Chelsea's contradictory statements

[txsvicki]

Chelsea doesn't seem quite as inconsistent as Lindsay and Misty, but some of her statements don't make sense. She does not seem afraid of Joe at all, and Timmy being all doped up on Rx pain meds yet up at 1:00 am doesn't fit. I'm beginning to wonder if they all went somewhere that night and left all the kids home alone. Why would both sister in laws do so much covering while trying to accuse some cousin.

 

[gngr~snap]

Chelsea doesn't seem quite as inconsistent as Lindsay and Misty, but some of her statements don't make sense. She does not seem afraid of Joe at all, and Timmy being all doped up on Rx pain meds yet up at 1:00 am doesn't fit. I'm beginning to wonder if they all went somewhere that night and left all the kids home alone. Why would both sister in laws do so much covering while trying to accuse some cousin.

BBM
Who did Misty want to babysit for the night Haleigh disappeared?
I think this IS part of the puzzle...

After all it was JO's last night before returning to Tenn. never heard they all went out... guess they could have tho

 

[Wendy101]

I thought it was Chelsea..I just wasn't sure.

But remember the part when Misty says "It'll hurt two people" One person they care about and the other not so much?? Chelsea comments on how she doesn't give a damn about Ron. Misty said something about it not being Ron and Chelsea seemed confused when she said "It's not him?" When Misty told her to "think"...I think she was guiding Chelsea back toward the Tommy and Jo story.

JMO though

Oh my! I thought she was talking to Lindsy.

I thoguht Lindsy said "it's not him?" ..
then Misty said
She said something like this.. think about chelsea, and you'll know...which then lead me to think that TiC was involved.

Geez..is there transcript here somehere?
LOL...this case is crazy!!

 

[Donjeta]

I don't understand why, if Misty and Tommy are so darned intimidated by Joe, and fear that he'll hurt Tommy's children etc., how can Chelsea and others be sure that he won't hurt Chelsea and Timmy's children if she goes on blaming Joe?

 

[Missingmeds]

I don't understand why, if Misty and Tommy are so darned intimidated by Joe, and fear that he'll hurt Tommy's children etc., how can Chelsea and others be sure that he won't hurt Chelsea and Timmy's children if she goes on blaming Joe?

Or Hank or Lisa, neither of whom seem able to defend themselves? Or Lindsy and Tommy's children? Remember Tommy said that "he" couldn't get to them now? Why is that? If Joe got a ride down once, what is stopping him from
getting a ride again?

There are just so many things that don't make sense in this case.

 

[Donjeta]

Sorry I don't remember where I read what and I'm a bit fuzzy about the details but didn't Chelsea say that Timmy was out cold having taken painkillers due to the wreck he was in and couldn't have got up and gone anywhere without her noticing? I seem to remember having read somewhere also that despite the former statement, Timmy was up at about 1 am. and made some observation relating to Joe. If my recall is correct it counts as a bit of a contradiction to me as well because Chelsea didn't say anything about Timmy being up at night and if she didn't know he was up what else didn't she know? TIA if anybody remembers more precisely.

 

[Kat]

I am posting this to Chelsea's thread. Kimster I am so sorry if you have to move another of my posts. Please advise me on how to keep it easier on you mods!

Okay I'm not posting this as a theory, or indicating in any way that this means anything. I just found this curious and wondered if this might be one of the reasons why it appears that Chelsea has descrepancies? I have not drawn conclusions and welcome any input from fellow WS'ers


http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4151469&highlight=timothy#post4151469

...Lindsey Croslin told investigators that during that 14 hour questioning of Timothy and Chelsea Croslin, detectives wanted to know if the couple had helped Misty hide Haleigh.

also from above article:

...Chelsea says the chief PC investigator in the Haleigh Cummings disappearance was accompanied by PCSO, as well as two Massachusetts State Troopers this past weekend. They showed up to her home around 9am and asked her to come with them for questioning.

"I was down there probably from about 9 o'clock to noon. They just wanted to go over the phone lines. They wanted to go over time lines, and try to fill in gaps of what happened that night and who Misty talked to.," said Croslin.

Again SIL Lindsey comments on interview:


http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4148239&highlight=chelsea#post4148239

...Lindsy Croslin says investigators had a lot of questions, 14 hours worth.

"Why did you move to Massachusetts? Like they were running from something. That's where Chelsea grew up. That's where her family is."

She says investigators tried to expose holes in the couple's story.

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4151469&highlight=timothy#post4151469

...Additionally, phone records show multiple calls between Misty and her brother (Timothy Croslin)during the night Haleigh Cummings went missing.

NOTE: How does the above quote fit into what we know as facts about the phone and phone calls? TIA!

Again, not pointing fingers but noticed that Chelsea directly doesn't address the 14 hour interview. (might mean nothing).

Zaha had posted a transcript of Chelsea's husband during a phone call with ToC. In that Tim C. states the Chelsea has been cleared as a suspect but he hasn't. This was long after the 14 hour interview.

Just food for thought.

 

[s1rebecca]

Hmm very good catch. If he was knocked out on pain meds, how was he talking to Misty multiple times.

 

[gibby207]

I also seem to recall reading somewhere that Misty was really, in essence, "raised" by TiC instead of her parents?

 

[debs]

I also seem to recall reading somewhere that Misty was really, in essence, "raised" by TiC instead of her parents?

I believe Misty's statement to this was that when things went bad in the family, it was always her and Timmy together, no matter what or where.

Chelsea is very close to Misty, even going so far as to help her fight her (literal battles). She has never ever once contradicted herself on that.

 

[Quiche]

Chelsea is to Misty, as Teresa is to Ron. mo

Puppeteers.

 

[cluciano63]

I wonder if Chelsea reads these threads...if so, maybe she will feel the need to go back on NG show and "clarify" some of these issues...

