Long before joining Websleuths I lurked and enjoyed the thoughtful discussion.
There was agreement, disagreement, point and counter-point.
The suppositions extended to give JY the benefit of the doubt with the totality of the CE feels disingenuous at best.
I don't think so, but I will be glad to run the list of reasonable doubt again.
1) Timeline
2)Clean NTO
3)No blood in SUV, nothing in his SUV to connect him to the crime scene
4)No hairs, fibers, traces found at hotel from Birchleaf
5)No fibers, traces from the hotel found at Birchleaf
6)Daughter not afraid when she saw him again
7)No proof or evidence daughter was drugged
8) LE issuing a search warrant for Michelle's car, thinking CY was removed from the home
9) 2 eye witnesses seeing cars at Birchleaf at a time Jason could not be there
10)Same camera tampered with at same hotel, same stairwell, previously
11)Twig was able to hold door open
12)Bush was in reach of door
13)Ordered cigars from Tampa at a previous date
14)Would have had to drive 510 miles
15) Seen on Video at gas station before leaving Raleigh
16)Seen on Video at CB
17)Seen on Video at hotel
18) NO VIDEO in King, NC, no customer, news delivery man later confirmed he never saw any such incident
19) Palmprint on sheetrock EXCLUDED Jason Young
20) LE checked airports for flight plans
21)Unidentified print on medicine cap/dropper
22) DNA on rock not a match
23)Shoes could not be a match, unless expert had the exact shoes
24)State trooper called, confirmed it was an accident
25)Emails revealed there was an accident that Jason saw, to explain computer searches
26) SIZE 10 SHOES IN BLOOD