I really thought you would see holes in the theory instead of rationalize it. Personally, I'm not falling for the robbery home invasion. But that's okay to think about.For sure not something I thought of over the 3+ months but after seeing robbery pop up as motive and then looking back on reddit, this theory began to take shape.
Possibly
True, student debt is common. LE must have checked Eli’s financial records for things like crypto, gambling, or large withdrawals, those motives usually lead to intimidation, not abduction.
It's not that consistent because the victim is usually left bound or injured at the scene.
The removal of EW suggests he was a perceived threat to the robbers.
The dog being left in the fire was either a rushed exit or a total lack of empathy.
Yes and alternatively, if not cash or valuables, then potentially digital (hard drives, ledger keys) or personal (silence)
If the perps didn't get what they wanted, EW's disappearance might have been a forced relocation to get information.
Most likely destroying evidence... DNA, fingerprints, or digital footprints.
If the perps found out that they were being recorded, it would explain why they set the apartment on fire and
took EW away. Perhaps to silence him or relocate him.
Robbers who are acting on a debt collection want a victim alive and working to pay them back.
Removing a person from a scene increases the risk of being caught.
The perps must have felt that leaving him there was a greater risk than taking him.
I'd say in this theory, the emotion is methodical - burn all the DNA and destroy the electronics.
Although MOO from the start has been that the fire was set out of rage. A strong need to silence or erase EW.
Good to see these details added about EWs MSW student placement that started in September 2025.
*** Research and speculation ***
When I learned via LinkedIn that EW began a new placement in September 2025 with Health & Wellness Friendly Communities, I looked on Ontario social work forums to find out what roles are typically assigned to MSW students.
Some counselling work is done virtually through an encrypted platform but the program itself requires significant hours of in-person engagement with community members.
Master of Social Work (MSW) students in their final year (Advanced Field Education) at Wilfrid Laurier University must complete a minimum of 500 hours in their field placement. This placement requires a minimum of 16 hours per week, with options for 21, 28, or 35 hours per week depending on the schedule chosen.
There is an option for thesis that requires 100 hours of advanced field placement which seems to be what EW was working towards with the plan to move back to NS and finish the degree virtually.
Link
Health & Wellness Friendly Communities operates its main services in partnership with Community Healthcaring Kitchener-Waterloo (Home), located at 44 Francis Street South, Kitchener, ON N2G 2A2.
HCKW runs programs via outreach services at a number of community partner sites across Kitchener for vulnerable clients experiencing homelessness and insecure housing.
It’s unknown which location EW was working at.
Here is a list of locations:
The Working Centre (TWC):
58 Queen St S, Kitchener, ON N2G 1V6
House of Friendship (HOF):
House of Friendship
HOF operates programs across several sites in Kitchener, including a main administrative office, addiction treatment facilities, housing, and various community centres.
Administrative Office: 236 Victoria St N, Suite 3A, Kitchener, ON N2H 5C8
Addiction Treatment and Women's Residential Treatment: 71 Ann St, Kitchener, ON N2B 3T3
Emergency Food Hampers: 807 Guelph St, Kitchener, ON N2H 5Z2
HOF Supportive Housing:
Charles Village: 75 Charles Street East, Kitchener, ON
Eby Village: 50 Eby Street South, Kitchener, ON
HOF Neighbourhood Community Centres (Family Outreach/Food Programs):
Chandler Mowat: 222 Chandler Drive, Kitchener, ON
Courtland Shelley: 1064-G Courtland Avenue East, Kitchener, ON
Kingsdale: 72 Wilson Avenue, Kitchener, ON
Centreville Chicopee: 141 Morgan Avenue, Kitchener, ON
Forest Heights: 1700 Queens Boulevard, Kitchener, ON
Victoria Hills: 10 Chopin Drive, Kitchener, ON
Ray of Hope: 659 King St E #230, Kitchener, ON N2G 2M4
Thrive HIV Prevention and Support: 5-1770 King Street East, Kitchener, Ontario, N2G 2P1
In addition, there are undisclosed supportive housing sites and motels.
Fire / Arson
When I look up Kitchener fires, there have been 2 fires close to the The Working Centre (TWC):
58 Queen St S, Kitchener, ON N2G 1V6
Kitchener Fire Department: Major incident report
Nov 18, 2025 - 2nd floor fire, unoccupied building known to have squatters
January 25, 2026 - 2nd floor above dispensary 2 tenants escaped. 2 missing but no injuries reported. Kitchener Fire incident reports | City of Kitchener
Moo...with the work he was doing. You also hear of who is dealing drugs, stolen goods n flesh. That's why I quit. It gets dangerous especially if you live in the neighborhood...moo
Moo...you end up with unwanted information. You cannot say anything.. confidential info....mooI can certainly see that. Thanks for sharing your experience . Absolutely could expose people to risky situations, and it makes sense that you stepped back for your own safety.
Cause of death not released by LE
Family shared on Facebook Dec 23, 2025 that the apartment was lit on fire with Princess inside.
Her remains are being sent to family in Nova Scotia.
View attachment 640007
Moo...you end up with unwanted information. You cannot say anything.. confidential info....moo
Moo..they are clients. You are paid to provide positive support. People talk a lot about their life, environment, the people who are positive....but usually the chat is about negative peoples in the environment...mooI would think that might scare a client or whatever you call them. They may want to protect themselves.
Moo..also clients want support but you cannot be their friend, even if you want to. For some clients, they do not understand that necessary boundary. ..moo
It is complicated to keep that boundery
A 6 a.m. fire report means the escalation happened hours earlier. If mom meant midnight NS time, that was 11 pm Kitchener time. Hours between 1 & 3 am are strange for visitors, but people typically become sad, lonely, vulnerable at that time and if had been out drinking (for instance), that would be the time they might show up.As far as fire goes, the 911 was at 6 am and the unit was fully engulfed.
Had it been a slow starting fire smoke alarms would have gone off long before that and his dog would have been barking lots, no?
I’m not sure if it was a real fireplace or not but here is screenshot from real estate video walk through of 25 Major st house.
View attachment 639794
I really thought you would see holes in the theory instead of rationalize it. Personally, I'm not falling for the robbery home invasion. But that's okay to think about.![]()
the thing that I struggle with is how did they incapacitate Eli while they started the fire? Eli wouldn't have just stood and watched while they burned his house and killed his dog IMO ... so how did they incapacitate him or was there two people there, one to hold Eli and one to start the fire?