GUILTY South Africa - Jayde Panayiotou, 28, Port Elizabeth, 21 April 2015

Welcome to Websleuths!
Click to learn how to make a missing person's thread

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Christopher Panayiotou, 28, returned to court today for the continuation of his bail application. He told the court last week that the conditions in the holding cells at St Alban’s prison were “despicable”. His co-accused are Thando Syoli, 31, and Sizwezakhe Vumazonke, 30.

He’s facing the following charges: Conspiracy to commit murder, robbery with aggravated circumstances, kidnapping, murder and defeating the ends of justice.

CP’s parents are both present. CP looks pale and haggard, and appears to have lost weight, no doubt due to “despicable” food.

The following is what’s happened so far today:

Court starts more than one hour late. State Prosecutor Marius Stander and Alwyn Griebenow, Defence attorney, are present in court. Stander tells the court that as Defence counsel, Terry Price, isn’t present (as he’s not in Port Elizabeth for some inexplicable reason), Advocate Roelofse will replace him today. Magistrate Beaton isn’t happy.

Magistrate Abigail Beaton is concerned that CP won’t be fairly represented. Advocate Roelofse says CP is happy for him to act in Price’s absence but the Defence want a postponement as the State has filed 5 affidavits and the Defence haven’t had an opportunity to respond. The State want to proceed but the Defence want the matter postponed until this afternoon. The Magistrate is most unimpressed and tells the Defence they’re playing for time. The State say there’s no need to stand down and waste the court’s time, that they can read their case onto the record and then the Defence can proceed.

Beaton reiterates that she’s not happy with the change in representation and doesn’t want to see a situation where the accused later claims that he’s not been afforded a fair trial. Stander says 3 of the 5 affidavits were submitted timeously. Of the remaining 2, one relates to allegations from an unknown man who allegedly made contact with CP and offered to make evidence disappear. The remaining affidavit is from Cyprus and relates to CP’s status and passport.

Beaton again says she won’t allow any stalling of time and repeats that she’s really not happy. Beaton calls a 15 minute adjournment to allow the Defence to consult with CP. When court resumes, Magistrate Beaton tells Defence Advocate Roelofse that he’s speaking with a forked tongue when he asks for a postponement until 2.00pm as nothing will change between now and then. She gives him 1 hour to contact Price as to his availability. She says she’s concerned about court time and that other applicants are being denied access to the court. She asks the Defence, “What makes your client so special?” Before the court adjourns for 1 hour, Roelofse says that he isn’t sure if he’ll be able to contact Price between now and then as Price was flying back to Port Elizabeth and he may not be in a position to provide any additional feedback to the court. Beaton says that whoever proceeds will have to see it through to the end.

This sounds very much like Barry Roux tactics on the part of the Defence, but this Magistrate won’t tolerate any nonsense. Good for her. Judge Masipa could learn a lesson or two from this Magistrate.

Court has resumed again. Roelofse says he's now been given full instructions on the State's case. CP's lawyer says he's happy to go ahead but Magistrate Beaton isn't comfortable with this so adjourns the matter until tomorrow when Terry Price will be available.

And a bit of breaking news: The co-accused (hitman) has laid assault charges against the police and will sue for a "massive amount".
 
The lawyer for CP's alleged mistress, Chanelle Coutts, says she claims that she was intimidated by the police and that she wasn't warned of her rights before making a statement to them. She says she's been threatened by members of the public and told that her throat would be cut.

Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 2m 2 minutes ago
Alleged #JaydePanayiotou hitman has had his parole for illegal gun possession revoked after his arrest -now eligible for release in Jan 2016
 
For those who aren't across this story yet, here it is from the beginning. Apologies if you already know all this.

Jayde and Christopher had been together for 11 years and married for 3 1/2 years.  She was an elementary school teacher who taught Grades 4 to 7 and also coached hockey. 
 
On 21 April 2015, Jayde rang or sent a Whatsapp message to a fellow-teacher as they were both members of a car-share club and the fellow teacher was going to pick Jayde up at 6.30am that morning.  The last Whatsapp message between them was at approximately 6.21 but when she drew up in her car 9 minutes later, Jayde wasn’t there.  The teacher phoned Jayde's husband and asked him where she was and he said she must still be standing outside, waiting.  Her cell phone was turned off and no further contact could be made with her. Shortly afterwards, R1,700 cash was withdrawn from her account from a cashpoint and the police have photographic material of the suspected kidnapper from that cashpoint. The following day, her body was spotted by a police helicopter in a field outside a township. 
 
