Please remember, there was also the FINAL witness... BB. We have never heard from her and don't know what she saw. She may have seen SG run INTO CPH's house for all we know? (Of course, we DON'T know, so that is just pure fantasy)
well, FINAL is subjective, depending on whether or not you believe this kid:
(taken from new york post article 12/16/10)
... She spent some time inside before fleeing after Coletti said he had called the cops.
Gilbert was never seen again.
"That was the last time she was seen. We saw her footprints in the sand," said Justin Canning, 20, who lives down the street.
"She was in a panic. We thought she was on drugs."
--some questions with his quote: 1)who is "WE"? (canning and ?)
2)if you only "saw her footprints in the sand" and not her, how did you know they were hers?
3) if only "saw...sand", and not her, then how do you know she was in a panic?
4) "WE" who (again) thought she was on drugs? (had to be close to think that)
5)and how can you(s) think she was on drugs if you(s) didn't see her, but rather only her footprints in the sand?
---is he lying?exaggerating? wanted just some attention by talking to a reporter?
--if he just stopped with the footprints comment, he later could have said he meant he saw them the next day, maybe? but, still, how would you know they were hers?--like a few people here, I have some thoughts on this, but can't violate the TOS, since it encompasses those not mentioned in msm