- Joined
- Oct 8, 2022
- Messages
- 12,068
- Reaction score
- 118,798
It is my understanding from the article I linked and many others I’ve read here and around the internet that no local water system is designed to handle the demand of putting out nearly 5,000 house fires during 60-100 mph winds (meaning fast-moving, with no possibility of air support).Do you feel that Governor Newsom's call for a report about fire hydrant performance during this fire event necessary? JMO.
It doesn’t hurt. There are always things to learn and possibly improve, as is illustrated in the linked article below about the Almeda fire in Oregon that I referenced earlier. But these fixes are bandaids when it comes to a wind-driven fire. It might save a few houses, but if people think it will put out these types of fires they are sadly mistaken, as is shown in the video I posted.Do you feel that Governor Newsom's call for a report about fire hydrant performance during this fire event necessary? JMO.
I would also hope there would be serious discussions about the encroachment of building into areas that cannot be protected from disastrous fires like this, and how to prevent it when people will not be responsible with fire hygiene.It is my understanding from the article I linked and many others I’ve read here and around the internet that no local water system is designed to handle the demand of putting out nearly 5,000 house fires during 60-100 mph winds (meaning fast-moving, with no possibility of air support).
Doing a post-mortem on fire hydrant performance is useful to see if a tragedy like this can be prevented in the future, but no one did anything wrong. No system would be designed to prevent this. Gov. Newsom has to call for action because that is the politically responsible thing to do.
It is valuable for California to start clearing wildlands responsibly as they are already planning to do. It’s a massive and expensive task.
Jmo
Sounds like you're saying no matter what is done this kind of disaster will reoccur in the future.It is my understanding from the article I linked and many others I’ve read here and around the internet that no local water system is designed to handle the demand of putting out nearly 5,000 house fires during 60-100 mph winds (meaning fast-moving, with no possibility of air support).
Doing a post-mortem on fire hydrant performance is useful to see if a tragedy like this can be prevented in the future, but no one did anything wrong. No system would be designed to prevent this. Gov. Newsom has to call for action because that is the politically responsible thing to do.
It is valuable for California to start clearing wildlands responsibly as they are already planning to do. It’s a massive and expensive task.
Jmo
Thanks to climate change, I bet a fire like this will happen again and I say that as a resident of L.A. <modsnip>Sounds like you're saying no matter what is done this kind of disaster will reoccur in the future.
I find that very disconcerting. JMO.
Sounds like you're saying no matter what is done this kind of disaster will reoccur in the future.
I find that very disconcerting. JMO.
I'm so sorry for your loss.View attachment 556877
Altadena Community Church burned to the ground. This was my church when I lived in Southern California. It's gone now. And many members of the church have also lost their homes, as have many other community members from groups that used the church space for their various needs.
Ik you arent talking to me, but i love poking my head into convos im not involved in lol.Do you feel that Governor Newsom's call for a report about fire hydrant performance during this fire event necessary? JMO.
So there's no solution and the wholesale destruction from these fires is inevitable. That's sad. JMO.It doesn’t hurt. There are always things to learn and possibly improve, as is illustrated in the linked article below about the Almeda fire in Oregon that I referenced earlier. But these fixes are bandaids when it comes to a wind-driven fire. It might save a few houses, but if people think it will put out these types of fires they are sadly mistaken, as is shown in the video I posted.
![]()
Water lines that failed during Almeda Fire to get system improvements
This week, the Oregon State Legislature approved a $3 million grant for fire resiliency improvements to the Talent-Ashland-Phoenix (TAP) system, the joint water line that suffered failures during the Almeda Fire. "As each individual home burned or business burned, those lines were open and...ktvl.com
I can’t speak about the policies of every county in California, but my family was evacuated during the Carr, Camp, Butte, and the LNU Lightning Complex fires. These include some of California’s largest wildfires (all in various parts of Northern California).I would also hope there would be serious discussions about the encroachment of building into areas that cannot be protected from disastrous fires like this, and how to prevent it when people will not be responsible with fire hygiene.
You are absolutely right about clearing wildlands. Here in Southern Oregon my town is nestled up against the Siskiyou mountains. We would be sitting ducks if a fire broke out uphill. The Ashland Forest Resiliency Project has worked for over a decade to clear the forest interface of fuel…brush, dead trees. Every spring when it’s wet enough we see smoke rising above town from their preventive burns. And of course, people who live in or near the interface are strongly encouraged to reduce the fuel around their homes.It is valuable for California to start clearing wildlands responsibly as they are already planning to do. It’s a massive and expensive task.
There are always ways to improve things and make people safer. I am middle-aged and was born in California. Nothing like this ever happened when I was a child. There has been an huge accumulation of wood fuel and very poor maintenance of electrical lines (mostly due to the electrical utility PG&E). All but 2 of the largest fires in California history have occurred since 2000, all but 5 of the top 20 have occurred since 2012.Sounds like you're saying no matter what is done this kind of disaster will reoccur in the future.
I find that very disconcerting. JMO.