5:32am ( I do not believe the 5:32am time is correct) and GCs call was after BB who called at 5:22am. This makes no sense as there is no way police could respond to BBs phone call in 10 minutes.
GC only went to the gate house after his 911call. He had no idea anybody else called. So therefore he could be only responding to his own call when he went to the gate to let LE in.
My opinion is that GC called 911 before BB called, and then he went to the gate house to let LE in. It is my opinion because of the distances involved; LE arrived around 6:00am, possibly the 6:07am that has been stated.
If MP caught SG at 5:25am, three minutes after BB called 911, he could have exited Oak Beach quite easily by 5:31-5:35am. If GC arrived after 5:36am, he would not have seen MP leave.
The point I am making without knowing the exact time of GCs 911call and the exact time GC arrived at the gate, we are in a knowledge vacuum.
Can anybody, maybe ps149 can help, please give the following times.
1) Official time of GC 911 call
2) Official time of BB 911 call
3) Time of GCs arrival at gate to allow LE in.
4) Official Time of LE arrival at Oak Beach gate
When we have this information we can accurately calculate if MP had time to abduct SG, or not.
For those who believe MP could not be involved in SG'd death because he did not leave his home for months after. Most criminals do not leave ther homes after committing crimes. Some maintain the same residence for decades.
MOO