Welcome to Joe's thread- I hope you can put some new perspectives in place and a new set of eyes always helps! ALso, so glad to FINALLY have a MTG gamer on board. We had TONS of questions in the beginning that were answered by some nice people on the MTG board.
As far as the other board, I spent a whole weekend and went thru each 'players' thread and they all signed up within a week of eachother and its just a cruel game- They are mocking Joe and a couple others, but I have 5 pages of notes somewhere if you think they would be useful- I came to the conclusion it was a hoax, and they all list their locations as states all the close prox to eachother (WA, OR, WI, CO, ID, etc). They have a widely-distrubuted pic of Joe in fron of the Christmas tree and what kid in their 20s would use that pic? I think that says a lot right there- ITS A JOKE!!
I also called BPD and passed it on to Det Davis.