GUILTY Australia - J 32 y.o. Justin Stein, charged w/ murder of 9 y.o. Charlise Mutten, Mt Wilson, 13 January 2022 #3

  • #401
Was a very interesting morning, plus I got to sit next to the lovely Candace Sutton from The Daily Mail.
Haha, I remember at the very beginning of WT's inquest, I was sitting next to Candice & I asked her who the legal reps were etc. She just handed me her phone with their names. :oops:
 
  • #402
Do we know what is happening with the baby?
 
  • #403
Do we know what is happening with the baby?
I got the impression that she either had a miscarriage or she ended the pregnancy. I could be wrong but reading between the lines, it seemed that was what happened. None of the journalists would say anything but 'we have no further info on the baby' etc.
 
  • #404
Do we know what is happening with the baby?
Nothing was said in court today, but in Kallista’s Victim Impact Statement she did say something like she would never have the chance to be a mother…

IMHO
 
  • #405
I got the impression that she either had a miscarriage or she ended the pregnancy.

Ditto.

(Another possibility is that it was fostered out.)
 
  • #406
Nothing was said in court today, but in Kallista’s Victim Impact Statement she did say something like she would never have the chance to be a mother…

IMHO
Well actually, she did have the chance, and she blew it.
 
  • #407
Surprised that no media has talked about the usb device that was mentioned previously in court…. And Justice Helen Wilson brought up today, asking Stein’s Barrister, Ms Davenport, if she wanted to take things further regarding the usb device. Ms Davenport said no, and Justice Helen Wilson agreed, saying that she had listened to the audio contained on the usb and had found nothing out of the ordinary on it, and said it was usual prison talk, people calling out words like “dog” etc, and profanities in the background whilst Stein was on the telephone. The judge said she could not hear that any of the insults shouted out were actually aimed at Stein. So the usb was not used in Ms Davenport’s submission. Obviously the plan was to use the usb as a sympathy vote…. But it didn’t work.
 
  • #408
C's grandmother is suffering 'much mental anguish and sadness,' he said. 'It affects her mental and physical health (causing) depression and anxiety.

'The failure to protect C will haunt our consciences for the rest of our lives, causing depression and sometimes suicidal thoughts.
 
  • #409

'Daddy' turned murderer: Sentence looms for schoolgirl killer​


Justice Wilson said it was possible Stein shot the girl once while she was trying to flee, before approaching her and firing another shot directly into her head.
"It's almost akin to an execution," she said during his sentence hearing on Friday.
 
  • #410
  • #411
In court again today.

They have just brought Stein into the court room. He looks quite dazed. His hair is a bit wet….. ?sweating???

Clint Mutten is here in court, but Deborah Mutten isn’t here.
 
  • #412
In court again today.

They have just brought Stein into the court room. He looks quite dazed. His hair is a bit wet….. ?sweating???

Clint Mutten is here in court, but Deborah Mutten isn’t here.
Thanks for reporting for us Marg :)
 
  • #413
The judge has announced she will give an account of what happened to Charlise.

While the judge is saying major points in the case, she looks directly at Stein. Stein looks sooo spaced out. Such long blinks. Enormous pupils.

The judge has said that Stein’s testimony in which he gave the appearance of crying, he “used a tissue as a prop”… to wipe his dry eyes.
 
  • #414
The judge is still summing up, and has mentioned the missing underpants. Charlise had the clothes on that Kallista said she was last wearing, when her body was found, apart from her underpants. The judge said it it not possible to come to a conclusion why Charlise was found without wearing her underpants. The judge said this is abiding by the rules of “proof beyond reasonable doubt”.

Oh boy… I had never heard this….
Stein bought the sand from Bunnings using a gift card that he had been given as a Christmas present!!!!!!
 
  • #415
Judge still summing up…
“His record denies the prospect of leniency”
 
  • #416
He really does not deserve to live.
 
  • #417
At the beginning of the summing up (which is still continuing), the Judge stated this case “will be published to Caselaw”.
 
  • #418
The judge has stated that the absence of motive does not reduce the severity of the crime.
 
  • #419
Judge has said “remorse is taken into account when sentencing, and the offender has never shown this. He has never shown a shred of remorse.”

“The offender has a bleak chance of rehabilitation, which is also taken into consideration in sentencing”
 
  • #420
I think the judge is getting nearer to imposing his sentence.

The judge has stated…
“the community must be protected from him”
“The offender displays no humanity, morality and self-control”
“The offender is not capable of true empathy”
 

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
73
Guests online
2,720
Total visitors
2,793

Forum statistics

Threads
632,099
Messages
18,621,979
Members
243,019
Latest member
22kimba22
Back
Top