2011.02.10 Defense Accuses Detectives of Destroying Evidence

[Aedrys]

Oh for heaven's sake, THIS is the mystery motion?? :banghead:

Baez, pay attention. That there is a REAL lawyer responding to your motion. THAT SHOULD TELL YOU SOMETHING!!!!

I just can't wait until Joypath responds. You are looked down upon by lawyers and scientists, dude!

 

[Aedrys]

AND..while I don't want to give the defense any ideas or help, but they always seem to miss the mark. I am no lawyer, but I think the better argument might have been to try and have the garbage thrown out because it was tossed into the dumpster and retrieved later. INSTEAD, they say the yucky stinky garbage isn't yucky stinky anymore, so it needs to be thrown out. I......don't......get......these.......people. To me, this is how I see JB....it's as if you have an itch and you scratch, but it's not quite the right spot.....

I know...the defense reminds me of that car insurance commercial with that mischief guy playing GPS in a car. "I'm your GPS, and you haven't updated me in awhile. Turn Right. *something about car insurance* TURN RIGHT NOW!", *crash*, mischief cracks up laughing. It's like the defense starts going in a logical direction and then for no reason swerves and crashes. EVERY. TIME.

 

[kaRN]

Yeah, well, couldn't the defence accuse LE of many things without proof? I think it's another way to cast unreasonable doubt hoping for an ignorant and unthinking public and jury.

Where is their proof?

In one of their expert reports. Oooops never mind

 

[Aedrys]

In one of their expert reports. Oooops never mind

:floorlaugh::floorlaugh::floorlaugh: You guys are killing me!!!! That is awesome, kaRN! And so true!

 

[kaRN]

I hope they noticed the news media on this motion.

Anthony's "Rotten Pizza Theory" Tested By Eyewitness News

http://www.wftv.com/news/17053323/detail.html

I think it's safe to say that a juror with teenagers has probably found dead pizza somewhere in their home, under a couch, bed or backseat of the car. Or are my kids the only slobs?? :innocent: lol!
There's still time to repeat those tests and then bring in a cadavre dog for the jury. JB realy doesn't do much critical thinking does he?

 

[LancelotLink]

I think it's safe to say that a juror with teenagers has probably found dead pizza somewhere in their home, under a couch, bed or backseat of the car. Or are my kids the only slobs?? :innocent: lol!
There's still time to repeat those tests and then bring in a cadavre dog for the jury. SNAP!

They will need top make sure they conduct the experiment correctly. Lucky for us, JoJo has the rule book.
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BE-hqxNgyR8"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BE-hqxNgyR8[/ame]

1:44

HAHA! GA was hoping to put this a lil bit to rest here. Like, ok, guys, do not ask about this again.

 

[Reality Orlando]

AND..while I don't want to give the defense any ideas or help, but they always seem to miss the mark. I am no lawyer, but I think the better argument might have been to try and have the garbage thrown out because it was tossed into the dumpster and retrieved later. INSTEAD, they say the yucky stinky garbage isn't yucky stinky anymore, so it needs to be thrown out. I......don't......get......these.......people. To me, this is how I see JB....it's as if you have an itch and you scratch, but it's not quite the right spot.....

I totally agree. That's what I figured would be their reasoning also when I first started reading. Duh.:waitasec:

 

[sindydee]

Oh dear god, now what is he up to? :floorlaugh:

Am I reading this right? :waitasec:

So what he is now saying is:-

The police, on purpose, left the bag open, so the "garbage smell" has now gone from the bag of garbage in evidence?

Because of this, is he saying that it is impossible to tell if the dead body smell left in the boot of the car was left by the garbage?

Is this guy insane?

 

[TallCoolOne]

Well, I will almost guarantee you that no matter WHERE that CAR was stored, in no matter WHAT kind of conditions--WET or DRY, in a CARDBOARD BOX, or out in a FIELD--the trunk STILL STINKS TO HIGH HEAVEN of human decomposition.

Xactly!!! Thank you for this! That's exactly what I was thinking, forget the garbage, take that jury to the storage place where that car is and let 'em get a sniff of where that 'garbage' was stored and that will tell them all they need to know.

Slamdunk!!!!

 

[TotallyObsessed]

Well, I will almost guarantee you that no matter WHERE that CAR was stored, in no matter WHAT kind of conditions--WET or DRY, in a CARDBOARD BOX, or out in a FIELD--the trunk STILL STINKS TO HIGH HEAVEN of human decomposition.

