Caylee Anthony General Discussion Thread #78

[Blink34]

Okay so is she saying she is a forensic nurse, which I don't think she is , or did she interrupt her own self mid sentence and throw in the fact that she is a nurse when she was talking about the smell of decomposition. It would be idiotic of her to state she is a forensic nurse if it could be easily proven that she isn't so I tend to believe she was talking so much she interrupted her own sentence.

well she did state that George was a former homicide detective that no-one has been able to corroberate so she may have done exactly that..

 

[sweetmop]

Newbie to WS here.
This case is nauseating me.
The people involved in this case are nauseating me.
Sorry to say, but I believe this poor little child no longer walks among us.
Her sorry excuse for a "mother" is (IMO) absolutely to blame, even if she didn't actually raise a hand to this sweet child.

All I can say is, I hope LE can prevent Ms. Anthony from roaming free -- and that somehow and soon, Caylee is brought home.

Welcome SelmaClue!

This case is nauseating to me too. I see Caylee's precious face when I close my eyes each night. What a beautiful little girl. Casey Anthony never realised what a gift she was given!

I too pray that Casey ( If guilty of doing harm ) is punished severely and pays for her horrendous crime.

 

[panthera]

The only thing I've heard about a broken gas gage is that's the reason Casey stole and kept gas cans in her trunk. According to George and Cindy that is.

I think it's a ruse. Why not just get it fixed if it really has a problem? The car's only 10 y/o!

 

[txsvicki]

An office in a nursing home.

That's what I thought, administration in a nursing home. Maybe meant that she's a nurse of decomposition because she works at a place that deals with very elderly, bed ridden, and even people about to die. I guess she caught herself saying that, and realized it wasn't appropriate, even if true.

 

[lostnfound85]

Anyone that's been to a dog show and seen tracking contests knows how sensitive a dogs sense of smell is. There was definitely a dead body in that car.

 

[Dorvillian]

I don't think she was counting on it being towed either! It definitely sounds set up for being stolen where she might even have wanted to pin that on whoever had Caylee. Then she finds out from her mom that the car was back at their house with everything in it and comes up with the nanny-abduction at the apt. Her not calling her dad about the broken-down car is very telling, imo.

You and I seem to think alike. This idea explains a lot. Not one single thing she said to LE that first day was an even somewhat plausible lie - she must have had something planned - she did have a month after all.

Maybe this is the reason she begged for just one more day.

I wonder why LE has never made a public statement about the the car looking like a failed alibi.

 

[Amberjack]

:boohoo:
Casey has run out of time. She told the guard don't, feel like a meet with Lee, then Baez runs behind and says she was ill. Bull, Casey is a coward she recalls what she told her family about Caylee being home for her birthday tears and all. Attention now being waned from Casey. Withdrawal must be hard for her.

Seriously, withdrawal from what exactly?

IMO Tomorrow (Mon. 8/10) will bring some answers hopefully.
DNA results, and maybe George's realization now that Caylee was probably in the trunk with the gas containers. (Did he say who took out the wedge?)

 

[Blink34]

Sorry blink distracted for a while. Which video's are you referencing. I mentioned I don't buy a belly ache claim from Casey on her not wanting to see Lee.

No apology necessary Check, I am referring to the phone calls/last jail visit(s) with Lee and the Anthony's. LE fought the PA from Baez to be able to make them public, but have not.

 

[sweetmop]

thought she worked in an office

Sorry if that's the case. I could of sworn I heard her say she worked in home health,
Regardless, a nurse should know that smell.

 

[CheckDaFacts]

You know Tony beat feet as soon as this whole thing came down and he made his statement. It's amazing how she cared more about getting in touch with him than worrying about Caylee. That really clinched it for me that she knew what happened. All the rest of just stacks up nice and neat. I have total faith in LE that they are gonna wrap this up with a bow for the prosecutors. And yeah Checkdafacts, the withdrawal must be making her crazy. I'm hoping she does something really out there so the spotlight can be on her. Does she attend the bond hearing? I'd sure like to see if she's lost weight and sleep.

