Pretty sure ER docs and neurosurgeons operate on people with these fractures and are well aware of what's survivable and what's not. Neurosurgeons deal with fractures constantly; one can argue they have more experience with fractures than forensic pathologists who do not exclusively focus on the skull and brain. Neurosurgeons are far more experienced in matters of the brain than forensic pathologists.
And I've seen multiple forensic pathologists also say that the situation doesn't make sense-- one in particular is Dr. Cyril Wecht.
With all due respect and not trying to be rude, but ER doctors should be the last MD's commenting as they are NOT specialists, only in Emergency Medicine. Appreciate what you all bring to the table but we need to be certain we are as accurate as possible with statements which is why I linked more information. See all below:
ER docs are very limited in what they can do and are not surgeons.
See link w/description of their responsibilities and capabilities:
Emergency Medicine | HospitalCareers.com
Emergency physicians are trained in the important emergency medicine rule, i.e., “Rule out the worst case scenario.”
Using this rule, the physician must determine if a patient’s symptoms may be caused by a serious medical condition.
If a patient presents to the emergency department in distress, the emergency physician may be expected to perform any of the following procedures:
- Collecting medical histories
- Thoroughly examining patients
- Drawing conclusions and order tests
- Deciding on appropriate courses of treatment
- Emergency resuscitation
- Placing intravenous lines
- Taking whatever steps are necessary to stabilize the patient for transport to another area of the hospital or transport to another hospital
- Effectively treating less serious injuries, such as broken bones or lacerations.
- Determining if patients need to be admitted to the hospital for further evaluation
- Deciding whether
- Discharging some patients with instructions for self-treatment and follow-up with their personal care physician for additional evaluation on an outpatient basis.
Neurosurgeons, a whole different ball game. Neurosurgeons are medical doctors that diagnose and treat conditions related to the
brain,
spine, and other parts of your
nervous system. They differ from neurologists in that they’re specifically trained and certified in the use of surgical treatments, whereas neurologists focus on other forms of treatment.
NEUROSURGEONS:
Link to webmd:
What Is a Neurosurgeon?
****Cyril Wecht and other forensic pathologists would be the most qualified to make educated statements as to BS's death investigation.
What is a Forensic Pathologist?
The forensic pathologist is a subspecialist in pathology whose area of special competence is the examination of persons who die suddenly, unexpectedly or violently. The forensic pathologist is an expert in determining cause and manner of death.
The forensic pathologist is specially trained: to perform autopsies to determine the presence or absence of disease, injury or poisoning; to evaluate historical and law-enforcement investigative information relating to manner of death; to collect medical evidence, such as trace evidence and secretions, to document sexual assault; and to reconstruct how a person received injuries.
Training
Forensic pathologists are trained in multiple forensic sciences as well as traditional medicine. Other areas of science that the forensic pathologist must have a working knowledge of toxicology, firearms examination (wound ballistics), trace evidence, forensic serology and DNA technology.
The forensic pathologist acts as the case coordinator for the medical and forensic scientific assessment of a given death, making sure that the appropriate procedures and evidence collection techniques are applied to the body.
When forensic pathologists are employed as death investigators they bring their expertise to bear upon the interpretation of the scene of death, in the assessment of the time of death, of the consistency of witnesses’ statements with injuries, and the interpretation of injury patterns or patterned injuries. In jurisdictions where there are medical examiner systems, forensic pathologists are usually employed to perform autopsies to determine cause and manner of death.
Love you all and JMO
