Now I see it clearly! He has on a red t-shirt with a black stripe around the chest area and he has too much hair for it to be PG.
I just had a strange thought - what if that is Garrido when he is younger and that girl that looks like Jaycee is the girl on the business cards? I think it only makes a little sense due to the time frame and that folks were saying that girl looked like it was more 80's... maybe it was more early 90's? Then again, I don't know why that pic would have been where it was and displayed unless Jaycee had it because she is one of the young girls in the pic?