I don't think so. Like most of the "according to Rusty" story collection - that witness is a mash-up of fact and fiction. The only credible eye-witness to have seen the girls (that I know of) was a guy from high school that was a manager at The Record Bar. It was next-door to Murphy's. That would be Robbie Ramsel. Same class as Tommy [1971], tall funny guy everyone liked. He was in that crowd Tommy hung around. Even if he didn't recognize Rachel - he would have remembered Tommy if she decided to say "Hello." What I can't stitch together is him calling Rachel's parents at 1am since he wouldn't have known how to reach them. If he was losing sleep over it, he would have called Tommy - a phone number in "the book." Also, the record department in Murphy's was just inside the entrance. Sears had a record department. Robbie Ramsel is one of many names on the lists that litter Rusty's personal case file. I doubt he was the late night caller, and I am certain he was not the tooth collector. I would expect the police interviewed him, as he would have made the short-list in the first few days. I'm sure Debbie remembers him. Ask her. She may have provided his name to police since she no doubt was trying to help. Robbie died in 1999. If he told police he saw the girls; he did. RIP. It's a mash-up even in the press. But he wasn't named. He's the guy I knew that is probably the guy referred to regarding record stores/departments. Finally, he would not have been "following them around," as the mash-up goes. He would have been at work that day.