Your post agrees with the information I have on file.
House#35 is the tiny house, right beside Savage, that gave the impression (through realty photos) that a single male resided there. I believe this is whom Savage was referring to. There is a realty listing (or at least there was at one time), which had it "drastically reduced for an immediate sale!!!". I don't believe this home was vacant at the time WT disappeared. I found another indication online that this house was initially listed for sale on November 4, 2014. It sold in June 2015. There was a feedback given, where the home owner praised the realtor, and signed with a ... not real name (or perhaps real name in condensed/abbreviated form). I remember years ago looking into that signature, but couldn't really find anything tangible. Unfortunately his review of the realtor has now slid off of the scale of reviews, replaced with newer ones. However, it can still be found if you can make your way to find the 'cached' version of that page. There are a lot of hits if you start with typing in 35 Benaroon. Find the realtor, then search for that realtor's reviews, then select the cached version, which still shows it. I'm sorry but I cannot remember now why I knew that that review came from that person.
As far as I understood at the time, the vacant house which was referred to, was the one up in behind FGM's house, on same side. (It would be house#52 on that drawing that I posted above recently)
ETA: ok I remembered how I knew that review belonged to the homeowner at 31Benaroon... on the review there was a photo of the home. The jpg is still noted, but the link is dead now.