Boy we all hope we can depend on LE crossing those T's and doting all those i's. Were close with Casey only for sentencing purpose. In the meantime. Caylee is still missinng.

 

[McSev]

Can I insert myself in the debate and offer some middle ground? Perhaps it wasn't Cindy who smelled it (orthopedic nurse so fits with some posters argument she wouldn't have as many chanced to smell a decomposing body) but it was George who smelled it (ex homocide LE and the one who drove the car home and cleaned it).

While they are frantic about finding out that Casey was lying that she was in another town with Caylee and they abandoned their car in terrible condition, between the calls to find Cayse, the trip to locate her with Amy, the thoughts of what is going on, George did say to Cindy the damn car smells like a dead body. There wasn't a party going on in the Anthony's home that night. There must have been screams and discussions and tears and pleas for Caylee's whereabouts and where Cayse was the days she didn't have the car or what she was doing, and even Lee was invited by George to come and assist with the situation. Mayhem.

George did smell it but that was before Cindy went to get Casey from Tony's apartment. As the situation escalates and finally Cayse admits to Lee that Caylee was ''taken by zanny'' Cindy is on fast mode on her 911 call. She is losing it, everything is escalating from Cayse being her irresponsible self to someting more serious and dangerous and Cindy relates to the dispatcher what she heard her husband comment regarding the car. Cindy did say the car smelled like a dead body, she didn't say she smelled it. So she perhaps saying to the dispatcher what George commented about the car?

Since I saw many different posters saying from personal experience that once you smell a decomposing body you will know, there is nothing like it, I have to believe them. And I do believe them.

Why grandparents later changing their story? Not both of them smelled it just one of them. So doubt about what George smelled? The smell could not be overwhelming? George detected what it was but it was not overwhelming thus he doubted himself later under Cayse's emotional manipulation that someone has Caylee? If Cayse transfered a body at some point in her trunk but only transfered and not stored, if a body was covered in a box and placed in the trunk for only a little time, could there be a smell but not as overwhelming? A smell that a train homocide LE would recognize but still not overwhelming? This is a question for those with experience with the issue. The grandparents backpedalled in what one of them might smelled because they had to believe their daughter and her abduction stories and were afraid the focus of the investigation will change from a missing child that was still out there to something else?

However... the dog hitting on the trunk has to be significant. Perhaps we could consider as a mistake by the dog, but one cannot accept a mistake or coincidence when it is combined with Cindy talked about the same spot and dead body smell on her VERY AUTHENTIC AND VERY REAL and VERY RAW 911 call.

IIRC, the search warrant says "Cindy" removed the pants from the backseat of the car. She was in there.

 

[sweetmop]

Has anyone heard when the public will hear the test results?

 

[QuickAttack]

Does anyone know if Casey has another brother? I saw this picture before Casey's myspace page went private. Under it the pic it said, "Uncle Brian and Caylee." It is posted also on Brian Lufkin's myspace page. Do you think it could be another brother or just a good friend that they call "uncle"? He is 25. Pretty sure that George is sitting on the couch in the background.

Pretty sure he's a friend of Lee's and a close family friend. In some of his comments on Casey's myspace, he sometimes seemed frustrated with her.

 

[QuickAttack]

IIRC, the search warrant says "Cindy" removed the pants from the backseat of the car. She was in there.

Cindy herself said it, too.

 

[Chilly Willy]

Can I insert myself in the debate and offer some middle ground? Perhaps it wasn't Cindy who smelled it (orthopedic nurse so fits with some posters argument she wouldn't have as many chanced to smell a decomposing body) but it was George who smelled it (ex homocide LE and the one who drove the car home and cleaned it).

While they are frantic about finding out that Casey was lying that she was in another town with Caylee and they abandoned their car in terrible condition, between the calls to find Cayse, the trip to locate her with Amy, the thoughts of what is going on, George did say to Cindy the damn car smells like a dead body. There wasn't a party going on in the Anthony's home that night. There must have been screams and discussions and tears and pleas for Caylee's whereabouts and where Cayse was the days she didn't have the car or what she was doing, and even Lee was invited by George to come and assist with the situation. Mayhem.

