CA - Joey, Summer, Gianni, Joseph Jr McStay Murders - Feb 4th 2010 #12

[missy1974]

Both of his Baby Mama's made that same decision.

Both?

 

[Force Ten]

You need to watch or listen to the testimony. And actually, we have never heard about emails.

Because there weren't any.

 

[Tortoise]

I'm hoping this is more clear in the actual testimony? I'm not sure what to think about that... although, because she is family, she could have sat in on court every day if she had wanted to, so not like she wouldn't have heard everything up to this point already.

Yeah I'm just wondering why she hadn't already seen her own police report. Perhaps she doesn't have access to all the files.

 

[Tortoise]

This says Part 2 but I don't see a Part 1 up yet.

eta Note posted under video -

NOTE: Day 29 Part 1 will be uploaded at a later time, hopefully tonight, or maybe in the morning, thanks for your patience. I figured, it's better to upload something rather than waiting access to part 1. - From AddiLawCrime in the L&C Chat

 

[missy1974]

ITA - I think it took courage, and lots of love for her dad, to take the stand. Especially since she was young in 2010 and probably might not recall everything. Her answers seemed honest to me, as did her belief in CM. jmho

I'm not ready to make a judgement call based on tweets Really would have like to have been able to watch this, but audio is better than nothing

 

[oceanblueeyes]

Both of his Baby Mama's made that same decision.

Oh he has more children by another woman? IDKT. How many kids in total does he have?

Tia

 

[Bernina]

CM's the one that contacted LE and advised them about the situation JM's own family didn't even have enough concern to do so. I suppose CM should have also tracked down the killers?

....say what.......?

DK contacted PM before anyone contacted LE. CM didn't contact LE, he had a warrant. A neighbor called Animal Control (semi-LE), then MM contacted LE.

 

[missy1974]

Yeah I'm just wondering why she hadn't already seen her own police report. Perhaps she doesn't have access to all the files.

oh I see what you are saying... maybe because they just wanted her to use her memory? that actually seems like a good thing... not like she was "studying" her previous statements.

 

[missy1974]

This says Part 2 but I don't see a Part 1 up yet.

Dang, I want to listen to part 1 first, hopefully not long

 

[missy1974]

....say what.......?

DK contacted PM before anyone anyone contacted LE. CM didn't contact LE, he had a warrant. A neighbor called Animal Control (semi-LE), then MM contacted LE.

CM went to Susan's house... on the 9th? or 10th?

 

[Bernina]

CM went to Susan's house... on the 9th? or 10th?

But CHASE didn't call LE as Texas Red wrote. Chase had a warrant, or at least that's his excuse.

 

[missy1974]

But CHASE didn't call LE as Texas Red wrote. Chase had a warrant, or at least that's his excuse.

You mentioned everyone else that went there, including animal control, but didn't mention Chase contacting Susan and going there... just thought I would add that for clarity is all

 

[JMarsh]

Which is why he never called, texted or emailed after he knew JM was dead despite that he told Carmen he had been trying to get ahold of Chase all weekend and the records prove otherwise. IMO

Chase did call Joey after the family went missing. That is on the record.

 

[citygirl]

This is what I'm saying citygirl... now does this mean that everything Mike said was true or he remembered everything at that moment? probably not. But I think this applies to other witnesses in equally stressful situations. I have kids, at 18-19, I fully imagine being interviewed by detectives in a case that your dad is being blamed for murder of a family you knew would be stressful. Also, sometimes at that age, unless you specifically ask the question, you may not get a specific or clear answer .. cuz they are teenagers and suck lol My son got pulled over once... he came home shaking and didn't even get a ticket! No way this was easy for her, and I'm disappointed in the comments I have read about her today. JMO

My post wasn't meant to be specific to Taylor's testimony. Just testimony in general. I can't take any of her testimony as valid because she was a little girl . Eleven when it happened and interviewed when she was Fifteen. And, now as an adult, testifying for Daddy. To save his life.

 

[asyousay]

Chase going to the house proves nothing at all, it’s the phone logs that tell the story.

He was barely calling Joey once he went missing on the 4th and he conventionally only raised the alarm once he had staged the home. Those are the important facts!!!

 

[mom2chloe]

CM went to Susan's house... on the 9th? or 10th?

And bummed money off her that he never repaid! IMO

 

[JMarsh]

Garcia.. Sequieda... Mitchelly.... And numerous LE reports that EVERY witness has referred to LOL

I love how the transcripts or reports are only relied upon when it 'supports' the theory. I would like to know when her first interview was... before or after Merritt was arrested.

Neither Cathy or Taylor were interviewed until AFTER the bodies were discovered. When they are first interviewed, years have passed.

 

[oceanblueeyes]

Chase did call Joey after the family went missing. That is on the record.

Like everything else CM does he couldn't even do that for very long.

Imo

 

[missy1974]

Neither Cathy or Taylor were interviewed until AFTER the bodies were discovered. When they are first interviewed, years have passed.

hmmm McGee said that Cathy has been saying the same thing since Feb 2010, so I wonder where she said it if not an interview?

 

[Force Ten]

Chase did call Joey after the family went missing. That is on the record.

He called him, not because he couldn't get a hold of him or thought he was missing.