AZ - Isabel Mercedes Celis, 6, Tucson, 20 April 2012 - #13

[Prof]

The first 911 caller was Sergio Junior! They thought the caller was a female, because of his young voice.

Did JVM state they thought the caller was female?

 

[Madeleine74]

BBM.. For what purpose? I don't know but there are crazy people in this world.. So your guess, I supsect, would be as good as mine.. IMHO Neither of the parents seem to be too overly distraught over a child being missing.. I would be a basket case IF it were my child...JMHO

Well you're the one who originally asked if this could be a hoax. You didn't specify what you meant by "this."

I'm not speculating, I'm inquiring what you think might be a hoax.

A hoax by the parents would mean that Isa is not really missing and since she's only 6 years old, someone would be taking care of her. Why parents would want LE, CPS, the FBI, and the general public invading their lives and separating the children from both parents if there were no crime is beyond my comprehension. They're not on a reality TV show. LE would have ascertained by now if there was a hoax. I don't see this as a possibility at all.

 

[liltexans]

Pat Brown on JVM (HLN) says it's unusual for families to be split apart at a time like this.

I have to agree with Pat. I don't think Sergio was removed from his boys becuase he's overly emotional. JMO

 

[Eileen730]

What are the reasons, for all you experts out there, that he would be removed from the kids but still be allowed to see Becky?

As i see it whomever did this is out to hurt Sergio!
We have no idea what this family might have been intobut they sure have remained pretty silent..I thought they were hiding from someone.
the home has a wall around it its like a prison.
Dogs,, i thought one was a watch dog and the other a pet!


Or he is the one responsible!

Very strange if ya ask me!

Akk JMO

 

[cluciano63]

I think today took away what strand of patience I had left with HLN...will not be transcribing NG anymore...FWIW.

 

[azmary]

I am not an expert. I have a question.

If LE had somehow overheard Sergio speaking privately with Becky, could they have heard him suggest or threaten to do something foolish, like take the boys and go to live in Mexico? If Sergio said these things out of frustration with the media coverage or public opinion, he might have realized that he shouldn't have said it and really wouldn't do such a thing, but LE would still have to take his words seriously and move to protect the boys (and to cover their butts). Would a situation like this fit the LE description that Sergio himself is not a threat to the boys unless they are with him? :moo:

You might be right. Even though we have not been told about phone or text message who is to say TPD doesn't have those?:twocents:

 

[Anita Richman]

Did JVM state they thought the caller was female?

The police dispatch said to the responding officer that "the complainant will be the sister", after describing the missing child. (I wondered about that when I saw the playback transcription of the dispatch from the call.) JVM was clarifying why that was, as her producers were listening to the tapes.

 

[Dr. Know?]

http://www.tucsonnewsnow.com/category/218560/kold-news-13-live-video

live but has a delay compared to tv.

 

[carole]

As i see it whomever did this is out to hurt Sergio!
We have no idea what this family might have been intobut they sure have remained pretty silent..I thought they were hiding from someone.
the home has a wall around it its like a prison.
Dogs,, i thought one was a watch dog and the other a pet!


Or he is the one responsible!

Very strange if ya ask me!

Akk JMO

BBM

There are lots of homes like this in AZ, MN, etc.

If I were trying to hide, it wouldn't be on a corner lot on a busy street with plenty of people coming and going to the various stores/shopping in the area!!

 

[cluciano63]

You might be right. Even though we have not been told about phone or text message who is to say TPD doesn't have those?:twocents:

Still, even if Sergio HAD said he would take the boys to Mexico (which seems highly doubtful to me)...why be prevented from ANY contact with them? That just seems awfully serious to me...JMO

 

[Madeleine74]

I think today took away what strand of patience I had left with HLN...will not be transcribing NG anymore...FWIW.

LOL! Welcome to the light, cluciano! HLN, especially NG and those shows, are not ones to follow if what you are looking for are accurate facts of a case. However, if one enjoys histrionic yelling, overuse of the word, "bombshell," and commercials every 3 min, then HLN will fit the bill perfectly.

 

[Prof]

The police dispatch said to the responding officer that "the complainant will be the sister", after describing the missing child. I wondered about that when I saw the playback transcription of the dispatch from the call.

This can be explained by the multiple calls to 911 by different members of family ----

 

[Whisperer]

Press Conference - 5/14/12 @3:00 PM Tuscon Time

http://www.myspace.com/video/565006329/isabel-celis-press-conference-5-14-12-audio-only/108733030

:gthanks:

 

[azmary]

:what:

BBM

There are lots of homes like this in AZ, MN, etc.

 

[~n/t~]

I think today took away what strand of patience I had left with HLN...will not be transcribing NG anymore...FWIW.

Too late. We all voted about 5 minutes ago and you're it. :floorlaugh:

 

[Patty G]

Jane is not going to play the 14 year old calling ... legal issues.

Playing the mother's call.

 

[Anita Richman]

Can't play the first 911 call because the caller is a minor.

 

[PAXIMUS]

Above BBM. While IMO at this point its quite possibly unwise that they do not have an Atty.. it does however IMO lend more credence to their not being involved in their daughters disappearance.. jmo and I could be wrong for feeling that way but IMO. It certainly seems as tho if one were involved and LE has the heat turned up this high on them tthat if they had half a brain cell they'd be retaining a lawyer FOR ABSOLUTE CERTAIN!!! ..again jmo, tho!

It blows my mind they have no attorney with all this heat on them, it means two things to me, they are either incredibly stupid or incredibly innocent.

 

[Emeralgem]

Well you're the one who originally asked if this could be a hoax. You didn't specify what you meant by "this."

I'm not speculating, I'm inquiring what you think might be a hoax.

A hoax by the parents would mean that Isa is not really missing and since she's only 6 years old, someone would be taking care of her. Why parents would want LE, CPS, the FBI, and the general public invading their lives and separating the children from both parents if there were no crime is beyond my comprehension. They're not on a reality TV show. LE would have ascertained by now if there was a hoax. I don't see this as a possibility at all.

IMHO..I asked a legitimate question.....JMHO

 

[cluciano63]

The abode walls around houses in the deserts are, in part, to keep out critters...JMO
I live in NM...the homes near me by the mountain have them, as there are lots of coyotes and they take away dogs and kitties who are let outside... Not to mention snakes around.