Debate Thread for Caylee is alive

[Katie526]

Bringing over Exit's post from that thread:

Thanks

 

[RR0004]

Ummmm, I didn't quote Casey.

But you're saying she said she had a miscarriage...as reported by friends. So again, I'll ask...since when has Casey told the truth to anyone?

 

[SeriouslySearching]

And it was said that it was around or ON July 2nd at that party she was at.

No. This is not what was stated on the thread by the person who was at the party and claims to have seen what happened. Also, from Amy's interview which was under oath to back up the statements Exit13 made on that thread.

No one said she had a miscarriage during that party!!

 

[Katie526]

But you're saying she said she had a miscarriage...as reported by friends. So again, I'll ask...since when has Casey told the truth to anyone?

She didn't say it. Her friends were with her, apparently.

 

[LiveLoveLaughLiza]

What if Casey was wearing her Grey Pants when she miscarried and they were in the trunk?

And it was said that it was around or ON July 2nd at that party she was at.

The party is on May 25th (on page 42 of recent docs). If it is even true, the miscarriage did not happen at the party, but prior….before.

She wore the gray pants, according to George on June 16th.

 

[Ladytazz]

Hmmm, I'll check. I could be wrong but I thought he said the party where they wore the Red White and Blue which was July 2nd.

That was the anything but clothes party, may 30th.

 

[LinasK]

She didn't say it. Her friends were with her, apparently.

Ummm, yeah she did. From what I read of the Brandon thread, she went in the bathroom at the party and threw a little fit at/about Brandon about the miscarriage and his rejection of her. Reread exit13's posts again.

 

[Katie526]

But you're saying she said she had a miscarriage...as reported by friends. So again, I'll ask...since when has Casey told the truth to anyone?

I don't believe I said the SHE said. Unless I'm losing it, I didn't state that.

Actually, I'll end this debate right now. If I find other information, I'll bring it in. I will not argue. I can take a post when I am wrong but I will not let you bait me.

 

[Katie526]

Ummm, yeah she did. From what I read of the Brandon thread, she went in the bathroom at the party and threw a little fit at/about Brandon about the miscarriage and his rejection of her. Reread exit13's posts again.

Okay, maybe I misread. But they DID mention the miscarriage. It really doesn't matter when she had it. I was simply saying "What if she had it while wearing her gray pants" and that's what was in the trunk.

 

[Elley Mae]

The miscarriage that was mentioned at the party was mentioned in past tense It was nothing more then Casey wanting attention again. I don't believe there was a miscarriage.

 

[Capri]

She didn't say it. Her friends were with her, apparently.

Do you mean that her friends were present and saw her have a miscarriage? Any link for that?

 

[treeseeker]

Okay, maybe I misread. But they DID mention the miscarriage. It really doesn't matter when she had it. I was simply saying "What if she had it while wearing her gray pants" and that's what was in the trunk.

Cindy said she washed the pants, which were in the back seat, I think, because they smelled. I honestly think, if they were in such a condition she would have flipped. Even if she was aware of a miscarriage, I really don't think she would have tried to wash them after that length of time.

 

[Katie526]

Cindy said she washed the pants, which were in the back seat, I think, because they smelled. I honestly think, if they were in such a condition she would have flipped. Even if she was aware of a miscarriage, I really don't think she would have tried to wash them after that length of time.

I guess so. I'll have to review more on this. I obviously missed dates somewhere.

 

[Capri]

The miscarriage that was mentioned at the party was mentioned in past tense It was nothing more then Casey wanting attention again. I don't believe there was a miscarriage.

draaaaama & sympathy, exactly

 

[trina133]

trina, that pic has been surfaced and floating around - was a little girl in a backyard with a hat on and sunglassess, I think....it was dissproved and I just did a search on the posts here looking for it - but after mucho time wasted, I can't find it - maybe someone else has the pic handy. It was way early in the case.

Thank you, I thought it was a recent one is why I asked.

 

[Fandy]

She has a miscarriage, takes her nasty pants off, stuffs them in the trunk, and leaves them there...then wears them again on June 16th....stuffs them back in the trunk until July 15th or so when her mother washes them?! This is what you are saying, correct?

uke:

 

[Angelonline]

Okay, maybe I misread. But they DID mention the miscarriage. It really doesn't matter when she had it. I was simply saying "What if she had it while wearing her gray pants" and that's what was in the trunk.

It would help you a lot with the dates and stuff if you read the interviews. Most of them are large print just under 300 pages, did not take me that long to read them all last night. If you don't have time for all, I suggest: AH, LA, JG, TL for starters. Very interesting reading and they clear up some questions that we have all had for awhile.

 

[Elley Mae]

Amy was at the party in her statement she said Casey "Claimed she hada miscarriage by Brandon and cried and disappeared in the bathroom for and hour and a half. Paleeeze.

 

[ThoughtElf]

I haven't read all the transcripts and I don't have the time too. ANYONE can lie to be in the spotlight. Not saying they are lying, but did you read the posts on Brandon thread that Casey may have had a miscarriage around July 2nd. Could that be what is in the trunk, could this be why she used a shovel (don't know that date).

Don't have time to read the transcripts, yet, they'd answer so many questions? As such a strong advocate for the Anthony's and Caylee, what could possibly be more important to MAKE TIME for? Perhaps you'd glean important details and evidence?

I have had 5 - yes 5 - miscarriages, and at no point would it have crossed my mind during any of them to put the clothes I was wearing at the time in my trunk.

 

[amethyst221]

It is not even a proven fact that Casey ever had a miscarriage at all, only that at a party she made a dramatic scene when she saw a particular "ex" and SAID that she did, sometime in the past, and that it was "his." It is no more than the grossest speculation to go from that to saying that she not only had a miscarriage, but decided to keep it and place it in her car trunk, or had on particular clothes when the event occurred, never washed them, and saved them to later put in her trunk to decompose or leave DNA, or maybe crawled into the trunk sometime after Caylee was "taken" and had the experience, etc.