After re-reading the new AWs once again, I have come up with some new thoughts to address a few of the questions:
- FO, hair-conscious as he was (by several statements he made), shaved at least his head if not also his arms (by several accounts) either the night before or early that morning (at 4:20AM).
- He left alone - because of the above, he would not have wanted Michelle's hair to have been found.
- MT, following the plan, went to take selfies, which was likely not something she normally did - clearly part of the schedule.
- FD planned to kidnap Jennifer, or do a bloodless killing and take her body -- either way, to make it look like an abduction.
- In order to do the above, he surprised her from behind in the garage, restrained/overpowered her, perhaps with the pillow to stop her screams. He put a zip tie around her neck first perhaps, to get control, then around her arms, legs.
- Perhaps he was wearing a ski mask, and she didn't even know who he was, at least at first?
- If he assaulted her it was around this time. He had a harder time controlling her than he had expected - he thought he could overpower her more easily - so he grabbed something nearby - a hockey stick, something - or, a knife that he had with him - and then the scene became bloody - which he had NOT anticipated. (Think KB's murder, where it was harder than he thought it would be). Cut underwear could be at this point, or could be later back at 80MS (not getting into detail here; LE know more.)
- We know he didn't anticipate a bloody scene, as he didn't even bring paper towels or a pillow
- Cleanup was much more than he expected
- He put her in a bag - unconscious, and literally bleeding to death - and into her truck, along with his bike.
- Drove to park where the Tacoma was waiting
- Moved her and the bike to the Tacoma
- Cleaned her truck as well as he could in 20 min, jogged to the pond at the park while there to drop her phone to make it look like she was jogging there, and was abducted there. Set up her truck to leave lights on so someone would hopefully steal it.
- Drove to 80MS.
- Put on ponchos - one for him and one for MT. SINCE HE DIDN'T EXPECT THE SCENE AT NC to be so bloody, these were intended for what he did at 80MS and may have been stored there. Were these sold by MT's sister? Her sister sells plastic foot-coverings.
- Proceeded to, with MT's help, clean up car.
- Somehow prepared to bury or dissect (?) Wearing ponchos.
- Put her in bags <- THIS PART IS NOT CLEAR - or left her for KM somewhere
- Brought trash bags to Albany Ave
- Called KM on the ride while on Albany Ave to say it was done
- OR, to tell him WHERE TO GET THE BODY - FOR KM TO BURY?
- Or: Called KM, as part of an alibi that evening ("I was in Hartford all day!" - not knowing cameras caught him dumping evidence, and not expecting that evidence to ever be found.
The following day, he had done all he needed to do - everything was done on the 24th. Why? Because he expected to get his kids early that next day. He would not have had loose ends left to do.
Purse on floor at home:
If it were a handbag with upright handles, it would be less in the way -
with 5 kids' stuff to get ready for school in the morning - to leave it on the floor (which I'm sure was spotless). 5 lunches, backpacks, etc - that's a lot on the counters already.
She may have grabbed her wallet/license, phone, and keys, and left, with tea and granola bar ready for her return- in too much of a rush that morning to have them before she left.
She may have left the purse on the floor in an area not visible directly from the garage. Perhaps there were coats or backpacks over it.
FD might not have seen it and was afraid of leaving tracks around the house and needed to get out of there after using sink to wash blood off of him / splattered (on his face? He probably didn't care about blood that was elsewhere except that it might get on car seat.)
ETA: or more likely: he saw purse, but it didn't fit in with his abduction plan -
he took what he wanted from it already - it was just more stuff to get rid of, so he didn't need the purse.
Still working on all of these ideas. Will refine as I go along...