There are almost too many of them....
Like BeanE always says "don't pay any attention to the man behind the curtain" or something like that...
LOL, yeah I know.
Ok, so my deep dark personal feelings on a possible religious angle to the whole thing:
1. This was a prank that went wrong. My parents were religious and we went to church as a family. One of the "traditions" within the youth group at the church we attended was that the Senior (HS) girls would "kidnap" the Freshman girls. Parents were notified of course. The Sr.s took us sometime past midnight, in our jammies, and made us eat disgusting things and forced us to t.p. (that would be toilet-paper for the youngsters on the board) the cutest-boy-in-town's house. We then went back to one of the Sr.s houses, where we would sleep for a few hours, before being fed a wonderful breakfast and returned, safely, home. Kind of like rushing a sorority, but with a religious bent. I've wondered (although it seems improbable) if this could have been something that started out similarly, but went horribly horribly wrong.
2. My deeper and darker HB religious scenario, is that she was taken so that she could be "taught a lesson". Or used as an example. I keep coming back to Drew's grandmother's comment:
Last night was the first night they’ve been apart for about a year.
Did she mean that literally? Were Drew and HB possibly allowed "conjugal" visits within this small and religious community?
Jealousy has been mentioned as a possible motive. I do wonder if we are talking about a certain jealousy of a different kind.
I've also considered righteousness. That can also be a very strong emotion.
Still more perplexed than ever, and waiting to hear what others might think....