- Joined
- May 17, 2009
- Messages
- 35,724
- Reaction score
- 339,058
Thank you for the information, much appreciated.I am not in any way defending this evil, evil act.
But as a mental health professional specialising in psychosis, this is simply not correct, and misinformation could potentially harm other vulnerable people.
People in psychosis often appear very confident and organised. When you talk to them there are usually signs (disorganised speech, for example) but sometimes it's impossible to tell if someone is in a state of psychosis unless you ask about whatever the specific delusion is. The stereotype of psychotics being visibly chaotic and disturbed is sometimes true, but generally only at extremes. Patients who are in a state of acute psychosis can appear extremely focused and to have clarity of purpose, and can come up with and execute complex plans, because all of their focus is 100% single-mindedly set on achieving whatever task they feel compelled to by their delusion. (Talk to anyone who's ever worked in a psychiatric hospital, patients with psychosis are infamous for being "sneaky", and also for appearing to be very lucid and sane, until they say something which reveals that they are not.)
I shared a personal story before of a loved one who became psychotic, her specific delusion was that she was convinced that she was being watched at all times by some shadowy authority. She managed to come up with and carry out a very intelligent and complex plan that involved travelling quite some distance in a way that avoided all CCTV cameras. Purely out of the delusion that this shadow person was watching her in real time, hopping between different CCTV cameras to do so.
Most people who are in psychosis utterly reject the idea that they are in psychosis, because one of the problems with psychosis is that psychotic people feel extremely lucid. The whole point about psychosis is that you're convinced that your specific delusion is 100% real, and that delusion is the most important thing in your life.
But I don't think she is in a state of psychosis, simply because someone in psychosis would tell everyone, "yes I got rid of the demon possessing my little girl's body, isn't that wonderful?" or something similar. She wouldn't have awareness that what she'd done was wrong (which A clearly does, as she stonewalled and refused to cooperate with police), and she wouldn't have enough awareness of being mentally ill to plead insanity.
Ashlee's Mom stated she is bipolar. Do you have an opinion as to whether that could relate to her choice to murder Melodee?