As rumours of motives for the murder swirled, it emerged that police launched a huge sting operation to nab Jayde’s husband, Chris.  There were two other suspects, one of whom was Thando Siyoli, 31.  He agreed to work with police to set up the sting and contacted Chris to demand that he pay him more, claiming he needed it due to the hype and huge public interest surrounding the killing. Police watched as the two men met and Chris paid him the money. 
 
As Chris was bidding a tearful farewell to Jayde at her funeral, undercover police pretending to be mourners were monitoring his every move.  At the time of the funeral, Thando Siyoli, who was arrested by police acting on a tip-off, gave detectives a step-by-step recap of the plot and concluded a plea deal that involved the operation to catch Chris for orchestrating Jayde’s killing.  He claimed Chris had paid him to have Jayde killed.  Chris is the owner of the Infinity Cocktail Bar and Eatery where Siyoli worked as a bouncer. 
 
One of the men suspected of murdering Jayde has been on the run for two months following the hijacking of a pregnant woman from the underground parking lot at the Greenacres Shopping Centre in Port Elizabeth.  It turns out he was out on bail for a hijacking case when the Greenacres incident occurred.  The name of the third accused is Sizwesakhe Vumazonke.
 
Police have released photos of Jayde’s engagement and wedding rings. 
 
Chris has been charged with conspiracy to commit murder, murder, kidnapping as well as robbery with aggravating circumstances.
 
It's such a shame we have such a small number of people here. It's been classed as a high-profile case in SA and somewhere between 4,000 and 5,000 people marched in the streets when Jayde's body was found.

The hearing continues in 1:15 (5.00pm Oz time).
 
A bit more from yesterday.

Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 19h 19 hours ago
Advocate Terry Price tells @eNCAnews he's laid a complaint with Chief Magistrate against Magistrate Abigail Beaton #ChristopherPanayiotou

Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 19h 19 hours ago
Price says he wasn't briefed to appear for #ChristopherPanayiotou today - and is "very angry" that Beaton accused him of being unethical
 
from JudgeJudy:
"This is a very interesting case which is somewhere between OP and Dewani. It's very high-profile in SA with between 4,000 and 5,000 people taking to the streets when Jayde's body was found to demonstrate against violence to women. I've outlined the whole story to date on the relevant thread (mentioned above) for anyone who's interested. The bail hearing continues in one hour ... 9.00am SA time".

Is that 5.01pm AEST?
 
Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 17m 17 minutes ago
State expected to claim #ChristopherPanayiotou deliberately lied about having Cypriot passport and is a flight risk @eNCAnews

Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 14m 14 minutes ago
#ChristopherPanayiotou parents talk to his advocate Terry Price about the contentious Cypriot passport issue.
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CFgw2axWoAA8fOs.jpg:large
 
from JudgeJudy:
"This is a very interesting case which is somewhere between OP and Dewani. It's very high-profile in SA with between 4,000 and 5,000 people taking to the streets when Jayde's body was found to demonstrate against violence to women. I've outlined the whole story to date on the relevant thread (mentioned above) for anyone who's interested. The bail hearing continues in one hour ... 9.00am SA time".

Is that 5.01pm AEST?

Yes. It looks like they're starting late again. Prosecutor and Defence Advocate have left the courtroom and the Magistrate isn't present either. Once again, a packed courtroom. Here are the best 3 links:

http://m.news24.com/news24/SouthAfr...ou-returns-to-court-for-bail-hearing-20150521

https://twitter.com/karynmaughan

http://www.heraldlive.co.za/panayiotou-trial-happens/
 
Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 1h 1 hour ago
Swanepoel: #ChristopherPanayiotou and his wife were married for 2 years. He's been in a sexual relationship with employee for 3 years. :facepalm:
 
Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 1h 1 hour ago
Swanepoel: #ChristopherPanayiotou father found out about the affair - and told him if he didn't end it, he'd be disinherited

Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 1h 1 hour ago
Swanepoel: the mistress wasn't happy with #ChristopherPanayiotou being married, he used her friend to help placate her

Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 1h 1 hour ago
Swanepoel: #ChristopherPanayiotou approached Siyoli to kill someone in October last year.
 
Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 1h 1 hour ago
Swanepoel: #ChristopherPanayiotou said his wife was costing him too much money

Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 1h 1 hour ago
Swanepoel: #ChristopherPanayiotou agreed to pay R70000 to have his wife killed
 
Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 1h 1 hour ago
Swanepoel: hitman rented car to kill #JaydePanayiotou. There was a plan to kill her on a Sunday after lunch.

Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 1h 1 hour ago
State: #JaydePanayiotou was shot twice in the back and once in the head
 
Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 1h 1 hour ago
Swanepoel: bouncer Thando Siyoli immediately named #ChristopherPanayiotou as mastermind when arrested. He handed over the R30000

Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 53m 53 minutes ago
#ChristopherPanayiotou tells Siyoli he needs to disappear, will tell police he went to East London. "I will sort out your family"
 
Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 27m 27 minutes ago
Swanepoel: #ChristopherPanayiotou obtained Cypriot passport with sole purpose of evading his trial.

Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 47m 47 minutes ago
Swanepoel: facing a life sentence makes #ChristopherPanayiotou a flight risk

Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 36m 36 minutes ago
Swanepoel: #ChristopherPanayiotou was in financial difficulty. He didn't have enough money to keep a wife and mistress happy.

Karyn Maughan @karynmaughan · 24m 24 minutes ago
Swanepoel: this is a crime for which life in jail is the only suitable sentence #ChristopherPanayiotou
 
Today got off to another late start. Advocate Terry Price for the DT told Magistrate Beatson he hadn’t been briefed to appear yesterday and that the attorney should have told her. Beatson asked if Price told the media that he’d laid a complaint against her. Price said he told them that he’d spoken to the Chief Magistrate.

The following is paraphrased from Karyn Maughan’s tweets as Prosecutor Stander reads one of investigating officer, Kanna Swanepoel’s affidavits onto the record. It relates to facts that recently came to light. CP will be arraigned (appear in court, be formally charged and enter a plea) in the High Court.

CP and his wife were married for 2 years. He's been in a sexual relationship with an employee for 3 years. CP’s father found out about the affair and told him if he didn't end it, he'd be disinherited. The mistress wasn’t happy with CP being married so CP used one of her friends to placate her.

CP approached Thando Siyoli to kill someone in October 2014. CP agreed to pay R70000 to have his wife killed as she was costing him too much money. There was a plan to kill her on a Sunday after lunch and the hitman rented a car to be used. Apparently there were multiple plans for her murder, the last one being to kill her and make it look like a robbery.

Jayde was assaulted with blunt force trauma to the head. She was then put into the boot of the car, driven to a location, carried out of the car and shot twice in the back and once in the head. When Siyoli, a bouncer at a club owned by CP, was arrested, he immediately named CP as the mastermind and handed over R30000.

A tape recording between CP and Siyolo was then read onto the record. CP tells Siyoli he needs to change his SIM card, can't call him. Only missed call. He asks Siyoli what police asked him when he was questioned. CP says, “So they didn't ask anything about me? If I'm involved in any way?” He goes on to say, “Somebody said something because it's like a murder thing now. Is it black guys or colored guys?” (in an apparent reference to his wife's attackers). He tells Siyoli that he needs to disappear and that he’ll tell the police he went to East London. "I will sort out your family". He adds, “These boys made it big. They didn’t take the watch”.

CP’s family lean forward to catch the details of the transcripts as they’re read out.
 
Continued paraphrasing of Karyn Maughan's tweets.

Investigating officer Swanepoel said it's likely that if CP is released, he’ll attempt to evade his trial. If he leaves, he'll be leaving debt behind. He owes nearly R3million on houses and a car. Facing a life sentence makes him a flight risk. CP knows witnesses who are against him including his mistress, her friend, and the woman who would have picked his wife up the morning she disappeared. He says there’s a great opportunity to influence his mistress and she runs his store.

Swanepoel said:

• the conditions at St Albans where CP is being held are not as he claimed in his bail affidavit and that he hasn’t lodged a complaint with Correctional Services.
• Siyoli has agreed to testify against CP and the State and his legal team are in discussions.
• CP was in financial difficulty. He didn't have enough money to keep a wife and mistress happy.
• CP had his wife killed not to gain financially, but to curtail his ever increasing debt.
• CP never deals with his relationship with his wife in his bail affidavit. No wonder he had to google a eulogy.
• He intervewed the man who CP said had offered to make his case disappear for R45000 but his version was different.
• CP obtained Cypriot passport with sole purpose of evading his trial.
• He denies CP’s claim that he is shareholder in OK Grocer store and says he's just a manager.
• This is a crime for which life in jail is the only suitable sentence.

The head of St Albans prison said that when CP arrived, he bought his own duvet, sleeping bag and pillow. He was offered a single cell but turned it down. However he was put in single cell for safety.

The State have made it clear that CP and his co-accused will be tried together.

The State read out an affidavit from Tyrone Tiervlei, who claims CP offered him R40000 for "something because I'm in trouble". Tiervlei says it was “clear” that CP wanted to have a witness killed. CP claims it was Tiervlei who made the offer. Tiervlei is effectively saying that CP tried to arrange the hit while in jail. Karyn Maughn said his affidavit seemed very weak.

CP has prepared an affidavit in response to the State’s case against him.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
166
Guests online
1,152
Total visitors
1,318

Forum statistics

Threads
606,587
Messages
18,206,361
Members
233,895
Latest member
lizz28
Back
Top