Who is the Mystery Man who came for Chili ?

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Bumping this post, as some have wondered after the March 2/3/4 hearings and the revelation that Mark Hawkins wore a wire to JB's office and to the Anthony's... if he could have been mystery chili man.

(ETA: Prior to this I always assumed chili-man was Kalani too. FWIW.)

MH was not in FL in August, was he? I thought the wiring was done in October... I also assumed the fam knew MH prior to his enlistment, ICA and MH apparently went to school together from Jr High or upper elementary age on. (CA also appeared to know his ex wife Tara).

I don't think we've ever been given a name of the chili-man, but I believed it was Kalani too - based on the comments by GA of this mystery guest being someone they hadn't known or wouldn't have known if not for Caylee being missing (something along those lines) and Kalani suddenly having ICA's big ol' white sunglasses around this time frame.
 
As some have also mentioned, it is strange that Casey doesn't ask any questions about the mystery man, and, George offers nothing up aside from inviting him in to eat with them.

The reason Casey doesn't ask any questions, IMO, is cause she already knew about it.
Letter's were already being secretly passed between them, or, Baez told her about it.

Otherwise, she would have been a nervous nilly wanting to everything about who he was, what he wanted and what was said - and not because he may have been the evil kidnapper either.

And, as far as the Anthony's "inviting" anyone into their home out of the goodness of their hearts = they can sell that to someone else also IMO.
These people that took hammers and hoses after anyone that dared to cross their crime scene tape, inviting a stranger into their home??

A stranger, when Casey had them believing that everyone's life's were in possible danger, and that was why she couldn't talk.

A stranger, when the Anthony's have never trusted anyone before in their entire life's??

Nope, not biting on that one - didn't then, and certainly am not now either for that matter.

As far as it being Mark Hawkin's, not sure.
If it was, then, I would think that they would have been really suspious of him returning in October again, so soon, esp with him being military.

If it were me, and it was Mark Hawkin's on Caylee's birthday, I would be wondering what and why he is back again in October.
And, I would be on my guard, really, really on my guard around him ~

BBM - ICA's only concern that visit was ICA (like all the rest) - missing out on chili and "the party" she assumed they had... she had no reason to fear some stranger having dinner with C&G - remember she knew what happened to Caylee, knew exactly where she was and how she got there. If it was someone she knew, she'd just be peeved that he got her helping of chili. If this person had stories for G&C she would just deny and lie.

Some nice stranger? "Ho - hum, I hid under the blanket all day, thanks for nothing!"
 
OK I am back to believing it was Kalani.

But what a gigglefest if it were P.I. Lyons!

(OK sorry mods, will behave now.)
 
My vote goes to Kalani...

that guy was a train wreck...and a drama queen. would they want his dramatic self there? the sunglasses...that was stupid, he looked dumb and he could have bought those at any target. do we know if he isnt close to his family? he was friends with "river" right?
 
I don't think it was him because in one of the tapes he talks to her about meeting Josh Duckett. So it wouldn't make sense to then talk about a "nice young man". He would just say Josh Duckett came over. IMO

http://www.wftv.com/video/18035029/index.html

George, FBI interview, Part 7, 7:15 mark

George mentions Josh Duckett coming to the A house unexpectedly, but I don't know if this is what you are referencing. He didn't say anything about chilli, so maybe he isn't the same nice young man.
 
http://www.wftv.com/video/18035029/index.html

George, FBI interview, Part 7, 7:15 mark

George mentions Josh Duckett coming to the A house unexpectedly, but I don't know if this is what you are referencing. He didn't say anything about chilli, so maybe he isn't the same nice young man.

I didn't remembering him mentioning JD during the FBI tape..I was referencing a jailhouse video where he said he had me JD and ICA says "really?"
 
George : So how did you get through Last Saturday

Casey : I didn't I spent the day almost completely by myself Sniff with my head under the covers. I read my bible almost most of the entire day I was completely miserable just completely and utterly miserable just like I have been the entire time That was the first time outside of our visits that i really showed any emotion and I was open and I didn't care just because i couldn't' hold anything back i broke down it was the first time it was the first time that i truly truly broke down and it hurt and I am still recovering from that sniff
hearing about that fact that mum was making chilli and there was probably a bunch of people at the house

George : ah ah um no there wasn't there was just your brother and I and your mum and Mallory came over a little bit after work and that was it and so whatever else you heard that was totally wrong

Casey: Oh I was just told that mum was making food im just going off of what people were telling me what people were reeling off from the media so I was just speculating myself

George Well mum did ..made some of her great Chilli we had some bread and corn bread and you know just old things like that it was just us and just things like that and it was just us and there wasn't no one else

At this point Cindy says something about invited ... we invited that man

George: Im sorry there was a... mum just remembered a young guy who just called who was alone and wanted to have a little bit of a family he came over and we just talked for a bout a hour and we never met the man before you know he was alone so and we opened our heart to him to come in and talk a little bit you know

Casey: well that's what you should do

George: and that was something That he needed and in truth it was something we needed it also

Casey: Bible says to love they neighbor

George: yep

Casey: to share the things that you have

George : Right

Casey: to give unto others so you did exactly what you should do and by all means I know that meant more to him that any of you guys could ever imagine

George:well it certainly is I mean he was a really nice y...ah guy.... it was just really nice to talk to him and to get the chance to know him a bit .

This exchange was always curious to me and really showed us George's propensity to lie. He insists no fewer than four times that no one else was over, knowing full well that was untrue. When Cindy reminds him of the visitor, he minimizes his dishonesty with, 'Oh, Mom just remembered a young guy who just called blah, blah, blah.' So through no fault of his own he lied to her face no fewer than four times, he just simply didn't remember. If this is how Casey grew up, it explains a lot about how easily (and skillfully) she lies.
 
MH was not in FL in August, was he? I thought the wiring was done in October... I also assumed the fam knew MH prior to his enlistment, ICA and MH apparently went to school together from Jr High or upper elementary age on. (CA also appeared to know his ex wife Tara).

They did know eachother. Mark Hawkins was Tara's Husband. Tara was screwing around with Lee, got pregnant... (who knows by who) left Lee... Mark divorced her.
 
They did know eachother. Mark Hawkins was Tara's Husband. Tara was screwing around with Lee, got pregnant... (who knows by who) left Lee... Mark divorced her.

That would have made for a lively gathering. Pass the crackers?
 
I don't believe it was Duckett who came for chili..

In one of the first interviews that Cindy did on July17th, 2008 she tells the reporter, I think it was Louis Bolden of WKMG, that Josh Duckett had reached out to them but she didn't have a chance to call him back but she wanted to talk with him..
George was sitting next to her in that interview..

I listened to the interview yesterday..off to find it again.
 
Whoever he was I sure hope he was wired! Wouldn't that just just chap G & C's behind to find out he was mole for LE. The thought is delicious.
 
always thought it was the singer who sang at memorial - kyle thomas
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
130
Guests online
305
Total visitors
435

Forum statistics

Threads
609,474
Messages
18,254,639
Members
234,662
Latest member
LikeCandy
Back
Top