George did smell it but that was before Cindy went to get Casey from Tony's apartment. As the situation escalates and finally Cayse admits to Lee that Caylee was ''taken by zanny'' Cindy is on fast mode on her 911 call. She is losing it, everything is escalating from Cayse being her irresponsible self to someting more serious and dangerous and Cindy relates to the dispatcher what she heard her husband comment regarding the car. Cindy did say the car smelled like a dead body, she didn't say she smelled it. So she perhaps saying to the dispatcher what George commented about the car?

Since I saw many different posters saying from personal experience that once you smell a decomposing body you will know, there is nothing like it, I have to believe them. And I do believe them.

Why grandparents later changing their story? Not both of them smelled it just one of them. So doubt about what George smelled? The smell could not be overwhelming? George detected what it was but it was not overwhelming thus he doubted himself later under Cayse's emotional manipulation that someone has Caylee? If Cayse transfered a body at some point in her trunk but only transfered and not stored, if a body was covered in a box and placed in the trunk for only a little time, could there be a smell but not as overwhelming? A smell that a train homocide LE would recognize but still not overwhelming? This is a question for those with experience with the issue. The grandparents backpedalled in what one of them might smelled because they had to believe their daughter and her abduction stories and were afraid the focus of the investigation will change from a missing child that was still out there to something else?

However... the dog hitting on the trunk has to be significant. Perhaps we could consider as a mistake by the dog, but one cannot accept a mistake or coincidence when it is combined with Cindy talked about the same spot and dead body smell on her VERY AUTHENTIC AND VERY REAL and VERY RAW 911 call.

Good post, makes complete sense to me. And you're right, the dog hitting on the trunk is significant, regardless of how strong or faint the smell might have been to human noses.

 

[GameTheory]

IIRC, the search warrant says "Cindy" removed the pants from the backseat of the car. She was in there.

Correct! Did not account for that.

 

[SuziQ]

Okay so is she saying she is a forensic nurse, which I don't think she is , or did she interrupt her own self mid sentence and throw in the fact that she is a nurse when she was talking about the smell of decomposition. It would be idiotic of her to state she is a forensic nurse if it could be easily proven that she isn't so I tend to believe she was talking so much she interrupted her own sentence.

Oh I don't believe she literally had the official title of "nurse of decomposition" or even meant a forensic nurse. The main point she was trying to make is she does know what a dead body smells like but later decided it smelled like rotten pizza. It was just a bit comical that she inadvertently came up with a non existent job title. So we've all been calling it the "nurse of decomposition" title.

 

[ketel0ne]

A theory about the dogs hitting in the backyard.

Concrete PAVERS were put down in parts of the backyard over the july 4th weekend. They were put down under and around the area of the playhouse/sandbox. This is visible in the video with greta as well as the gallerys with the still photos of LE in the back yard with the dogs and the search.

In order to put down pavers you need the ground to be pretty level and the dirt may have been spread out and moved to different parts of the yard. I am pretty sure no human could smell decomp in the backyard but the dogs higher smell did, it became inconsistent IMO because the dirt had been moved.

 

[JBean]

Has anyone formulated any theory as to why Casey "rolled over" for Cindy when Cindy wanted to call the cops?
I mean here we have Casey avoiding Cindy for a month, but she sticks around while Cindy calls the cops on her.
Why didn't she just take off? Did she finally want to tell someone about Caylee?
Was she tired of prolonging the inevitable and figured it would be easier if Cindy reported Caylee's disappearance?

 

[TxRose]

Didn't Cindy mention something on Greta about Casey telling her that the boyfriend was going to fix the broken gas gauge?

That was probably her excuse (or lie) for why she needed the gas. Of ocurse she couldn't admit she didn't have money...because she was supposed to be working and getting a paycheck right?

BTW - I thought it disgusting in that interview with the GP's when they were talking about the broken gauge when they both said the broken gas gauge made perfect sense. They said that is why she needed the gas cans. No big deal they said. Excuse me....she STOLE them! She broke the shed! Geez - wake up George and Cindy. Stop minimizing everything she does!