CA - City to investigate after video shows 2 men forcibly throwing young man off Muni, Aug. 30, 2018

EuTuCroquet?

“What's happening to my special purpose!?”
Joined
Mar 11, 2017
Messages
5,402
Reaction score
8,717
http://www.sfexaminer.com/twitter-v...lack-teenage-boy-off-muni-playing-loud-music/

City to investigate after Twitter video shows two men forcibly throwing young man off Muni

EDITOR’S NOTE: This story has been updated to include comment from SFMTA and San Francisco police.

Two videos posted to Twitter Thursday night show two adult men physically tackling an apparently younger man of color and throwing him off a San Francisco Muni train against his will.

Social media users who helped the video go viral pointed to racial tensions as possible motivations behind the incident, and dubbed the young man’s alleged assailants, who appear white, #MuniMatt and #MuniMark, though their identities and ethnicities are not known.

Anna Sterling, a local journalist who posted the videos, confirmed the incident occurred on the N-Judah Muni line Thursday night somewhere between 32nd and 40th Avenues. Sterling said she was not on the train herself, but the video was recorded by her friend. Sterling is a journalist with bylines at the Los Angeles Times, Huffington Post, VICE and NBC News, among other outlets.
———

Anna Sterling's tweets:
Anna Sterling on Twitter
Anna Sterling on Twitter
Anna Sterling on Twitter
Anna Sterling on Twitter

Anna Sterling‏ Verified account @AnnaMSterling
Whoa these two men just tried to throw this kid off the muni train because he was playing music too loudly. He easily could’ve hit oncoming traffic. This is not okay.

... They’re attempting to throw him onto the street. You can see it clearly here. He’s just a kid. This is not okay.

... In my report for @mic, the witness who took the video explains why no one intervened in the SF #Muni attack: Dexter Lotz, man who was attacked on San Francisco Muni train, said he nearly lost consciousness #MuniMatt #SFMTA

... She told me that it was mostly women who were bystanders and that one woman did try to intervene but couldn’t do much.


From Sterling's report for Mic:

Dexter Lotz, man who was attacked on San Francisco Muni train, said he nearly lost consciousness

San Francisco native Dexter Lotz was on his way home from a fun-filled afternoon with friends and family in Dolores Park on Thursday. The 21-year-old, who works at a local deli, left San Francisco’s Mission District, taking the N-Judah train alone back to his place in the outer Sunset neighborhood in the Bay Area. Playing some XXXTentacion on his speaker, he was getting ready to get off the train around 31st Avenue.

That’s when a heavy-set man wearing a hat and beard, who has yet to be identified, approached him. Lotz had noticed that the man was looking at him throughout the ride. He figured it was about the music he was playing on his speaker.
...

Lotz is considering a civil case against the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency. According to San Francisco Police Department, they received several calls about the incident before they arrived on the scene. The second man involved in the altercation had not been found. It’s currently an ongoing investigation.

“This is very disturbing video,” Paul Rose, spokesperson for SFMTA, said. “We are working with SFPD to fully investigate this matter. We are providing the surveillance video from the train to SFPD for the investigation.”
...

Lotz said he remembers three men getting involved in the altercation and that he almost lost consciousness more than once.


 
Last edited:
More reporting from Mic and Sterling:

Dexter Lotz, man who was attacked on San Francisco Muni train, said he nearly lost consciousness

“I’ve never experienced that before,” Lotz said in an interview with Mic. “Things started going black. I couldn’t see anything.”
...

Lotz said police approached him when he got off the train and ordered him to the floor and handcuffed him. The police also questioned the heavy-set white man; he was not in handcuffs. When Lotz asked why he was in handcuffs and not the initial aggressor, police told him that reports claimed that Lotz was the aggressor.
 
I'm aware there are racial sensitivities in the US which I, as a foreigner, do not understand, but are we absolutely certain that the two white men attacked the black one because he was black? It wasn't just because he was a teenager being an inconsiderate arse and pissing people off?

I watched the video and did not hear any racist language being used, however several references were made by bystanders to the music the teenager was playing. Since the article mentions it being played "on his speaker" it's pretty clear that everyone else could hear it.

From the link provided at #3 it seems to me Lotz was very well aware his music was pissing at least one person off but he didn't give a damn.

My experience of public transport here in the Birmingham area is that teenagers of all colours play music loudly as a way of marking territory. If anyone complains or asks them to turn it down they often turn it up because they know they are pissing other passengers off.
 
They don't deserve to be choked out or thrown off a train for doing it. Nobody does. There were other options available instead of violence.
 
-deleted-
 
Last edited:

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
93
Guests online
446
Total visitors
539

Forum statistics

Threads
625,538
Messages
18,505,873
Members
240,811
Latest member
seanbrwh
Back
Top