 

[debs]

(hi chelsea!)

 

[Quiche]

I wonder if Chelsea reads these threads...if so, maybe she will feel the need to go back on NG show and "clarify" some of these issues...

I'm sure Chelsea reads here-- I'd love to hear more from her.

If I were a member of that group, I sure as heck would read here... and if I didn't have the literacy skills to do so, I'd get right on those early readers.

:smiley4:

 

[cyberborg]

I believe Misty's statement to this was that when things went bad in the family, it was always her and Timmy together, no matter what or where.

Chelsea is very close to Misty, even going so far as to help her fight her (literal battles). She has never ever once contradicted herself on that.

This, to me, explains why Chelsea felt compelled to jump on the NG show that day when Gma Flo was spilling theories. Chelsea has a vested interest to help protect Misty from this as well as Timmy, assuming he is involved in helping Misty clean up the mess. Rather than chill Chelsea felt compelled to speak up and try to stop the unravelling. Why? What's the stake for her?

It sure would be a wake up call if Timmy got the call from Misty that night (based on the 14 hours of LE questioning focused on phone calls versus ~40 mins for JO), despite pain meds. Adrenalin would take over in the rush to cover up.

Blaming the vehicle being moved and scratched can also be a distraction to cover for the fact that Timmy (and Chelsea?) used it because LE would question the damage and if any forensics is found ..... blame someone else.

 

[grandmaj]

This thread is way off topic. Why? Chelsea's Contradictory Statements.

 

[lonetraveler]

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?p=3475674&highlight=chelsea#post3475674

Back in March of 2009 Chelsea comments that she thinks that someone staying at her home had to have taken the van the night that Haleigh went missing. Fair enough, we have since learned who was staying at her house. But this was back in March of 2009. Before MC wrote any letters implicating that relative. After reading a post by Elle this morning I thought to myself could this be the genisis of JO cover story? KWIM?

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?p=3477795&highlight=chelsea#post3477795

The van had a scratch and a broken headlight (hadn't heard about the headlight) here again she states she almost knows who did this (took the van and who might be involved in Haleigh's disappearance). This was March of 2009.

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4135144&highlight=chelsea#post4135144
September 2009

snip:

Should know a lot better than to look at the choice of words that the two families use in expressing themselves and finding anything particular about them but the word above "KILL" caught my eye. Only because I read the next article.

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4135319&highlight=chelsea#post4135319

In this article she changes the word of Kill to stating stolen. Not a big deal but I thought it interesting.

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4148239&highlight=chelsea#post4148239

snip:

April of 2010

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?p=5070476&highlight=chelsea#post5070476



From Feb. of 2009 to April of 2010 Chelsea has been pretty much insisting that JO did something from what I take away yes? But MC didn't initially. I have to wonder if the story came from CC? Just a thought.

Just another statement by CC.
http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?p=5072842&highlight=chelsea#post5072842

I'm sorry I have to go lay down for a bit. (a bit under the weather today) I think that her statements when looked at (including her videos and her NG appearance) are making me evaluate how much she has to do with the JO story? Did she really tell LE to search the dock area for that long?

I'm not saying she had anything to do with Haleigh missing directly. What I'm saying is she seems to be very vocal very early on about the JO scenario. KWIM?

I have been suspicious of Chelsea for quite a while now. She was entirely too eager to throw Joe under the bus. She appears to be willing to protect Misty at all costs. Then I wonder if she is throwing Joe under the bus so that LE will not consider her or Timmy as being the one who drove the van over to Misty's house, maybe to help her with a very major problem, disposing of Haleigh. Misty could have convinced her that she was helping to cover her, when it really is Ron. The tattoo of Haleigh on her foot looks a bit suspect to me. If Haleigh was her child I might could justify a tattoo, but Haleigh is not even a relative. Something stinks here. Also, maybe the two people Misty was referring to as one they really care about and one, not so much were really Timmy and Tommy. This would also explain why Chelsea is deeply involved with this case. From her appearance on the Nancy Grace show, she seemed to have been under a great deal of stress in the last year or worse. JMO.

 

[Dr.Fessel]

BBM
My #2 theory has ron following chelsea, her kids, misty and Haleigh from the bus. Jerry Santos (iirc) said lindsey came by the bus stop w/ a male in her car and spoke to chelsea's car, so lindseys in the mix at that time. I think they may have all headed to the sr. croslins place, where maybe one of them would babysit(hopefully not leaving the kids alone, but you never know) so that the rest of group maybe goes to visit the sr.in the hospital. Could be ron's fighting w/ misty and jo is there cause he's getting ready to go home and he was staying there. chelsea has been close w/ misty for along time, I don't think she'd have a problem jumping in for misty. Then maybe timmy & tommy. The young kids would be all hanging out together running around. There's alot of property around that mh. If the kids heard arguing, my bet is they'd come to see what was going on. This is where possibly Haleigh got hurt and thats why they are all covering because they don't know how she was hurt or maybe they do and she was shot by someones gun but they dont know whose.?

I think that is very close to what happened.

 

[seeking truth]

I think that is very close to what happened.

I realize that this thread is about Chelsea, but in response to the thinking that all the Croslin "kids" and their mates were together when HaLeigh was hurt, how then do we explain Teresa and Annette's words and actions from the very beginning?

 

[LuLa]

I thought it was Chelsea..I just wasn't sure.

But remember the part when Misty says "It'll hurt two people" One person they care about and the other not so much?? Chelsea comments on how she doesn't give a damn about Ron. Misty said something about it not being Ron and Chelsea seemed confused when she said "It's not him?" When Misty told her to "think"...I think she was guiding Chelsea back toward the Tommy and Jo story.

JMO though

I vaguely remember this. Thanks for the reminder!