I so wish the State could park that car there in the courtroom with the trunk and doors open and let the odor permeate the room. Through the ENTIRE trial. Me thinks the point would be driven home very, very fast.

 

[Jay D]

In my opinion, there is nothing lost , stolen or destroyed here. As LambChop pointed out, the "smell" could be recreated exactly with a simple trip to the grocery store.
There is nothing stopping JB from reproducing this evidence. In fact, he could kill two birds with one stone here by enticing possible new recruits at the convention in Chicago with a free lunch. If experts will work for a crate of oranges, they might sign on for a cheese and meat sandwich. Worth a try.
He could then put the left over packaging into a plastic trash bag and wait two or three weeks
Then all he would need is Judge P's permission to present the smell to the jury. Or not. :crazy:

 

[racegirl72]

Can someone elaborate more on the grave wax napkins in the trash/trunk? Is there a link to more info on this? To me, the grave wax napkins is HUGE for the SAO!

 

[Snaz]

Please forgive me if this has been addressed already, as I am a couple of pages behind.

How can the defense ask for all mention of the smell to be disallowed at trial since HHJP has already ordered the 911 calls can come in? Cindy's "It smells like there's been a dead body in the damn car" is there for all to hear.

TIA!

 

[kaRN]

They will need top make sure they conduct the experiment correctly. Lucky for us, JoJo has the rule book.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BE-hqxNgyR8

1:44

HAHA! GA was hoping to put this a lil bit to rest here. Like, ok, guys, do not ask about this again.

:floorlaugh: Woudn't the 10 gallons worth of Arm and Hammer thwart the true stench? ( She says with praying hands)
I've never seen that before. TKS!! Weirdest facial expressions I've ever seen in a sequence like that. It was like animation. Did you notice the long pause after he was asked about the pizza and he had to chose between telling the truth...or the pizza theory. Classic!!

 

[whiteangora]

Has this motion been made available anywhere to read?

 

[JDzWife]

OT somewhat, but I am really starting to get a bad taste in my mouth for Defense attorneys. I know they have a job to do, but JB really takes the cake in being slimy. How many times can one's jaw drop the floor in one case??

 

[Ssejors]

This is what was in the trash bag, no wonder Dr.Lee isn't going to be backing up his own statement...just a piece of old dried up pizza...Oh wait maybe it's ham and cheese..:loser:

http://www.examiner.com/crime-in-national/trash-found-casey-anthony-s-carpicture?slide=7676611#main

TY !

Any mention of the SMELL of this Garbage by the LEO who laid this out on the table? I'm sure if this stuff smelled as bad as a "damn""Dead body", enough to stink up an entire vehicle FROM the trunk for WEEKS on end, then I would think who ever emptied the contents onto the table would have documented the overwhelming smell.

 

[kaRN]

Can someone elaborate more on the grave wax napkins in the trash/trunk? Is there a link to more info on this? To me, the grave wax napkins is HUGE for the SAO!

Here you go racegirl http://orlandosentinel.image2.trb.com/orlnews/media/acrobat/2009-06/47589408.pdf
Starting on page 7 they discuss the paper towels in detail.

 

[Snaz]

OMG. Just when I think a dumber motion couldn't possibly come up...are you telling me, Mr. Baez, that you are WHINING that you won't be able to say the smell of decomp in the back of Casey's car is garbage because the meanie LE let took the empty containers out of the garbage bag and let them air out? Seriously? So you want the decomp smell out because there's no garbage smell to compare it to? You whined about the sniffer stuff, but now you're saying there's no stuff to sniff? You want to snuff the sniffer stuff because LE took the sniff out of the stuff? :floorlaugh::floorlaugh:

Are we on candid camera or something? Is Ashton Kutcher about to punk HHJP? This just can't be a real motion...yet it is...okay, I need to stop trying to make sense of it because I'm just going to go crazy...

Methinks the only stuff Baez is sniffing is about to give him an overdose! Rehab, Baez! You need an intervention!

I seriously think when the SA and HHJP read this motion, they won't know whether to laugh or cry...

BBM

Bwahahahaha!!!

Snuff the sniffer stuff because LE took the sniff out of the stuff....... Love it!!! :floorlaugh:

 

[strawberry]

O/T but not really...Someone at the office got Valentines flowers and a ballon. The balloon is a smiling squirrel and when I look over I just see this squirrel looking out over the cubby at me. I think it's spying on us. I bet he's glad he's off the hook and it was really the garbage that smelled and not us.