Thank you, MsMarple. After reading your post, things make more sense to me now. I must have missed that article. Btw, I always enjoy your take on things.
IMO they will have to have the evaluation done, just to put what happens in the record, and to complete it -- however "complete" it will be, again, for the record. This part therefore, when done, will not be grounds for an appeal. I feel sure the judge will insist that it be done, no matter what the Defense Team says, etc. One more thing accomplished for justice for Jenise, her family, and the People of the State of Washington.
I can't imagine why the DT would advise GG not to answer any questions, but I know nothing about these evals. Seems to me, it would help him more than hurt him -- if he answers the questions -- but we'll see, I guess. And I agree with the judge -- just get it done ASAP. And get on with the rest of it. Now. Grrrrrr.
JMHO
I am just jumping off your post, but what is "acting normally?" His wrestling coach said he was very quiet until he got on the mat then he changed. Is that really normal? Yes, he was driving, but he was driving with his mother. Someone to watch over him and make sure he was doing it OK. He was on anti-depressants, even while in school, and I'm pretty sure that isn't considered "normal". Don't get me started on texting, which IMO can be anything from normal to completely abnormal and no one seems to notice the difference half the time. I've looked at pictures of GG with his brothers. I don't see "normal" in GG's eyes, as I do in his brothers' eyes. (you know, the difference between looking at the camera and looking through the camera? It might be medication related or not.) That alone makes me understand why there were people who thought GG should be tested so there couldn't be any backlash about GG getting a proper defense later. JMO.Another thought.... What do you suppose made people think GG had to be tested in the first place? Was it because he sat there letting his nose run at the police station?? As far as was reported, he seemed to be acting normally before he was charged. Driving, texting, playing sports, going to school. What made someone think he could be incompetent? I don't get it.
bb
I've got a word for it: sociopathic
And it does seem to me that it would be better for him if he were found to be incompetent, but I don't know what types of questions, etc., those competency tests have in them. Anybody know anything about those tests?
IMO the only benefit to being found incompetent is that his trial will be delayed. If he's found incompetent, they'll just keep evaluating him periodically until he is found competent. (That's happens frequently here in Washington. We're finally starting a trial that's been postpones for years because of mental incompetence.) The evaluation consists of mental health testing and IQ testing. If the defense wants to go for an insanity plea, I believe they'll do their own testing by their own psychiatrists.bb
I've got a word for it: sociopathic
And it does seem to me that it would be better for him if he were found to be incompetent, but I don't know what types of questions, etc., those competency tests have in them. Anybody know anything about those tests?
And her momma. I can't imagine the pain of her lossThinking of Jenise today. Hope she is playing happily in heaven.
I respect the possibility of ''mental illness'' but am leaning at this point more towards an entitled spoiled brat who is playing Mr Macho - a person who has gotten his own way by being a bully. (MOO)
He's possibly advised his lawyer that he won't answer questions possibly because he barely answers hers??
He may be just a bad seed .... with a very bad attitude.
I respect the possibility of ''mental illness'' but am leaning at this point more towards an entitled spoiled brat who is playing Mr Macho - a person who has gotten his own way by being a bully. (MOO)
He's possibly advised his lawyer that he won't answer questions possibly because he barely answers hers??
He may be just a bad seed .... with a very bad attitude.
I think it's good that you raise your concern. This was part of a chain of responses where I was answering "with my regular poster hat on" with my experience as a parent with legal issues and mental health issues.
To clarify, my son was attempting suicide when I called the police. In his frustration, he threw the knife and it landed at my feet. That brought him a charge of aggravated assault, even though it didn't touch me and he was 15 feet away from me. Because a dangerous weapon was involved, he was charged with a strong felony with a domestic violence attachment. There was a maximum sentence for that charge of 25 years in prison, the presumptive sentence was 7 years. He pleaded (at the advice of the attorney I hired) to a class 6 non-violent felony with two years probation. The domestic violence charge was removed. He now has a felony on his record and has no work experience at all because he was only just 18 when this happened. Finding a job, even with mental health case workers involved, is nearly impossible with an active felony on his record.
We don't know anything about GG really. We have had many posts by other posters that he may have had some sort of break or medication reaction. We simply do not know. We don't know that he may not be a victim in some sense as well. Regardless of our opinions of whether that should affect his sentencing, his parents probably have their own opinion and ultimately, it will be up to the judge if any of that matters in his sentencing, etc.
With the context of the OP's post and wondering if the parents could have any impact in a plea deal or with the defense attorney, it is a given to me that any parent is going to want whatever happens to their child as a consequence to want the easiest path possible.
I do try to note that I'm posting with my "regular poster hat on" but feel that it's distracting to paste that into every single response when there is a chain. I am sorry that you felt it was inappropriate.